Brothers

Plot

Brüder depicts the brutal reality of Hamburg dockworkers in 1896, who endure grueling labor for meager wages while living in squalid conditions. When their exploitation becomes unbearable, the workers organize a massive strike to demand better treatment and fair compensation. The conflict becomes deeply personal when one of the strikers discovers that his own brother serves as a policeman tasked with suppressing the labor uprising. The film portrays the violent clashes between workers and authorities, showing the human cost of industrial capitalism while highlighting the solidarity among the working class. Though set in the 19th century, the story resonated strongly with contemporary audiences facing similar struggles during the economic turmoil of the late 1920s.

Historical Background

Brüder was produced during the final years of the Weimar Republic, a period marked by severe economic depression, political polarization, and social unrest in Germany. The Great Depression had devastated the German economy, leading to mass unemployment and widespread poverty that mirrored the conditions depicted in the film's 1896 setting. The late 1920s saw intense labor conflicts across Germany, with strikes and worker demonstrations becoming increasingly common. The film's release coincided with the rise of both communist and Nazi movements, both of which sought to appeal to working-class discontent. Hochbaum's sympathetic portrayal of labor struggle reflected the growing social consciousness in German cinema, which had begun addressing contemporary issues rather than focusing solely on entertainment. The film emerged as part of the 'New Objectivity' movement in German arts, which rejected romanticism in favor of stark, realistic depictions of modern life.

Making Of

Werner Hochbaum approached Brüder with a revolutionary vision for German cinema, seeking to create what he called 'fictional documentary' that would expose social injustices. He spent months researching the 1896 Hamburg dockworkers' strike, interviewing former strikers and their families to ensure historical accuracy. The production faced numerous obstacles, including police surveillance during filming in the Hamburg docks and threats from local authorities who viewed the project as subversive. Hochbaum insisted on using non-professional actors from Hamburg's working-class districts, believing they could better convey the authentic struggles of the characters. The cinematography employed handheld cameras and natural lighting techniques that were innovative for the time, creating a gritty, realistic atmosphere that distinguished the film from more polished studio productions of the era.

Visual Style

The cinematography of Brüder, led by cinematographer Emil Schünemann, employed groundbreaking techniques that blurred the line between documentary and narrative cinema. Schünemann used handheld cameras to create a sense of immediacy and intimacy during the dockwork and strike sequences, allowing viewers to feel as if they were witnessing actual events. The film utilized natural lighting whenever possible, particularly in the outdoor dockyard scenes, to enhance the gritty realism of the working environment. High-contrast lighting emphasized the harsh conditions of the workers' lives, while carefully composed shots highlighted the dignity and solidarity of the laborers. The camera work incorporated dynamic angles and movements during confrontation scenes, creating tension and emotional impact. The film also made innovative use of location shooting, avoiding the artificial look of studio productions and capturing the authentic atmosphere of Hamburg's working-class districts.

Innovations

Brüder achieved several technical innovations that advanced the language of social realist cinema. The film pioneered the use of location shooting for narrative features in Germany, moving away from the studio-bound productions that dominated the era. Hochbaum developed a hybrid approach combining documentary footage with staged scenes, creating a seamless blend that enhanced the film's authenticity. The production employed lightweight cameras that allowed for greater mobility during filming in the cramped dockyard spaces. The film also experimented with montage techniques influenced by Soviet cinema, using rapid cuts during strike sequences to create emotional and political impact. The technical crew developed new methods for filming in challenging industrial environments, dealing with issues like weather, lighting, and the movement of ships and machinery. These technical achievements allowed the film to capture working-class reality with unprecedented immediacy and authenticity.

Music

As a silent film, Brüder featured no recorded dialogue or synchronized music score. However, the film was accompanied by live musical performances during its theatrical run, typically consisting of labor songs and revolutionary anthems performed by local musicians or union choirs. The musical selections varied by venue and audience, with leftist theaters often featuring workers' songs like 'The Internationale' and 'Solidaritätslied.' In more conventional cinemas, classical pieces were sometimes used, though this created a dissonance with the film's working-class themes. The absence of a formal soundtrack allowed the visual storytelling to stand on its own, with the film's powerful imagery carrying the emotional weight of the narrative. The silence actually enhanced the documentary feel of many scenes, making the labor struggle appear more immediate and authentic.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence showing dockworkers struggling under heavy crates in the pre-dawn light, establishing the physical toll of their labor
• The tense confrontation scene where the two brothers meet on opposite sides of the picket line, their uniforms and clothing symbolizing their divided loyalties
• The mass meeting scene where workers vote to strike, with faces illuminated by candlelight showing determination and hope
• The violent police crackdown on peaceful strikers, filmed with handheld cameras to create chaotic, documentary-like immediacy
• The final scene showing workers returning to work with small gains, suggesting both victory and the continuing nature of their struggle

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised Brüder for its uncompromising realism and social consciousness, with many noting its departure from typical German cinema of the period. The film received particularly positive reviews in left-wing publications like Die Rote Fahne and the Arbeiter-Illustrierte-Zeitung, which hailed it as 'the voice of the working class in cinema.' More conservative critics expressed concern about the film's political message, with some accusing it of communist propaganda. International critics, especially in France and the Soviet Union, recognized the film as a significant contribution to the emerging genre of social realist cinema. Modern film historians have reassessed Brüder as an important work that prefigured many developments in documentary and realist filmmaking, with particular attention paid to its innovative visual techniques and authentic portrayal of working-class life.

What Audiences Thought

Brüder found its most enthusiastic audience among working-class viewers and leftist intellectuals in Germany, who recognized their own struggles reflected in the film's depiction of exploitation and resistance. The film generated significant discussion in labor unions and workers' cultural organizations, where it was often screened as part of political education programs. Middle-class audiences were more divided in their reactions, with some praising the film's artistic merits while others found its political message unsettling. The film's limited distribution due to official disapproval meant that many Germans never had the opportunity to see it during its initial run. Among those who did view it, the film sparked intense debate about labor relations and social justice, with screenings sometimes followed by heated discussions about the issues raised. The film's impact on audiences was such that it was frequently referenced in contemporary labor disputes, with strikers adopting the film's themes of solidarity and resistance.

You Might Also Like