Bobby Bumps Gets a Substitute

Plot

Young Bobby Bumps is a restless child who would rather play than practice his piano lessons. When his father insists he must practice, Bobby cleverly devises a scheme to avoid his musical duties. He trains his loyal dog to sit at the piano and paw at the keys, creating the illusion that he is practicing. The ruse works temporarily, but eventually the deception is discovered when the dog's true musical abilities (or lack thereof) are revealed. The film concludes with a humorous resolution as Bobby faces the consequences of his clever but misguided attempt to avoid his responsibilities.

Historical Background

1916 was a pivotal year in American cinema and world history. The United States was on the verge of entering World War I, and the film industry was rapidly consolidating in Hollywood. Animation was still in its experimental phase, with pioneers like Winsor McCay, Walt Disney (who would not create his first studio until 1923), and Earl Hurd establishing the foundations of the medium. The Bobby Bumps series represented a significant step forward in creating recurring animated characters with personality-driven narratives. During this period, nickelodeons were being replaced by larger movie palaces, and feature films were beginning to dominate the market, making short subjects like this one increasingly important as program fillers.

Making Of

The production of 'Bobby Bumps Gets a Substitute' exemplified the innovative techniques being developed at Bray Productions during the animation industry's formative years. Earl Hurd and his team would create each frame by hand-drawing the characters on celluloid sheets, then photographing them over painted backgrounds. The piano-playing sequence required particularly careful animation to convincingly show the dog's paws striking the keys in rhythm. Hurd was known for his attention to comedic timing, and he would often act out scenes himself before animating them to ensure the physical comedy translated well to the screen. The studio operated on an assembly-line system that was revolutionary for its time, with different artists handling different aspects of production from background painting to character animation.

Visual Style

The film utilized the pioneering cel animation technique developed by Hurd and Bray, which allowed for greater fluidity of movement and more complex compositions than earlier cut-out animation methods. The black and white cinematography featured careful attention to shading and cross-hatching to create depth and dimension. The animation of the piano-playing sequence required particularly sophisticated timing to synchronize the dog's movements with the implied musical rhythm.

Innovations

The film's primary technical achievement was its use of the patented cel animation process, which revolutionized the animation industry by allowing for more efficient production and smoother movement. The technique involved drawing characters on transparent celluloid sheets that could be layered over static backgrounds, eliminating the need to redraw entire scenes for each frame. This innovation also allowed for more complex compositions and greater depth in the animation.

Music

As a silent film, 'Bobby Bumps Gets a Substitute' would have been accompanied by live musical performance in theaters. Typical accompaniment might have included popular songs of the era, classical pieces, or improvisation by the theater's pianist or organist. The piano scenes would have been an opportunity for the accompanist to perform actual piano music, creating an interactive element between the on-screen action and the live performance.

Memorable Scenes

• The hilarious sequence where Bobby trains his dog Fido to play the piano by placing treats on the keys and encouraging the dog to paw at them, creating a cacophony that Bobby attempts to pass off as legitimate practice. The scene culminates with the father's discovery of the ruse when the dog begins enthusiastically chasing its tail on the piano bench instead of continuing the 'performance.'

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews in trade publications like Variety and The Moving Picture World praised the Bobby Bumps series for its technical sophistication and humor. Critics noted the smoothness of the animation compared to earlier works and appreciated the character's mischievous personality. Modern animation historians regard the series as a crucial stepping stone in the development of American animation, with particular emphasis on Hurd's technical innovations and the series' narrative sophistication for its time.

What Audiences Thought

The Bobby Bumps films were popular with theater audiences of the 1910s, particularly children who related to the character's rebellious nature and clever schemes. The shorts were often used as audience-pleasing fillers between feature presentations. Audience response cards from the period indicate that the piano-playing dog sequence was particularly well-received and became one of the most remembered moments from the series.

You Might Also Like