Alice Gets in Dutch

Plot

Alice Gets in Dutch follows young Alice as she misbehaves in her classroom, drawing on her slate and disrupting the lesson. As punishment, her teacher forces her to sit in the corner with a dunce cap. Alice falls asleep at her desk and enters a dream world where her school troubles manifest in surreal ways. She encounters dancing dogs and donkeys in a fantastical landscape, but her reverie is interrupted when three animated schoolbooks come to life and chase her. The dream culminates in a chaotic chase sequence where Alice must outsmart her animated pursuers before awakening back in the classroom.

Historical Background

Alice Gets in Dutch was produced during a transformative period in American cinema and Disney's career. 1924 was the height of the silent film era, just three years before 'The Jazz Singer' would revolutionize the industry with sound. The film industry was consolidating in Hollywood, and small studios like Disney's were competing for attention in a crowded market. The Alice Comedies represented Disney's attempt to stand out by combining live-action with animation, a relatively novel approach at the time. This was also during the Roaring Twenties, a period of economic prosperity and cultural change in America, which influenced the playful, irreverent tone of children's entertainment. The film reflects contemporary educational attitudes, where corporal punishment and public shaming (like dunce caps) were common in schools.

Making Of

The production of Alice Gets in Dutch represented a crucial period in Disney's early development. Walt Disney and his team worked in cramped conditions at their first Los Angeles studio, with Ub Iwerks handling much of the animation while Disney directed and coordinated. The live-action sequences with Virginia Davis were filmed first, then the team would carefully plan where animated characters would interact with the real world. The schoolroom set was deliberately built to allow for easy integration of animated elements. The dancing dogs and donkeys sequence was particularly challenging, requiring Iwerks to create fluid, characterful animation that could believably interact with the live-action footage. Disney insisted on multiple takes of Virginia's performance to ensure her reactions would match the timing of the animated characters she would eventually 'see'.

Visual Style

The cinematography of Alice Gets in Dutch utilized innovative techniques for combining live-action and animation. The film employed multiple exposure photography and careful matte work to integrate animated characters into the live-action footage. The camera work in the live-action segments was relatively static, as was common in early films, to facilitate the later addition of animated elements. The dream sequence allowed for more dynamic camera movements and surreal visual effects. The black and white photography used high contrast lighting to help separate the live-action elements from the animated portions, making the compositing process more effective.

Innovations

Alice Gets in Dutch demonstrated several important technical achievements for its time. The seamless integration of live-action and animation required innovative compositing techniques that were cutting-edge in 1924. The film's use of multiple exposure photography to place animated characters in the same frame as live actors was particularly sophisticated for the period. The animation itself showed improved fluidity and character expression compared to earlier Disney works. The film also demonstrated early mastery of timing and pacing in combining different media, a challenge that many studios struggled with during this era of hybrid filmmaking.

Music

As a silent film from 1924, Alice Gets in Dutch originally had no synchronized soundtrack. The film would have been accompanied by live musical performance in theaters, typically a pianist or small orchestra playing popular tunes of the era or classical pieces appropriate to the on-screen action. The musical accompaniment would have emphasized the film's comedic moments and dramatic chase sequences. Modern restorations and releases of the film typically feature newly composed period-appropriate scores or compiled music from the 1920s era.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening classroom scene where Alice disrupts the lesson with her drawings
• Alice being forced to wear the dunce cap in the corner
• The dream sequence's introduction with dancing dogs and donkeys
• The chase scene where Alice flees from the three animated schoolbooks
• Alice's abrupt awakening back in the classroom

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of Alice Gets in Dutch were generally positive, with trade publications praising the innovative combination of live-action and animation. The Motion Picture News noted the film's 'amusing blend of reality and fantasy' while Variety highlighted Virginia Davis's 'natural and charming performance'. Modern film historians view the Alice Comedies as important precursors to Disney's later success, with Alice Gets in Dutch often cited as a representative example of the series' creative approach. Animation scholars particularly appreciate the film for showcasing Ub Iwerks' early animation style and the technical challenges the Disney team overcame in creating seamless interactions between live and animated elements.

What Audiences Thought

Alice Gets in Dutch was well-received by audiences in 1924, particularly children who were the target demographic for the Alice Comedies. The film's blend of a relatable child protagonist with fantastical animated elements proved popular with theater audiences. The series as a whole helped establish Disney's reputation for creating engaging family entertainment. Modern audiences viewing the film through archives or DVD compilations often appreciate it as a historical artifact showing Disney's early development, though the silent-era pacing and 1920s sensibilities can feel dated to contemporary viewers.

You Might Also Like