One Too Many

Plot

In this silent comedy short, Plump (Oliver Hardy) faces a predicament when his wealthy uncle unexpectedly announces a visit. To impress his uncle, Plump must quickly produce a wife and baby to prove he's settled down. With the chaotic assistance of his friend Runt (Billy Ruge), their frantic search leads to a series of hilarious misunderstandings and mix-ups. The situation spirals out of control as multiple women and babies suddenly appear, creating increasingly absurd scenarios as they try to maintain the deception before the uncle's arrival.

Historical Background

1916 was a pivotal year in cinema history, occurring during the transition from short films to feature-length pictures. The United States was on the brink of entering World War I, and films like 'One Too Many' served as light entertainment for audiences seeking escape from growing international tensions. The film industry itself was in flux, with the center of American film production gradually shifting from the East Coast to Hollywood. Jacksonville, Florida, where this film was likely made, was experiencing its final years as a significant filmmaking hub. This period also saw the rise of the studio system and the increasing professionalization of film production. Comedy shorts were particularly popular during this era, serving as the main attraction in many theaters or as supporting material for feature presentations.

Making Of

The production of 'One Too Many' took place during Jacksonville's brief golden age as a filmmaking center. The Vim Comedy Company, which produced this film, was one of several studios operating in the area at the time. Oliver Hardy, who had been making films since 1914, was establishing himself as a reliable character actor and comedy performer. The Plump and Runt series was designed to capitalize on the popular 'fat and skinny' comedy duo formula that was successful in vaudeville and early cinema. The filming process would have been typical of the era - shot quickly with minimal rehearsal, using natural lighting where possible, and relying heavily on physical comedy and visual gags since it was a silent film. The production likely faced the common challenges of the period including primitive equipment, limited special effects, and the need to shoot sequences in long takes due to editing limitations.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'One Too Many' would have employed techniques typical of 1916 comedy shorts. The film was likely shot in black and white on 35mm film using hand-cranked cameras. Visual comedy would have been enhanced through careful composition and framing, with the camera positioned to capture physical gags and reactions. The cinematographer would have used relatively static shots with occasional pans to follow the action, as camera movement was limited by the bulky equipment of the era. Natural lighting would have been supplemented by arc lamps when filming indoors. The visual style would have prioritized clarity and visibility of the comedic action over artistic flourishes, ensuring that audiences could easily follow the physical comedy and situational gags that formed the core of the film's entertainment value.

Innovations

While 'One Too Many' was not groundbreaking in its technical aspects, it utilized the standard filmmaking technology of 1916. The film would have been shot on celluloid nitrate stock using hand-cranked cameras, requiring skilled camera operators to maintain consistent exposure and frame rates. Editing would have been done physically, cutting and splicing the film by hand to create the final sequence. The production might have employed some simple special effects techniques such as multiple exposures or matte shots to create the illusion of multiple characters in the same frame. The film's technical achievements lay primarily in its efficient production methods and ability to deliver comedic entertainment within the technical constraints of the period. Like many films of its era, it demonstrated the growing sophistication of film grammar and storytelling techniques that were rapidly developing during the 1910s.

Music

As a silent film, 'One Too Many' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its theatrical run. The exact musical score would have varied by theater, with accompaniment ranging from a single pianist in smaller venues to full orchestras in larger movie palaces. The music would have been selected to enhance the comedic timing and emotional tone of each scene, with popular songs of the period interspersed with classical pieces and original compositions. The tempo and style of the music would have changed to match the on-screen action - faster during chase scenes or chaotic moments, slower during more sentimental sequences. Some theaters might have used cue sheets provided by the distributor, while others relied on the improvisational skills of their house musicians to create appropriate accompaniment.

Memorable Scenes

• The frantic search for a wife and baby when Plump learns his uncle is coming to visit
• The chaotic sequence where multiple women and babies suddenly appear in the house
• The climactic scene where Plump tries to explain the situation to his uncle amid the confusion

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of 'One Too Many' are scarce, as was common for short comedy films of the period. Trade publications like Variety and Moving Picture World likely provided brief mentions noting the film's release and perhaps commenting on its comedic value. The film would have been judged primarily on its ability to entertain audiences with physical comedy and situational humor. Modern critical assessment is impossible due to the film's apparent lost status, but scholars of silent comedy recognize the Plump and Runt series as important in Oliver Hardy's development as a comic performer. The film would have been evaluated within the context of other comedy shorts of 1916, competing with productions from more established studios like Keystone, Hal Roach, and Mack Sennett.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception for 'One Too Many' would have been measured in laughter and repeat business rather than formal reviews. As a comedy short, its success depended on its ability to generate immediate entertainment value for theater audiences. The film's premise of mistaken identities and domestic chaos was a proven formula that typically resonated well with early 20th-century audiences. Oliver Hardy's growing popularity as a comic actor would have helped draw audiences to theaters showing this film. The Plump and Runt series developed a modest following during its run, though it never achieved the level of popularity enjoyed by more famous comedy teams of the era. Like most comedy shorts of the period, it was likely considered disposable entertainment - enjoyed in the moment but not expected to have lasting cultural impact.

You Might Also Like