Shors

Plot

Set in 1919 during the Russian Civil War in Ukraine, 'Shors' follows the story of Bolshevik commander Mykola Shchors as he leads his division against Ukrainian nationalist forces. After German troops retreat from Ukraine, the Directory government led by Symon Petliura takes control of Kyiv. Shchors's Bolshevik forces capture several cities including Vinnytsia and Zhmerynka but suffer a demoralizing defeat at Berdychiv. Through his personal courage and military leadership, Shchors inspires the retreating Red troops and leads them to victory over the enemy, cementing his legacy as a Soviet hero in the struggle for Ukraine.

Historical Background

The film was produced in 1939, a pivotal year in European history on the eve of World War II. Within the Soviet Union, this period saw the culmination of Stalin's Great Purge and the consolidation of Soviet power. The film's subject matter—the Bolshevik victory in Ukraine during the Russian Civil War—served to reinforce the legitimacy of Soviet rule in Ukraine, which was particularly important given recent Soviet policies including collectivization and the Holodomor. The portrayal of Ukrainian nationalist forces as enemies aligned with Soviet propaganda of the era, which sought to discredit independence movements. The film's release came just months before the Soviet invasion of eastern Poland and the eventual incorporation of western Ukrainian territories into the USSR, making its message about Bolshevik triumph in Ukraine particularly timely from the Soviet perspective.

Making Of

The production of 'Shors' took place during a particularly tense period in Soviet history. Dovzhenko, who had faced criticism for his earlier films being too formalist or insufficiently ideological, was under pressure to create a film that would satisfy Soviet authorities while maintaining his artistic integrity. The casting of Evgeniy Samoylov as Shchors was significant, as the actor was relatively unknown at the time but would go on to become one of the Soviet Union's most respected performers. The battle sequences were meticulously choreographed with the assistance of Soviet military advisors to ensure authenticity from the Bolshevik perspective. Dovzhenko employed his signature poetic visual style even within the constraints of the propaganda format, using sweeping landscapes and symbolic imagery to elevate the narrative beyond simple historical recreation.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'Shors' showcases Dovzhenko's characteristic visual poetry even within the constraints of socialist realism. The film employs sweeping panoramic shots of the Ukrainian landscape, using the natural environment to reinforce the epic scale of the historical events. Battle sequences are filmed with dynamic camera movement and careful composition, creating a sense of chaos and heroism simultaneously. Dovzhenko makes effective use of light and shadow, particularly in scenes depicting the contrast between the 'backward' nationalist forces and the 'enlightened' Bolsheviks. The visual style incorporates symbolic imagery and metaphorical shots that elevate the narrative beyond straightforward historical recreation, though these elements are more subtle than in Dovzhenko's earlier, more experimental works. The black and white photography demonstrates the technical sophistication of Soviet cinema of the late 1930s.

Innovations

For its time, 'Shors' demonstrated significant technical achievements in Soviet filmmaking, particularly in the execution of large-scale battle sequences. The film employed hundreds of extras, many of whom were actual Soviet soldiers, to create authentic military formations and maneuvers. The production utilized mobile camera units to capture dynamic action sequences, allowing for more fluid movement during battle scenes than was typical in earlier Soviet war films. The special effects team developed innovative techniques for simulating artillery explosions and gunfire that were both realistic and safe for the performers. The film's sound recording represented an advancement in location audio capture, particularly for the exterior battle scenes. The editing style, while constrained by the requirements of socialist realism, still shows Dovzhenko's rhythmic sensibility and ability to build tension through montage.

Music

The musical score for 'Shors' was composed by Dmitri Klebanov, a prominent Ukrainian Soviet composer. The soundtrack incorporates revolutionary songs and marches of the period, creating an authentic historical atmosphere while reinforcing the film's ideological message. The music swells during key battle sequences and moments of heroic sacrifice, using orchestral arrangements to heighten the emotional impact of these scenes. Traditional Ukrainian musical elements are incorporated, but reinterpreted through the lens of Soviet ideology to suggest that the Bolshevik cause represented the true liberation of Ukrainian culture. The sound design of the battle sequences was particularly advanced for its time, using location recording and post-production techniques to create realistic audio environments that immersed audiences in the historical action.

Memorable Scenes

• The battle of Berdychiv sequence, showing the initial defeat and subsequent rally of Bolshevik forces
• Shchors's inspirational speech to the demoralized troops, demonstrating his leadership qualities
• The final victory montage, intercutting the military triumph with hopeful images of the Ukrainian future
• The opening sequence depicting the German retreat and the power vacuum in Ukraine
• The personal moments between Shchors and his soldiers, humanizing the revolutionary hero

What Critics Said

Contemporary Soviet critics praised 'Shors' as a successful fusion of artistic merit and ideological correctness, with particular emphasis on Dovzhenko's ability to create a compelling heroic narrative within the parameters of socialist realism. The film received positive reviews in Soviet publications like 'Pravda' and 'Iskusstvo Kino,' which highlighted its educational value in teaching Soviet citizens about their revolutionary history. Western critics had limited access to the film upon its release due to Cold War restrictions, but those who did see it noted its technical craftsmanship while questioning its historical perspective. Modern film scholars view 'Shors' as a complex work that demonstrates both the constraints and possibilities of artistic expression within the Soviet system, with particular attention to how Dovzhenko managed to infuse the propaganda format with moments of genuine cinematic poetry.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by Soviet audiences, who were familiar with the legend of Mykola Shchors from school curricula and popular culture. Many viewers praised the battle sequences and the heroic portrayal of the Bolshevik commander. The film's release was accompanied by educational programs and discussions in factories and collective farms, as was typical for major Soviet productions of the era. Audience attendance figures, while not publicly documented in the Western sense, were reportedly strong across the Soviet Union, particularly in Ukraine where the historical events depicted had local resonance. The film became part of the standard repertoire shown in Soviet cinemas and was periodically revived for anniversary celebrations of the Russian Civil War. Modern audiences, particularly in independent Ukraine, view the film with more critical distance, recognizing it as both a work of cinematic art and a product of Soviet propaganda.

You Might Also Like