The Sinking of the Lusitania

Plot

Winsor McCay's groundbreaking animated documentary depicts the tragic sinking of the RMS Lusitania on May 7, 1915, when a German U-boat torpedoed the passenger liner, killing 1,198 people including 128 Americans. The film begins with an introduction showing the majestic Lusitania departing New York harbor, followed by detailed animated sequences of the German submarine stalking and attacking the vessel. McCay painstakingly animates the torpedo strikes, the rapid listing of the ship, passengers scrambling to escape, and the final descent beneath the waves. The film concludes with powerful intertitles condemning the 'barbaric' German act and honoring the victims, serving as explicit wartime propaganda to galvanize American support for the Allied cause. Through his innovative animation techniques, McCay transforms this historical tragedy into a visceral, emotional experience that captures the horror and injustice of the attack.

Historical Background

The film was created during World War I, three years after the actual sinking of the Lusitania on May 7, 1915. The attack had been a major factor in turning American public opinion against Germany, though the U.S. didn't enter the war until 1917. By 1918, when the film was released, America was fully engaged in the war effort, and propaganda films were common tools for maintaining public support. The Lusitania sinking remained a powerful symbol of German 'barbarism' and was frequently referenced in recruitment posters and speeches. McCay's film tapped into this sentiment while also pushing the boundaries of what animation could achieve as an art form. The timing of its release in mid-1918 coincided with major Allied offensives and growing optimism about victory, making it part of the broader cultural mobilization for total war.

Making Of

Winsor McCay was already renowned for his pioneering animated works like 'Gertie the Dinosaur' when he undertook this ambitious project. He was deeply affected by the Lusitania tragedy and felt compelled to use his artistic skills to document it. McCay worked obsessively on the film, often spending 16 hours a day at his drawing board. He developed new animation techniques specifically for this project, including more sophisticated methods for depicting water movement and explosions. The production was extremely labor-intensive - McCay had to draw each individual frame, with complex scenes requiring multiple layers of animation. The smoke effects alone required hundreds of drawings to create realistic billowing and dispersal. McCay's attention to detail extended to researching the ship's architecture, the torpedo's trajectory, and even the types of lifeboats used. The film's patriotic intertitles were carefully crafted to maximize emotional impact and anti-German sentiment.

Visual Style

McCay employed innovative animation techniques that were groundbreaking for 1918. He used a layered approach with separate cels for different elements, allowing for more complex compositions. The animation featured unprecedented detail in depicting the ship's architecture, the torpedo's approach, and the chaos of the sinking. McCay developed new methods for creating realistic water effects, using multiple overlapping drawings to simulate waves and splashes. The smoke and explosion effects were particularly sophisticated, using carefully graduated drawings to create convincing billowing and dispersal patterns. The camera work included subtle pans and zooms that added dynamism to the scenes. McCay's attention to lighting and shadow created a dramatic, almost theatrical atmosphere that enhanced the emotional impact.

Innovations

The film represented numerous technical breakthroughs in animation. McCay's use of registration pegs to maintain consistency between frames was more sophisticated than previous systems. His technique for animating water involved creating multiple transparent layers that could be moved independently, creating realistic depth and movement. The explosion effects used carefully timed exposures and multiple drawings to create convincing blasts and debris. McCay also pioneered the use of detailed, realistic backgrounds in animation, moving away from the simplified settings common in earlier cartoons. The film's scale - with thousands of individual drawings for a 12-minute piece - set new standards for animation production. McCay's documentation of his process, including photographs of his work, provided valuable insights into early animation techniques.

Music

The film was originally silent, as was standard for 1918, but would have been accompanied by live musical performance in theaters. Typical screenings featured patriotic music, classical pieces, and original compositions arranged to match the on-screen action. The dramatic moments would have been underscored with somber classical pieces, while the introduction of the Lusitania might have featured triumphant music. Modern restorations have added period-appropriate scores that attempt to recreate the original theatrical experience. The intertitles themselves were designed to be read aloud by live narrators in some theaters, adding another layer to the presentation.

Memorable Scenes

• The majestic opening sequence showing the Lusitania departing New York Harbor, rendered in stunning detail with smoke billowing from its funnels
• The tense underwater sequence following the German U-boat as it stalks the civilian vessel, creating suspense through careful pacing and dramatic lighting
• The torpedo strike sequence, with multiple explosions depicted through rapidly changing drawings and brilliant flashes of white
• The chaotic sinking scene showing passengers scrambling for lifeboats as the ship lists dramatically, combining horror with technical virtuosity
• The final descent of the Lusitania beneath the waves, with bubbles and debris creating a haunting visual elegy for the victims

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics were stunned by the film's technical achievement and emotional power. The New York Times praised it as 'a remarkable work of art that moves the heart while it educates the mind.' Film journals of the era noted its unprecedented realism and detailed animation. Critics particularly admired McCay's ability to make animated water and smoke effects appear believable. Modern critics and animation historians consider it a masterpiece of early animation, with many ranking it among the most important animated films ever made. The film is frequently cited in animation histories as a turning point that demonstrated animation's potential beyond simple comedy. Its combination of technical innovation and emotional impact continues to be studied by film scholars and animators.

What Audiences Thought

The film was shown in theaters across the United States as part of war bond drives and patriotic rallies. Audiences were reportedly deeply moved by the realistic depiction of the tragedy, with many viewers expressing shock at the graphic nature of the animation. The film's effectiveness as propaganda was noted in contemporary reports, with some theaters reporting increased war bond sales following screenings. However, its serious tone and disturbing content made it less commercially successful than McCay's earlier, more lighthearted works. The 12-minute runtime and lack of traditional entertainment elements limited its appeal to general audiences seeking escapism during wartime. Despite this, it found appreciative audiences among those seeking to understand and process the realities of war.

You Might Also Like