
The film begins in a room filled with oversized juggling props where a magician dressed in eccentric attire enters with his assistant. The assistant, seeking comfort, sits in an armchair only to discover it conceals a bucket of water into which he falls, creating immediate comedic effect. The magician then produces a large empty cask, places it on a table, and proceeds to fill it with water from several pails, demonstrating his magical abilities through the impossible task of containing more water than the cask should physically hold. Throughout the performance, Méliès employs his signature substitution splices and other visual effects to create the illusion of magical transformation, with the water appearing and disappearing at will. The film concludes with further magical manipulations of the water and props, showcasing the technical wizardry that made Méliès famous while maintaining the comedic tone established by the assistant's mishap.

The film was shot in Méliès' custom-built studio with theatrical sets and lighting, using his signature substitution splice technique for the magical effects. The oversized props were created specifically for this film to enhance the visual comedy and magical transformations.
1903 was a pivotal year in early cinema, occurring just eight years after the Lumière brothers' first public screening in 1895. The film industry was transitioning from novelty to a legitimate entertainment medium, with filmmakers like Méliès, Edwin S. Porter, and the Lumière brothers each developing distinct approaches to the new art form. Méliès was establishing himself as the master of fantasy and trick films, while others focused on more realistic depictions. 1903 also saw the release of other significant films including Porter's 'The Great Train Robbery,' which would help establish narrative filmmaking in America. In France, the Pathé brothers were building their film empire, which would eventually dominate the global market. The film was created before the formation of formal studios or distribution networks, with filmmakers often handling all aspects of production, distribution, and exhibition themselves.
"Comical Conjuring" represents an important milestone in the development of cinematic comedy and special effects. As one of hundreds of short films Méliès produced during his career, it demonstrates his systematic approach to exploring the possibilities of the new medium. The film's combination of stage magic traditions with cinematic techniques helped establish a new form of entertainment that was neither purely theatrical nor purely documentary. Its influence can be seen in the development of both physical comedy and fantasy genres in cinema. The film also represents the international nature of early cinema, as Méliès' films were distributed worldwide and helped establish visual storytelling techniques that transcended language barriers.
The film was created during what many consider the peak of Méliès' creative period (1902-1904), when he was producing his most technically sophisticated and imaginative works. The glass studio in Montreuil allowed Méliès to control lighting precisely, essential for the multiple exposures and substitution splices used throughout the film. The water effects required careful timing and coordination, as each substitution splice had to be perfectly executed to maintain the illusion of continuous action. The oversized props were constructed in Méliès' workshop, where he maintained an extensive collection of theatrical equipment and set pieces. The film was likely shot in one or two takes, with the magical effects created through in-camera techniques rather than post-production editing, which was not yet developed. Méliès himself often performed in his films, and it's possible he plays the magician role, drawing on his years of experience as a stage performer at the Théâtre Robert-Houdin in Paris.
The cinematography in "Comical Conjuring" reflects Méliès' theatrical background, with the camera positioned as if from the perspective of a theater audience member watching a stage performance. The single, static camera position was typical of the era but also served Méliès' technical needs, as substitution splices and other effects required a consistent frame. The lighting in Méliès' glass studio was carefully controlled to ensure even illumination across the set, essential for the multiple exposures used to create the magical effects. The composition of each shot was meticulously planned, with the oversized props and actors positioned to maximize visual impact and clarity for the effects.
"Comical Conjuring" showcases several of Méliès' pioneering technical innovations, most notably the substitution splice technique, which he developed and perfected. This technique involved stopping the camera, changing elements in the frame, and then resuming filming to create the illusion of instantaneous transformation. The film also demonstrates Méliès' mastery of multiple exposures, allowing him to create effects that would not be possible with a single exposure. The use of oversized props and forced perspective shows Méliès' understanding of visual manipulation within the cinematic frame. The water effects required careful timing and coordination between the camera operator and performers to maintain the illusion of continuous action.
As was standard for films of 1903, "Comical Conjuring" was produced as a silent film with no synchronized soundtrack. During exhibition, the film would have been accompanied by live music, typically a pianist or small ensemble in theaters, or a phonograph recording in smaller venues. The musical accompaniment would have been selected to match the action on screen, with lively, whimsical music appropriate for the comedic and magical elements. Some exhibitors may have used sound effects, particularly for the water splashes, to enhance the viewing experience.
Contemporary critical reception for individual Méliès films is difficult to document, as film criticism as we know it today did not exist in 1903. However, Méliès' films were generally well-received by audiences and exhibitors for their entertainment value and technical innovation. Trade publications of the era noted the popularity of his magic films and their strong commercial appeal. Modern critics and film historians recognize "Comical Conjuring" as representative of Méliès' style and technique, though it is not considered among his most famous works like "A Trip to the Moon." Contemporary scholars appreciate the film for its demonstration of early special effects techniques and its role in the development of cinematic comedy.
Early audiences were reportedly delighted by Méliès' magic films, which offered a unique combination of familiar stage entertainment and novel cinematic effects. The combination of comedy and magical illusion proved particularly popular with viewers of all ages. The water gag and other physical comedy elements would have been easily understood and appreciated by audiences across different cultures and languages. Méliès' films were regularly featured in programs at fairgrounds, music halls, and the first dedicated movie theaters, where they attracted repeat viewers fascinated by the magical effects. Contemporary accounts suggest that audiences often returned multiple times to see his films, attempting to understand how the visual effects were achieved.
"Comical Conjuring" is among the fortunate Méliès films that have survived to the present day, though many of his works were lost due to neglect, destruction, or the decomposition of early nitrate film stock. The film exists in the archives of several institutions, including the Cinémathèque Française and the Museum of Modern Art. Some surviving copies show the hand-coloring that was applied to certain prints for special presentations. The film has been digitized as part of various Méliès restoration projects.