Tweedledum as Aviator

Plot

In this Italian slapstick comedy, the bumbling character Robinet becomes obsessed with the new and exciting world of aviation, desperately wanting to become an aviator despite having absolutely no aptitude for it. Robinet's attempts at flight involve increasingly disastrous and physically demanding mishaps as he tries to build his own flying machine or hijack existing ones. The film showcases the character's relentless determination and complete lack of common sense as he endures countless falls, crashes, and humiliations in pursuit of his aerial dreams. True to the bone-breaking style of Italian slapstick of the era, Robinet suffers spectacular physical comedy that makes even the famous Keystone comedies look tame by comparison. The film culminates in a chaotic finale where Robinet's aviation ambitions lead to maximum destruction and minimum success.

Historical Background

1911 was a pivotal year in cinema history, occurring during the transition from short novelty films to more sophisticated narrative storytelling. The film industry was rapidly expanding globally, with Italy emerging as a major cinematic power alongside France and the United States. This period saw the rise of national film industries and the development of genre conventions. Aviation was capturing the public imagination worldwide, with pioneers like Louis Blériot making headline-grabbing flights across the English Channel in 1909. The film was produced during the Italo-Turkish War (1911-1912), when Italy was asserting itself as a modern industrial and military power. Cinema was also becoming more respectable as an art form, moving from fairground attractions to dedicated theaters. The physically demanding style of Italian comedy reflected broader cultural values of bravado and spectacle that characterized Italian cinema of the period.

Making Of

The production of 'Tweedledum as Aviator' exemplified the rough-and-tumble approach to filmmaking in early Italian cinema. Unlike later productions with elaborate safety measures, Marcel Perez performed his own stunts, enduring real falls and physical impacts that would be considered unacceptable by modern standards. The film was likely shot quickly in one or two days, as was typical for short comedies of the era. The makeshift aviation equipment shown in the film was probably constructed by the studio's prop department using whatever materials were available, reflecting both the ingenuity and limitations of early film production. Director Luigi Maggi, coming from a theatrical background, would have staged the physical comedy to play well to live audiences, emphasizing broad gestures and visible impacts that would read clearly on screen without the benefit of sound.

Visual Style

The cinematography would have been characteristic of 1911 Italian filmmaking, using stationary cameras positioned to capture the full range of physical action. The camera would have been placed at a distance to ensure all of Robinet's movements and falls were visible within the frame. The film was likely shot in black and white on 35mm film, with outdoor scenes utilizing natural light. The composition would emphasize clarity of action over artistic framing, ensuring that the slapstick gags were easily understood by audiences. Long takes would have been preferred to maintain the continuity of physical comedy sequences. The aviation scenes would have required careful positioning to capture both the performer and any flying apparatus or props.

Innovations

While not groundbreaking in technical terms, the film demonstrates the sophisticated stunt coordination and physical comedy techniques being developed in Italian cinema. The aviation props and effects, while rudimentary by modern standards, showed creative problem-solving in depicting flight on screen. The film's success in capturing complex physical action in long takes required careful choreography and timing. The production likely utilized the relatively stable cameras and reliable film stock that had become available by 1911, allowing for greater freedom in shooting physical comedy. The film represents the refinement of slapstick techniques that would influence comedy filmmaking for decades.

Music

As a silent film, 'Tweedledum as Aviator' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during theatrical exhibition. The accompaniment could range from a single pianist to a small orchestra depending on the theater's resources. The music would have been selected to match the on-screen action, with lively, comedic themes for Robinet's antics and more dramatic or suspenseful music for the aviation sequences. Popular songs of the era might have been incorporated when relevant to the action. The score would have been improvised or drawn from published collections of photoplay music specifically compiled for silent film accompaniment. The absence of recorded sound meant that the visual comedy had to carry the entire narrative weight.

Memorable Scenes

• Robinet's disastrous attempt to construct and fly a makeshift airplane, resulting in a spectacular crash sequence typical of the era's dangerous stunt work

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception of short comedies like 'Tweedledum as Aviator' was minimal, as film criticism as we know it today had not yet developed. Trade publications of the era would have focused more on the film's commercial potential and technical aspects rather than artistic merit. The film was likely reviewed in trade journals for its entertainment value and suitability for various programming slots. Modern film historians and archivists recognize such films as important cultural artifacts that provide insight into early cinematic comedy styles and the international nature of silent film production. The extreme physical comedy has been noted by scholars as characteristic of Italian slapstick's particularly brutal approach compared to other national traditions.

What Audiences Thought

Early audiences responded enthusiastically to the film's physical comedy and aviation theme, which tapped into contemporary interests in technological progress and human flight. The Robinet character was already established as a popular comic figure, so audiences would have been familiar with and receptive to his misadventures. The spectacular falls and crashes would have been major attractions, as early cinema audiences were thrilled by dangerous stunts and physical comedy. The film likely performed well in both domestic Italian markets and internationally, as slapstick comedy transcended language barriers. The aviation theme would have been particularly timely and exciting for audiences witnessing the rapid development of real-world aviation. The short format and straightforward humor made it ideal for the varied programming of early cinema theaters, which typically presented multiple short films per showing.

You Might Also Like