Demolishing and Building Up the Star Theatre

Plot

This groundbreaking documentary short film captures the complete demolition of New York City's Star Theatre over a one-month period, compressed into approximately one minute of screen time through innovative time-lapse photography. The film begins with the intact theatre building and systematically shows each stage of its destruction, from the removal of decorative elements to the gradual collapse of walls and final clearing of the site. The reverse sequence then shows the construction of a new building on the same location, creating a complete cycle of destruction and rebirth. The camera remains fixed in one position throughout, providing a consistent perspective that emphasizes the dramatic transformation of the urban landscape. This pioneering work serves as both a documentary record of a specific architectural loss and a meditation on the constant evolution of city life.

Historical Background

The film was created during a period of rapid transformation in New York City, when many 19th-century buildings were being replaced by modern structures. The early 1900s marked the height of the City Beautiful movement and urban redevelopment. This was also the dawn of cinema as a medium, with filmmakers experimenting with new techniques and possibilities. The Star Theatre itself was a significant cultural institution that had hosted many famous productions, and its demolition marked the end of an era in New York theatrical history. The film captures this moment of transition between old and new New York, documenting the city's evolution at a time when photography and motion pictures were becoming important tools for recording history.

Making Of

Frederick S. Armitage, working for the American Mutoscope and Biograph Company, conceived this project as a way to demonstrate the potential of motion pictures for documenting change over time. The technical challenges were significant - Armitage had to ensure the camera remained in exactly the same position for each day's shot, requiring careful marking and setup. The filming took place during April-May 1901, with Armitage visiting the site regularly to capture each phase of demolition. The Biograph Company was known for its technical innovations, and this film was part of their effort to showcase what motion pictures could do beyond simple entertainment. The film was likely processed at Biograph's facilities at 841 Broadway, just blocks from the demolition site.

Visual Style

The cinematography is characterized by a fixed camera position providing a consistent viewpoint of the demolition site. The use of time-lapse photography creates a staccato rhythm as the building gradually disappears. The 68mm film stock used by Biograph provided exceptional clarity and detail for the period. The composition carefully frames the theatre while including surrounding streets and buildings, giving context to the demolition. The lighting varies naturally throughout the sequence, reflecting the different times of day when filming occurred. The reverse sequence showing construction creates a surreal effect of rebuilding, demonstrating early understanding of cinematic manipulation.

Innovations

Pioneering use of time-lapse photography in cinema, innovative use of reverse motion to show construction, exceptional use of 68mm film format for maximum detail, early example of documentary filmmaking, technical precision in maintaining consistent camera position over multiple days, demonstration of cinema's potential for recording change over time.

Music

Silent film - no original soundtrack. In early exhibitions, it would have been accompanied by live piano or organ music typical of the period. Modern screenings often feature period-appropriate music or specially composed scores.

Memorable Scenes

• The complete sequence of the Star Theatre gradually disappearing frame by frame, creating a ghostly effect as the building dissolves before the viewer's eyes, culminating in an empty lot where once stood a grand theatre

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception is difficult to document due to limited film journalism in 1901, but trade publications noted the film's technical innovation. Modern critics and film historians universally recognize it as a pioneering work in documentary cinema and time-lapse photography. The film is frequently cited in film history texts as an early example of cinema's documentary potential. Critics today praise its simplicity, technical achievement, and historical importance. The Library of Congress selected it for preservation in the National Film Registry, recognizing its cultural, historical, and aesthetic significance.

What Audiences Thought

Early 1900s audiences were fascinated by the film's ability to compress a month-long process into seconds of viewing time. The novelty of seeing time accelerated was a major attraction, and the film was popular in vaudeville programs and early cinema exhibitions. Modern audiences viewing the film in archives or online often express wonder at both the technical achievement and the glimpse it provides into turn-of-the-century New York. The film continues to captivate viewers with its simple yet powerful demonstration of change and transformation.

You Might Also Like