Kill or Cure

1923 14 minutes Directed by Scott Pembroke

About Kill or Cure

A door-to-door salesman (Stan Laurel) tries to sell Professor I.O. Dine's Knox-All. The label claims the bottle works on coughs, colds, toothache, furniture polish, after-shave, fleas, baldness, grease spots, machine oil, and hair bleach. Customers shove him off, including an aggressive woman and a deaf man. A sheriff and a car owner join the trouble his samples start.

Cast & crew

More about Kill or Cure

Scott Pembroke directed the short for Hal Roach. Katherine Grant plays a maid with a birdcage, Noah Young a car owner, Eddie Baker the sheriff, and Mark Jones Speedy Sam. Released 15 July 1923.

Themes

  • The unwanted salesman
  • A cure-all that cures nothing
  • patent medicine
  • door-to-door salesman
  • Knox-All
  • sheriff
  • Prohibition

Background

Released in July 1923, during national Prohibition, when a bottle sold as medicine could also be read as a drink.

Making

Roach's unit built the reel around one prop, the Knox-All bottle, and a salesman who will not stop pitching it.

Music

Silent.

Preservation

Prints survive. A copy is on Wikimedia Commons.

Notes

  • Wikipedia notes that prints survive.
  • Helen Gilmore plays an aggressive non-customer, George Rowe a deaf man, and Sammy Brooks a short non-customer.
  • The bottle's label lists coughs, colds, toothache, furniture polish, flea killer, baldness, and machine oil as uses for the same mixture.

Scenes

  • Laurel reads off the impossible list of uses printed on the Knox-All bottle.

Also available

  • Wikimedia Commons