Alice Solves the Puzzle

Plot

In this installment of Disney's Alice Comedies series, young Alice and her animated cat companion Julius are enjoying a day at the seashore when they encounter the villainous Pete. Pete, determined to steal Alice's crossword puzzle, resorts to trickery by getting Julius intoxicated. As Julius struggles with drunkenness, Pete attempts to make off with the puzzle, forcing Alice to try to protect her prized possession. The situation becomes increasingly desperate as Julius must overcome his inebriated state to come to Alice's rescue and confront Pete. The film combines live-action footage of Alice with animated sequences featuring Julius and Pete, culminating in a comedic battle of wits and physical comedy.

Historical Background

1925 was a pivotal year in animation history, occurring during the silent film era's peak and just before the transition to sound. The animation industry was still in its infancy, with most studios producing short subjects as theater fillers. Disney's Alice Comedies represented an innovative approach by combining live-action with animation, a technique that set them apart from competitors like Fleischer Studios and Pat Sullivan's Felix the Cat cartoons. The mid-1920s saw the rise of consumer culture in America, with new fads like crossword puzzles capturing public attention. This film reflects that cultural moment while also demonstrating Disney's early understanding of incorporating contemporary trends into entertainment. The studio was still operating on a shoestring budget in their first Hollywood location, and each successful short was crucial for their survival. This period also saw the development of many animation techniques that would later become industry standards, including improved character animation and more sophisticated storytelling.

Making Of

The production of 'Alice Solves the Puzzle' followed the established formula of the Alice Comedies series, which Walt Disney and Ub Iwerks developed after moving to Hollywood. The filming process was labor-intensive, requiring precise coordination between the live-action filming and subsequent animation. Margie Gay, as Alice, would perform her scenes against a neutral backdrop, often having to interact with invisible animated characters that would be added later. The animation team, led by Ub Iwerks, would then create the animated sequences around her performance. The drunkenness of Julius was conveyed through animation techniques including wavering lines, exaggerated movements, and distorted perspectives. The crossword puzzle element was chosen specifically because it was a cultural phenomenon at the time, making the film more relatable to contemporary audiences. Production was rushed as Disney was under pressure to deliver a new short every few weeks to meet distributor requirements, often working 16-hour days to complete each film on schedule.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'Alice Solves the Puzzle' employed the innovative technique of combining live-action footage with traditional cel animation. The live-action segments featuring Margie Gay were shot on black and white film using standard cameras of the era, with careful attention to lighting and composition to facilitate the later integration of animated elements. The animated sequences were created using cel animation on paper, then photographed onto film using rostrum cameras. The technical challenge of seamlessly integrating these two different media required precise matching of perspectives and movements. The film uses visual techniques like forced perspective and careful framing to create the illusion that Alice and the animated characters exist in the same space. The cinematography also incorporates early special effects techniques, such as matte shots and multiple exposures, to enhance the interaction between live-action and animated elements. The visual style reflects the aesthetic of mid-1920s animation, with bold lines, exaggerated expressions, and fluid motion that was becoming increasingly sophisticated.

Innovations

This short film demonstrated several important technical innovations for its time, particularly in the integration of live-action and animation. Disney's team developed techniques for matching the perspective and scale between live-action footage and animated characters, creating a more convincing illusion of interaction. The animation of Julius's drunken state showcased increasingly sophisticated character animation techniques, with fluid movement and expressive gestures that conveyed emotion without dialogue. The film also demonstrated improved continuity between scenes and more refined timing in the animation. The production process involved careful planning and coordination between the live-action filming unit and the animation team, requiring innovative approaches to production workflow. Disney's experimentation with combining different media in these shorts would influence future developments in special effects and animation techniques. The series also contributed to the development of character animation principles that would later be codified as the '12 basic principles of animation' at Disney.

Music

As a silent film from 1925, 'Alice Solves the Puzzle' did not have a synchronized soundtrack. In theaters, the film would have been accompanied by live musical performance, typically a pianist or small orchestra. The musical accompaniment would have been selected from standard silent film libraries or improvised by the musician to match the on-screen action. The tempo and mood of the music would change to reflect the different scenes - playful during the beach scenes, tense during Pete's appearance, and frantic during the chase sequences. Some larger theaters might have used compiled cue sheets that suggested appropriate musical pieces for different moments in the film. The lack of synchronized sound meant that visual storytelling had to carry the entire narrative, with exaggerated gestures and expressions conveying emotions and plot points. The experience of viewing this film today often involves adding period-appropriate musical accompaniment to recreate the original theatrical experience.

Memorable Scenes

• The sequence where Julius becomes drunk, with wobbly animation and distorted perspective conveying his inebriated state through purely visual means
• The climactic confrontation between the sobered-up Julius and Pete as they battle over the crossword puzzle
• The opening beach scene establishing the playful dynamic between Alice and Julius

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of Alice Comedies in trade publications like Variety and The Moving Picture World were generally positive, praising the series for its innovative blend of live-action and animation. Critics noted the quality of the animation and the charm of the interactions between the live-action Alice and her animated companions. The series was often mentioned as one of the higher-quality cartoon series being produced at the time. Modern film historians and animation scholars view these shorts as crucial stepping stones in Disney's development, showing the evolution of Walt Disney's storytelling techniques and the studio's technical capabilities. Animation historians particularly note the series' importance in developing character animation techniques that would later be refined in Mickey Mouse cartoons. While not as celebrated as Disney's later works, these shorts are recognized as important artifacts in animation history and studied for their technical innovations and their role in establishing Disney's early success.

What Audiences Thought

The Alice Comedies were popular with theater audiences of the mid-1920s, who enjoyed the novelty of the live-action/animation combination. Children were particularly drawn to Alice's adventures with her animated friends, while adults appreciated the clever visual gags and contemporary references like the crossword puzzle theme. The series helped establish Disney's reputation for producing quality entertainment that appealed to family audiences. Theater owners reported good attendance for programs featuring Alice Comedies, and the series was successful enough to run for four years and produce over 50 shorts. Audience letters and feedback from the period suggest that viewers particularly enjoyed the character of Julius the cat and the recurring villain Pete. The series' popularity helped Disney secure better distribution deals and eventually move to more sophisticated productions. Modern audiences viewing these shorts often express fascination with the early animation techniques and the historical significance of seeing Disney's early work before Mickey Mouse.

You Might Also Like