Dinah
"The Mills Brothers Sing 'Dinah' with the Bouncing Ball"
Plot
In this delightful 1933 Screen Song cartoon, The Mills Brothers perform their hit rendition of 'Dinah' while animated animals enthusiastically work together to load cargo onto a ship named 'Dinah Lee'. The bouncing ball guides viewers through the song as various creatures - including elephants, monkeys, and other zoo animals - use their unique abilities to efficiently pack the vessel. As the ship sets sail, the animals continue their musical celebration aboard the deck, creating a joyful maritime adventure synchronized perfectly with The Mills Brothers' smooth harmonies. The cartoon combines live-action footage of The Mills Brothers' performance with whimsical animation, showcasing the innovative techniques Fleischer Studios was pioneering during the early sound era.
Director
About the Production
This was part of the Screen Songs series that combined popular music with animation. The production used early sound synchronization techniques and the innovative bouncing ball system that encouraged audience participation. The Mills Brothers' performance was filmed live and then integrated with the animated segments, a technically challenging process for the era.
Historical Background
Released in 1933 during the depths of the Great Depression, 'Dinah' emerged during a transformative period in American entertainment. The early 1930s saw the rapid maturation of sound technology in cinema, with animation studios racing to capitalize on the new possibilities. Fleischer Studios, operating from New York rather than Hollywood, developed a distinctive style that reflected urban American culture. This was also a significant period for African American performers in mainstream entertainment, with The Mills Brothers representing a breakthrough in racial integration of popular media. The Screen Songs series itself was an innovative response to the movie industry's need for engaging short content that could enhance the theatrical experience during economically challenging times.
Why This Film Matters
This cartoon holds cultural importance as an early example of racial integration in mainstream animation, featuring The Mills Brothers at a time when African American performers were rarely given prominent roles in white-produced entertainment. The Screen Songs series itself helped establish the music video format decades before MTV, combining popular music with visual storytelling. The bouncing ball technique pioneered by Fleischer Studios became an enduring educational tool, teaching generations of children to read through synchronized text and music. The film also represents an important moment in the history of animation, showcasing the transition from silent to sound cartoons and the development of techniques that would become standard in the industry.
Making Of
The production of 'Dinah' represented a significant technical achievement in early sound animation. The Mills Brothers were filmed performing the song using a sound-on-film process, and their audio track was then synchronized with the animated sequences. The bouncing ball animation required precise timing to match the syllables of the lyrics, a process that involved animators working closely with sound engineers. The Fleischer Studios team, led by director Dave Fleischer, employed their patented rotoscoping techniques for some elements, though most of the animation was traditionally hand-drawn. The integration of live-action footage of The Mills Brothers with the cartoon animals was particularly innovative for 1933, requiring careful matte work and compositing techniques that were still in their infancy.
Visual Style
The visual style of 'Dinah' exemplifies the rubber hose animation technique dominant in the early 1930s, characterized by fluid, boneless character movements and exaggerated physical comedy. The cinematography combines traditional cel animation with live-action footage of The Mills Brothers, requiring careful matching of visual styles. The color palette, though limited by the technology of the era, uses bold contrasts to create visual interest. The bouncing ball itself was animated with precise timing to match musical beats, demonstrating the technical sophistication of Fleischer Studios' animation team.
Innovations
The film's most significant technical achievement was the seamless integration of live-action musical performance with animated sequences, a process that required pioneering work in sound synchronization and visual effects. The bouncing ball animation system, patented by Max Fleischer, represented an innovative approach to educational entertainment, using visual cues to help audiences follow song lyrics. The production also demonstrated advanced techniques in multi-layered sound recording, capturing The Mills Brothers' complex harmonies with clarity that was impressive for the era. The compositing of live-action and animated elements required careful matte work that pushed the boundaries of available technology in 1933.
Music
The soundtrack features The Mills Brothers' performance of 'Dinah', arranged in their distinctive four-part harmony style that imitated instrumental sounds. The recording showcases their innovative approach to vocal jazz, with Donald, Harry, and Herbert Mills creating a rich, layered sound that was revolutionary for its time. The musical arrangement includes their signature technique of using their voices to mimic brass instruments, particularly evident in their interpretation of this jazz standard. The sound quality represents the state-of-the-art recording technology available in 1933, captured using the sound-on-film process rather than the earlier sound-on-disc systems.
Famous Quotes
"Dinah, is there anyone finer?" - Lyrics from the title song
"Dinah, is there anyone sweeter?" - Lyrics from the title song
"Dinah, is there anyone completer?" - Lyrics from the title song
Memorable Scenes
- The opening sequence featuring The Mills Brothers performing in their signature style
- The animated animals working together to load the cargo ship with synchronized movements
- The bouncing ball guiding viewers through the lyrics as the ship sets sail
- The finale with animals celebrating aboard the 'Dinah Lee' while The Mills Brothers' harmonies swell
Did You Know?
- This was one of the earliest Screen Songs to feature an African American musical group, reflecting the growing popularity of The Mills Brothers who had broken racial barriers in the music industry.
- The bouncing ball technique, invented by Max Fleischer, was patented in 1925 and became a signature element of the Screen Songs series.
- The Mills Brothers were one of the first African American groups to achieve mainstream success in the recording industry, signing with Brunswick Records in 1931.
- The song 'Dinah' was originally written by Harry Akst, Sam M. Lewis, and Joe Young in 1925 and had been recorded by numerous artists before The Mills Brothers' version.
- Fleischer Studios was one of the few animation studios operating in New York City during the 1930s, rather than Hollywood, giving their cartoons a distinct urban sensibility.
- The Screen Songs series ran from 1929 to 1938, producing over 60 cartoons featuring popular music of the era.
- The animation in this short showcases the rubber hose style popular in early 1930s animation, with characters having fluid, rubber-like movements.
- This cartoon was released during the Great Depression, when movie theaters relied on short subjects like this to attract audiences to double features.
- The Mills Brothers' unique vocal style, imitating musical instruments, was revolutionary and influenced countless vocal groups that followed.
- Paramount Pictures distributed Fleischer Studios' cartoons as part of their program of short subjects shown before feature films.
What Critics Said
Contemporary reviews in trade publications like Variety and The Film Daily praised the cartoon for its clever synchronization and the appeal of The Mills Brothers' performance. Critics noted the technical sophistication of combining live-action musical performance with animation, which was still relatively novel in 1933. The bouncing ball element was frequently mentioned as an engaging innovation that encouraged audience participation. Modern animation historians recognize the film as an important example of early sound animation and as a significant milestone in the representation of African American performers in mainstream cartoons.
What Audiences Thought
The cartoon was well-received by theater audiences in 1933, who enjoyed the sing-along format and The Mills Brothers' smooth harmonies. The Screen Songs series was particularly popular with family audiences, as the bouncing ball made it easy for children and adults to participate in the musical experience. During the Depression era, such uplifting and entertaining content provided welcome escape from economic hardships. The Mills Brothers' existing fan base likely contributed to the cartoon's success, as their recordings were already popular on radio and records.
Film Connections
Influenced By
- The earlier Talkartoons series by Fleischer Studios
- Disney's Silly Symphonies
- Vaudeville performance traditions
- Jazz and swing music culture
This Film Influenced
- Later Screen Songs in the series
- Warner Brothers' Merrie Melodies
- Modern music videos
- Educational sing-along programs
You Might Also Like
Film Restoration
The film has been preserved through various archives and is available through classic animation collections. Some versions exist in the public domain, ensuring its survival for future generations. The quality of surviving prints varies, with some showing the wear typical of films from this era.