The Broken Violin

Plot

The fragment that survives of 'The Broken Violin' begins in a bustling bakery where the proprietor gives orders to his workers. Amid the daily operations, a young worker secretly retrieves a hidden violin and begins to play it, suggesting a hidden artistic passion beneath his humble exterior. The film then abruptly transitions to another location, possibly showing the consequences or continuation of this musical interlude, but the surviving print cuts off at this point. The title suggests the violin may have been broken as punishment for the worker's unauthorized performance, though this remains speculation due to the incomplete nature of the film. The narrative appears to explore themes of art versus labor and the suppression of creative expression in working-class environments.

Historical Background

1908 was a pivotal year in early cinema, marking the transition from novelty films to more sophisticated narrative storytelling. The film industry was rapidly professionalizing, with companies like Pathé and Gaumont dominating the market. Méliès, who had been a pioneer since the 1890s, was facing increasing competition and changing audience preferences. This period saw the rise of longer films and more complex narratives, moving away from the trick films and fantasy scenes that had made Méliès famous. The year also saw the beginning of the film d'art movement in France, which emphasized literary adaptations and more serious subject matter. 'The Broken Violin' appears to reflect this shift toward more realistic, socially conscious themes, even as it maintains Méliès's theatrical visual style.

Making Of

The production of 'The Broken Violin' took place in Méliès's famous glass studio in Montreuil, which allowed him to control lighting conditions precisely. The bakery set would have been constructed with the same theatrical attention to detail that characterized all of Méliès's productions. The young man playing the violin was likely one of Méliès's regular actors, possibly Jehanne d'Alcy or one of the other performers who frequently appeared in his films. The violin itself would have been a real instrument, as Méliès was known for using authentic props rather than theatrical substitutes. The film was probably shot in one or two takes, as editing was minimal in 1908. The transition to another location would have been achieved through a simple cut or possibly a dissolve, techniques Méliès had mastered by this period.

Visual Style

The surviving fragment shows Méliès's characteristic static camera placement, typical of early cinema before the development of more dynamic camera techniques. The shots are composed with theatrical precision, using the full frame to stage the action clearly. The bakery set would have been lit through the glass roof of Méliès's studio, creating even, naturalistic lighting that was unusual for the period. The camera work is straightforward and functional, serving the narrative rather than calling attention to itself. If the film included colored versions, these would have been applied by hand frame by frame in Méliès's workshop, a laborious process that created distinctive visual effects.

Innovations

While 'The Broken Violin' does not appear to showcase the elaborate special effects that made Méliès famous, it demonstrates his mastery of filmic storytelling within the technical limitations of 1908. The film likely used simple editing techniques such as cuts and possibly dissolves to move between locations. The production design of the bakery set represents Méliès's commitment to creating detailed, believable environments for his narratives. The film's survival as a fragment also highlights the technical challenges of film preservation from this era, as early nitrate film stock was highly unstable and prone to deterioration.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Broken Violin' would have been accompanied by live music during exhibition. The choice of musical accompaniment would have been left to individual theater musicians or pianists, though Méliès sometimes provided suggested music cues in his film catalogs. Given the film's title and the presence of a violin in the story, it's likely that violin music would have featured prominently in the live accompaniment. The musical score would have been improvisational or drawn from popular classical pieces of the period, tailored to enhance the emotional content of each scene.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening scene in the bakery showing the daily operations and hierarchy of the workplace
• The moment when the young worker reveals his hidden violin and begins to play, suggesting his secret artistic nature

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of 'The Broken Violin' are difficult to locate due to the fragmentary nature of the film's survival and the limited film criticism of the period. Méliès's films from 1908 generally received mixed reviews, with some critics feeling his style was becoming dated compared to newer filmmakers. However, Méliès still had a loyal audience, particularly in France and the United States. Modern critics and film historians can only speculate on the film's original reception based on the surviving fragment and Méliès's other works from this period. The film is now primarily of interest to Méliès scholars and early cinema specialists as an example of his lesser-known realistic works.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception data for specific 1908 films is virtually non-existent, as systematic audience research was not conducted in this era. However, Méliès's films generally continued to find audiences in 1908, particularly in venues that programmed variety-style entertainment. The combination of a realistic setting with the promise of musical performance would have appealed to audiences looking for both familiarity and entertainment. The fragmentary nature of the surviving print means we cannot know how original audiences responded to the complete narrative, particularly the resolution suggested by the title.

You Might Also Like