Edward McNamara
Actor
About Edward McNamara
Edward James McNamara was a distinguished American character actor and singer whose career spanned the Broadway stage and the Golden Age of Hollywood. Born in Paterson, New Jersey, in 1884, he initially served as a police officer, where his powerful baritone voice earned him the nickname 'The Singing Policeman.' His life changed in 1914 when he was discovered by opera legend Madame Schumann-Heink, who introduced him to the world-renowned tenor Enrico Caruso. Caruso was so impressed by McNamara's 'natural organ' that he personally mentored him, making McNamara his only pupil. After years of touring the concert circuit, McNamara transitioned to Broadway in the 1920s and eventually Hollywood in the late 1920s and 1930s. He became a beloved fixture in the film industry, often cast as authoritative yet affable figures, and was a core member of the 'Irish Mafia' social circle alongside close friend James Cagney.
The Craft
On Screen
McNamara was known for his 'natural' acting style, often bringing a sense of grounded realism and warmth to his roles. His physical presence was described as 'rotund' and imposing, which made him a perfect fit for roles as police captains, judges, and working-class fathers. His performances were frequently punctuated by his booming, operatic baritone voice, which he used to great effect in both musical and dramatic contexts.
Milestones
- Discovered by Madame Schumann-Heink in 1914 while singing at a local festival
- Became the only vocal student ever personally taught by Enrico Caruso
- Toured the United States as a professional singer for six years with Schumann-Heink
- Made his Broadway debut in 1926
- Transitioned to Hollywood in 1929, appearing in nearly 20 films
- Became a founding member of the Hollywood 'Irish Mafia' social group
- Played a significant role in James Cagney's career as a close advisor and frequent co-star
Best Known For
Iconic Roles
Must-See Films
Accolades
Special Recognition
- Honorary member of the 'Irish Mafia' (Hollywood social elite)
- Member of The Players Club in Manhattan
- Member of the Dutch Treat Club since 1928
Working Relationships
Worked Often With
Studios
Why They Matter
Impact on Culture
Edward McNamara bridged the gap between the world of high opera and popular cinema. As the 'Singing Policeman,' he represented a unique American success story—a working-class officer who rose to international fame through raw talent. His presence in the 'Irish Mafia' helped solidify the cultural identity of Irish-American actors in Hollywood's Golden Age, influencing the way these characters were portrayed as both tough and deeply human.
Lasting Legacy
McNamara is remembered today as one of the most respected character actors of the 1930s and 40s. His legacy is preserved through his memorable supporting roles in classic films like 'Arsenic and Old Lace.' He is also cited in film history as a pivotal figure in the personal and professional life of James Cagney, often credited with keeping the star grounded during his rise to fame.
Who They Inspired
His transition from law enforcement to the arts served as an inspiration for other 'natural' actors. His mentorship under Caruso remains a unique footnote in music history, proving that operatic talent could find a successful home in the burgeoning medium of sound film.
Off Screen
McNamara was a lifelong bachelor who was deeply devoted to his craft and his social circle. He was famously close to James Cagney, serving as a traveling companion and confidant. In 1936, he was instrumental in helping Cagney find a retreat on Martha's Vineyard during the actor's legal battles with Warner Bros. He was known for his jovial personality and was a staple of the New York and Hollywood social scenes.
Education
Trained vocally by Enrico Caruso; attended local schools in Paterson, New Jersey.
Did You Know?
- He was a real-life police officer in Paterson, New Jersey, before becoming an actor.
- He was the only person Enrico Caruso ever agreed to teach.
- He died of a heart attack on a train while delivering racehorses to James Cagney.
- He was a key figure in the 'Irish Mafia,' a group that included Spencer Tracy and Frank McHugh.
- His nickname 'The Singing Policeman' followed him throughout his entire career.
- He was known for never taking show business too seriously, viewing it as a way to enjoy life with friends.
- He appeared in four films specifically because his friend James Cagney insisted on his casting.
In Their Own Words
Fine. What teacher? (His response to Caruso telling him he needed a teacher)
McNamara could have been one of the Metropolitan Opera's greatest stars... he was the perfect example of someone who could have had it all, but didn't want to pay the price. (James Cagney on McNamara)
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was Edward McNamara?
Edward McNamara was a former New Jersey police officer who became a celebrated Broadway actor and Hollywood character performer. He was famously the only vocal student of the legendary tenor Enrico Caruso.
What films is Edward McNamara best known for?
He is best known for his roles in 'Great Guy' (1936) alongside James Cagney and the classic comedy 'Arsenic and Old Lace' (1944), where he played a police sergeant.
When was Edward McNamara born and when did he die?
He was born on August 13, 1884, in Paterson, New Jersey, and passed away on November 10, 1944, in Boston, Massachusetts.
Was Edward McNamara really a policeman?
Yes, he served as a police officer in Paterson, New Jersey, where he was discovered singing while on duty, leading to his nickname 'The Singing Policeman.'
What was Edward McNamara's relationship with James Cagney?
McNamara was James Cagney's closest friend and frequent traveling companion. He was a member of Cagney's 'Irish Mafia' and appeared in several of Cagney's films.
Learn More
Films
1 film
