Naughty But Mice

Plot

Herman, a sophisticated city mouse with a distinct James Cagney-esque personality and fast-talking mannerisms, leaves his urban lifestyle behind to visit his humble barn-dwelling cousins in the countryside. The cultural clash between Herman's street-smart, cynical worldview and his relatives' simple, pastoral existence creates a series of comedic misunderstandings and mishaps. Throughout the short, Herman attempts to impress his country cousins with tales of city life while simultaneously struggling to adapt to rural challenges like farm animals, farm equipment, and country customs. The narrative culminates in Herman learning that despite their differences, family bonds transcend urban-rural divides, though not without plenty of slapstick humor and witty banter along the way.

Historical Background

Released in 1947, during the golden age of American theatrical animation, 'Naughty But Mice' emerged in a period of significant transition for the animation industry. The post-WWII era saw major studios like Paramount investing heavily in animated shorts as theater attendance reached all-time highs. This film reflects the urbanization trends of 1940s America, when many city dwellers were reconnecting with rural roots or moving to suburbs. The gangster parody aspect also resonates with audiences who had grown up with Hollywood's classic gangster films of the 1930s. The cartoon's production coincided with the beginning of the Cold War, though its content remained focused on light entertainment rather than political themes. The animation industry itself was undergoing changes, with the rise of UPA studios introducing more modernist styles that would eventually challenge the traditional approach exemplified by Famous Studios.

Making Of

The production of 'Naughty But Mice' took place at Famous Studios' New York facility, where the animation team worked under the direction of Seymour Kneitel, a veteran animator who had previously worked with Walt Disney and the Fleischer brothers. The voice recording sessions featured Jack Mercer, who was simultaneously working on Popeye cartoons, requiring him to switch between the gruff, fast-talking Herman and the mumbling Popeye character. The animators studied James Cagney films extensively to perfect Herman's mannerisms and body language, incorporating his distinctive walk, hand gestures, and facial expressions. The storyboarding process emphasized the contrast between urban sophistication and rural simplicity, with gags designed to highlight Herman's fish-out-of-water predicaments. The animation team used the limited resources of the post-war period efficiently, focusing on character-driven comedy over elaborate background details.

Visual Style

The visual style of 'Naughty But Mice' employs the classic cel animation techniques dominant in the 1940s, with hand-drawn characters moving against painted backgrounds. The cinematography uses traditional animation camera movements including pans, zooms, and tracking shots to enhance the storytelling. Character animation emphasizes exaggerated expressions and fluid movements, particularly for Herman's gangster-inspired mannerisms. The visual contrast between the sleek, angular designs representing urban elements and the softer, more organic shapes of the countryside reinforces the thematic dichotomy. Color palettes shift between cool, sophisticated blues and grays for city scenes and warm, earthy tones for rural settings, creating visual narrative support. The animation follows the 12-frame-per-second standard of theatrical shorts of the era, with careful attention to timing and spacing for comedic effect.

Innovations

While 'Naughty But Mice' didn't introduce groundbreaking technical innovations, it demonstrates the refinement of existing animation techniques by the mid-1940s. The cartoon employs multiplane camera effects to create depth in certain scenes, particularly when establishing the contrast between urban and rural environments. The animation team utilized synchronized sound recording techniques that had become standard by this period, allowing for precise timing between dialogue, music, and visual action. Character animation shows advanced understanding of weight and momentum, particularly in the slapstick sequences. The production process involved the use of exposure sheets for timing coordination and the application of cel painting techniques that had been perfected over the previous two decades. The film represents the technical maturity of theatrical animation just before the industry would be disrupted by television's rise.

Music

The musical score for 'Naughty But Mice' was composed by Winston Sharples, Famous Studios' resident musical director who scored hundreds of their cartoons. The soundtrack features a lively orchestral score that incorporates jazz elements and swing rhythms, reflecting Herman's urban sophistication while adapting to rural scenes with more pastoral melodies. The music includes leitmotifs for different characters and situations, with Herman's theme featuring brass-heavy arrangements reminiscent of gangster film scores. Sound effects were created using traditional animation techniques, including foley work for footsteps, crashes, and comedic impacts. The voice work by Jack Mercer, Carl Meyer, and Sid Raymond was recorded using the standard audio equipment of the era, with post-production adding reverberation and other effects to enhance the theatrical presentation. The soundtrack balances dialogue, music, and effects according to the conventions of 1940s animated shorts.

Memorable Scenes

• Herman's arrival at the barn, where his slick city clothes and fast-talking immediately contrast with his cousins' simple overalls and slow speech
• The sequence where Herman attempts to 'improve' the farm using city methods, resulting in chaotic slapstick with farm equipment
• The climactic scene where Herman's city skills unexpectedly help solve a rural problem, bringing the family together

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception for 'Naughty But Mice' was generally positive, with animation trade publications praising Herman's character design and the effective parody elements. The Motion Picture Herald noted the cartoon's 'amusing character contrasts' and 'well-timed gags,' while Box Office Magazine highlighted its 'appealing animation style' and 'entertaining premise.' Modern animation historians recognize the short as a solid example of Famous Studios' work, though it's often overshadowed by more famous characters from the same studio. The cartoon is appreciated for its period-specific humor and as a representative sample of post-war theatrical animation standards. Some critics note that while the animation is competent, it lacks the innovation of contemporary work from studios like UPA or the timeless appeal of Disney's output.

What Audiences Thought

Theatrical audiences in 1947 generally responded well to 'Naughty But Mice,' finding humor in Herman's city slicker antics and the familiar urban-rural comedy dynamic. Children enjoyed the slapstick elements and cartoon violence, while adults appreciated the Hollywood gangster parody and sophisticated wordplay. The cartoon performed adequately as part of Paramount's theater programming, though it didn't generate the same level of audience enthusiasm as some more famous animated characters of the era. In later years, as the cartoon appeared in television reruns, it developed a modest cult following among animation enthusiasts who appreciated its period charm and Herman's distinctive personality. Modern audiences discovering the short through animation festivals or classic cartoon compilations often find it entertaining as a time capsule of 1940s animation style and humor.

You Might Also Like