The Little Girl's Wrong

Plot

In this dramatic Neapolitan tale, young Tore becomes infatuated with Margaretella and attempts to win her affection through expensive gifts, resorting to stealing his mother's precious jewels to fund his courtship. However, Margaretella's heart belongs to Carluccio, who challenges Tore to a duel and successfully wounds him in combat. On her deathbed, Tore's mother forgives him for his transgression, but consumed by jealousy and rage, Tore seeks revenge by murdering Margaretella. Even while imprisoned for his crime, Tore remains haunted by thoughts of his victim, trapped in a cycle of obsession and remorse that defines his tragic existence.

Historical Background

The film was produced during a turbulent period in Italian history, following World War I and during the rise of Fascism under Mussolini. This era saw significant social upheaval as Italy struggled with economic instability and political transformation. Cinema was becoming increasingly important as both entertainment and propaganda, with the Fascist regime beginning to exert control over film production. Notari's work, which focused on the lives of ordinary Neapolitans and often critiqued social injustice, stood in contrast to the epic historical films being promoted by the government. The early 1920s also marked the peak of Italian immigration to America, and Notari's films became hugely popular in Italian-American communities, serving as cultural touchstones that connected immigrants to their homeland. The film industry was transitioning from short subjects to feature-length productions, and women like Notari who had established themselves in the early days of cinema were increasingly being marginalized as the business became more commercialized and male-dominated.

Making Of

The production of 'The Little Girl's Wrong' exemplified Elvira Notari's distinctive filmmaking approach, which prioritized authenticity and emotional truth over studio polish. Notari and her husband Nicola operated Dora Film as a family enterprise, with Elvira directing and writing while Nicola handled cinematography. Their son Eduardo frequently starred in their productions, creating a collaborative atmosphere that was rare in the commercial film industry. The film was shot on location in Naples's working-class neighborhoods, allowing Notari to capture the genuine texture of Neapolitan life. Local residents often appeared as extras, contributing to the film's documentary-like quality. Notari was known for her hands-on approach to directing, working closely with actors to achieve naturalistic performances that contrasted with the exaggerated acting style common in silent cinema. The production faced challenges from Italian censors who often objected to Notari's frank depiction of social issues and moral ambiguity.

Visual Style

The cinematography, likely handled by Nicola Notari, would have been characteristic of the Dora Film style, emphasizing natural lighting and authentic locations over studio artifice. The film probably employed static camera positions typical of early 1920s cinema, but with careful attention to composition and framing to capture the texture of Neapolitan street life. Location shooting in Naples's narrow streets and working-class neighborhoods would have presented technical challenges but also opportunities for visual authenticity. The visual style likely incorporated elements of Neapolitan popular art and theatrical traditions, creating a distinctive aesthetic that differed from the more polished look of contemporary Italian historical epics. Close-ups would have been used strategically to emphasize emotional moments, particularly in the dramatic confrontations between characters.

Innovations

While not technologically innovative in terms of camera or editing techniques, the film represented an achievement in its authentic approach to location shooting and its use of non-professional actors to create realistic performances. Notari's decision to film on location in Naples rather than in studios was technically challenging but resulted in a level of authenticity that was rare for the period. The film likely used standard 35mm film equipment of the era, but Notari's skill in using this technology to capture genuine human emotion and everyday life was notable. The production's ability to create compelling drama with limited resources demonstrated Notari's resourcefulness and technical competence as a filmmaker.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Little Girl's Wrong' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during theatrical screenings. Given Notari's practice of incorporating authentic Neapolitan culture into her films, the musical accompaniment likely included traditional Neapolitan songs and folk melodies. Theaters showing the film might have employed small orchestras or at minimum a pianist who would play appropriate music to enhance the emotional impact of key scenes. Neapolitan songs were an integral part of Notari's cinematic vision, and she often used popular music of the region to create an authentic atmosphere. The soundtrack would have changed the emotional tone of scenes, with romantic music for love scenes, dramatic music for confrontations, and mournful music for tragic moments.

Memorable Scenes

• The dramatic duel between Tore and Carluccio, which would have been choreographed to emphasize the tension and fatal consequences of their rivalry
• The deathbed scene where Tore's mother forgives him, representing a moment of emotional catharsis and moral complexity
• The murder of Margaretella, which would have been staged to convey both the brutality of the act and Tore's psychological torment
• The final prison scenes showing Tore's obsessive thoughts about his victim, creating a haunting conclusion to the tragic narrative

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception of Notari's work was mixed, with mainstream Italian critics often dismissing her films as vulgar or overly sentimental due to their working-class settings and melodramatic style. However, her films were extremely popular with audiences, particularly in Naples and among Italian immigrant communities abroad. Modern film historians and critics have reevaluated Notari's work, recognizing its importance in early cinema history and its influence on later Italian filmmaking traditions. Critics now appreciate her innovative use of location shooting, her authentic portrayal of Neapolitan culture, and her pioneering role as a female director in an overwhelmingly male industry. The film's emotional intensity and moral complexity are now seen as sophisticated rather than simplistic, and her visual style is admired for its documentary-like realism.

What Audiences Thought

The film was reportedly very popular with its intended audience, particularly working-class Neapolitans who recognized their own lives and struggles reflected on screen. Notari's films developed a cult following in Naples, where she was celebrated as a filmmaker who truly understood and respected local culture. The film also found enthusiastic audiences among Italian immigrants in America, where it was shown in neighborhood theaters and became part of the cultural fabric of Italian-American communities. Audience members reportedly responded emotionally to the dramatic storylines and authentic settings, often returning to see Notari's films multiple times. The film's themes of love, betrayal, and revenge resonated strongly with viewers who appreciated the moral complexity and emotional depth of Notari's storytelling.

You Might Also Like