A Great Love
Plot
In this poignant silent drama, Kenneth Reynolds recounts to Nelly's daughter the tragic story of his great love for her mother Nelly. Kenneth and Nelly were deeply in love until the mysterious arrival of a stranger created a rift between them, leading Nelly to abandon Kenneth and run away with this new lover. The betrayal proved devastating for Nelly's father, who died from grief over his daughter's actions. Years later, Nelly returned with a child in tow, only to collapse and die in Kenneth's arms, leaving him to carry the burden of their tragic love story. The emotional weight of this tale moves Nelly's daughter to tears as Kenneth, now aged and reflective, shares the painful memories that have haunted him for decades.
About the Production
This film was produced during the early years of American cinema when the industry was rapidly establishing itself in California. The American Film Company was one of the early production houses that operated during the silent era. The film was shot on location in the burgeoning film community of Los Angeles, taking advantage of the favorable climate and diverse landscapes that attracted many early filmmakers to the region.
Historical Background
1916 was a pivotal year in world history and cinema. World War I was raging in Europe, though the United States had not yet entered the conflict. The film industry was undergoing massive changes, with Hollywood rapidly becoming the center of American film production. This was the year that Charlie Chaplin signed his groundbreaking contract with Mutual Film Corporation for $670,000, making him the highest-paid actor in the world. The feature film format was becoming more established, though most films were still under an hour long. The era also saw the development of more sophisticated film techniques and storytelling methods. 'A Great Love' was produced during this period of rapid artistic and technical evolution in cinema, reflecting the melodramatic tendencies that appealed to audiences of the time.
Why This Film Matters
While 'A Great Love' was not a groundbreaking or particularly influential film, it represents the type of melodramatic romance that was extremely popular with audiences during the silent era. The film's themes of tragic love, betrayal, and redemption were staples of early 20th-century storytelling both in literature and cinema. The fact that it was produced by the American Film Company, one of the early major studios, demonstrates the industrialization of film production that was occurring at the time. The film's existence, even though it is now lost, is part of the historical record of American cinema's development and the types of stories that resonated with audiences during the World War I era.
Making Of
The production of 'A Great Love' took place during a transformative period in American cinema when the industry was consolidating its move from the East Coast to California. Director Clifford S. Elfelt was part of the wave of filmmakers who established themselves in Los Angeles during this era. The film was shot on location in and around Los Angeles, taking advantage of the diverse scenery that California offered. The cast was assembled from the pool of regular actors working for the American Film Company, who often worked on multiple productions simultaneously. The film was likely shot in a matter of days, as was typical for productions of this length during the silent era. The emotional scenes required the actors to use exaggerated gestures and facial expressions to convey the story's dramatic elements, which was standard practice in silent film acting.
Visual Style
The cinematography for 'A Great Love' would have been typical of American films from 1916, utilizing stationary cameras with occasional movement through panning or tilting. The film would have been shot on 35mm black and white film stock, with lighting provided primarily by natural light supplemented by arc lamps when filming indoors. Close-ups would have been used selectively for emotional moments, particularly in the death scenes and emotional revelations. The visual storytelling would have relied on composition and staging to convey the narrative and emotional states of the characters, as was standard practice before the advent of sound cinema.
Innovations
No specific technical achievements are documented for 'A Great Love.' The film would have utilized the standard technology and techniques of 1916 American cinema production. The film was likely shot on standard 35mm film at the typical frame rate of 16-18 frames per second for silent films. The editing would have followed the continuity editing practices that were becoming standard in the industry, with clear narrative sequencing and logical scene transitions. The film represents the state of mainstream American filmmaking technology during the mid-1910s rather than pushing technical boundaries.
Music
As a silent film, 'A Great Love' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its theatrical run. The specific musical score is not documented, but it would have typically been provided by a theater organist or small ensemble. The music would have been selected to match the emotional tone of each scene, with romantic themes for the love scenes, dramatic music for the confrontations, and mournful melodies for the death scenes. Some theaters might have used cue sheets provided by the film's distributor, while others would have relied on the musicians' discretion to choose appropriate musical pieces.
Memorable Scenes
- The emotional climax where Kenneth recounts the story to Nelly's daughter, the death scene where Nelly dies in Kenneth's arms, the arrival of the mysterious stranger who drives the lovers apart, the revelation of Nelly's return with her child, the opening scene establishing the frame narrative of Kenneth telling the story
Did You Know?
- Director Clifford S. Elfelt was also known as Clifford S. Elfe and worked primarily as a director during the silent film era from 1915 to 1920.
- Hayward Mack, who played Kenneth Reynolds, was a prolific character actor who appeared in over 200 films between 1910 and 1930.
- Mina Cunard, who portrayed Nelly, was a popular leading lady in silent films and appeared in more than 80 films during her career.
- Vola Vale, who played Nelly's daughter, was discovered by director D.W. Griffith and worked as an actress for nearly two decades.
- The film was released during World War I, a time when melodramatic love stories with tragic elements were particularly popular with audiences seeking emotional escape.
- At 30 minutes, this was considered a feature-length film in 1916, as most films of the era were much shorter.
- The American Film Company, which produced this film, was also known as the Flying 'A' Studios and was one of the most prolific early film production companies.
- This film is now considered lost, as is the case with approximately 75% of American silent films.
- The film's themes of lost love and redemption were common in silent cinema, where visual storytelling had to convey complex emotions without dialogue.
What Critics Said
Contemporary critical reception for 'A Great Love' is not well-documented, as was common for many films of this era. Trade publications like Moving Picture World and Variety may have reviewed the film, but these reviews are not readily accessible in modern archives. The film was likely received as a competent melodrama that delivered the emotional experiences audiences expected from the romance genre. The performances of Hayward Mack and Mina Cunard were probably noted positively, as both were established actors with reputations for delivering reliable performances in dramatic roles.
What Audiences Thought
Audience reception for 'A Great Love' in 1916 is not specifically recorded, but the film's themes of tragic romance and moral consequences were popular with contemporary moviegoers. The story's emotional arc, following the pattern of love, betrayal, suffering, and redemption, would have resonated with audiences who attended films for both entertainment and emotional catharsis. The film's runtime of 30 minutes made it suitable for theater programs that typically included multiple short features. The presence of established actors like Hayward Mack and Mina Cunard would have been a draw for audiences familiar with their previous work.
Film Connections
Influenced By
- Victorian literature
- Stage melodrama
- Contemporary romantic fiction
- Earlier silent film melodramas
You Might Also Like
Film Restoration
Lost film - No known copies of 'A Great Love' (1916) exist in any film archives or private collections. The film is considered one of the approximately 75% of American silent films that have been lost due to nitrate film decomposition, improper storage, or neglect during the transition to sound cinema.