A Lucky Strike

Plot

Bill, a wealthy miner living out West, grows lonely and decides to advertise in an Eastern newspaper for a wife. Two young women, Nellie and Eleanor, see his advertisement and decide to play a prank by responding with a romantic letter, though they have no intention of marrying him. When Bill receives their enthusiastic response, he believes it's genuine and travels East to meet his prospective bride. Upon arrival, the mischievous women panic and convince their cook to pose as the letter writer, leading to a series of comedic misunderstandings and farcical situations as Bill tries to court the disguised cook. The situation escalates as the real women attempt to maintain their ruse while Bill grows increasingly confused by the cook's unexpected behavior and appearance.

Historical Background

1915 was a pivotal year in cinema history, marking the transition from short films to feature-length movies as the industry standard. D.W. Griffith's 'The Birth of a Nation' had been released earlier that year, demonstrating the artistic and commercial potential of longer films. World War I was raging in Europe, though the United States would not enter until 1917. The film industry was rapidly consolidating, with studios like Lubin competing against emerging giants such as Paramount and Fox. This period saw the establishment of Hollywood as the center of American film production, though Lubin remained based in Pennsylvania. The technology of filmmaking was evolving, with cameras becoming more portable and lighting techniques improving, allowing for more sophisticated visual storytelling even in short comedies.

Making Of

The production of 'A Lucky Strike' was typical of the factory-like approach to filmmaking at Lubin Studios in the mid-1910s. The studio, founded by Siegmund Lubin, was known for churning out numerous short comedies each month to meet the insatiable demand of nickelodeon theaters. Arthur Hotaling, who directed this film, was one of Lubin's reliable directors who could quickly turn out entertaining shorts. The casting of Oliver Hardy shows the studio's eye for talent, though Hardy wouldn't achieve true stardom until his partnership with Stan Laurel began in the 1920s. The film was likely shot in just a few days on the studio's backlot, with simple sets representing both Western mining country and Eastern domestic settings. The comedy relied heavily on physical gags and exaggerated expressions, as was standard for silent comedies of this period.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'A Lucky Strike' would have been typical of 1915 studio productions, utilizing stationary cameras with basic movement techniques. The film likely employed simple lighting setups, primarily using natural light from studio skylights supplemented by artificial lighting when needed. Visual composition would have followed the theatrical tradition of framing actors centrally, with medium shots dominating the narrative sequences and wider shots establishing settings. The cinematographer would have focused on capturing the physical comedy clearly, ensuring that gags and facial expressions were visible to audiences. The black and white film stock of the era would have provided high contrast images, with limited tonal range compared to later developments in cinematographic technology.

Innovations

While 'A Lucky Strike' was not a technically innovative film, it represents the standard technical capabilities of American studios in 1915. The film was likely shot on 35mm film at approximately 16 frames per second, the standard speed of the era. The production would have utilized the latest camera equipment available to Lubin Studios, possibly including hand-cranked cameras that allowed for slight variations in filming speed to enhance comedic timing. The studio's lighting setup would have employed both natural and artificial sources, representing the state of the art in indoor film production. The film's editing would have used simple cuts between shots, with the narrative continuity that had become standard by the mid-1910s. While not groundbreaking, the technical execution would have been professional and consistent with industry standards of the period.

Music

As a silent film, 'A Lucky Strike' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during theatrical exhibition. The specific musical score would have varied by theater, ranging from a solo pianist in smaller nickelodeons to small ensembles or even full orchestras in larger venues. The music would have been selected from standard compilations of mood music published for silent film accompanists, with upbeat, playful pieces chosen for comedic scenes and more romantic melodies for the courtship sequences. Some theaters might have used popular songs of the era, particularly if any matched the film's themes of romance or Western adventure. The soundtrack would have been improvised to match the on-screen action, with musicians following cue sheets or relying on their experience to enhance the visual comedy.

Memorable Scenes

• The scene where Bill first reads the prank letter and becomes excited about finding a potential wife
• The panicked reaction of Nellie and Eleanor when they learn Bill is coming to visit
• The comic reveal of the cook disguised as the letter writer
• Bill's confused attempts to court the disguised cook while the real women watch in amusement

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception for short comedies like 'A Lucky Strike' was minimal, as trade publications of the era focused more on feature films and major studio releases. The film likely received brief mentions in trade papers like Moving Picture World or The Motion Picture News, which typically reviewed shorts in condensed format. Reviews would have focused on the comedy's effectiveness and the performances of the cast, particularly noting any standout gags or physical comedy. Modern critical assessment is limited due to the film's obscurity and potential loss, though film historians recognize it as an example of typical Lubin comedy production and as an early Oliver Hardy appearance.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception for 1915 short comedies was generally positive when the films delivered effective laughs and entertainment. 'A Lucky Strike' would have been enjoyed by nickelodeon patrons looking for brief amusement between longer features. The mistaken identity premise was a familiar and popular comedic device that audiences of the era readily understood and appreciated. Oliver Hardy's physical comedy, even in these early roles, likely resonated with viewers who enjoyed the slapstick style prevalent in silent comedies. The film's brief running time made it suitable for varied programming, and its lighthearted content provided welcome distraction from the serious news of World War I affecting many communities.

You Might Also Like