Carnival of Souls

Plot

After a traumatic car accident where she emerges as the sole survivor, Mary Henry attempts to rebuild her life by relocating to Salt Lake City and accepting a position as a church organist. Despite her efforts to move forward, Mary finds herself haunted by increasingly frequent and disturbing visions of a pale, ghoulish man who seems to follow her everywhere. These supernatural encounters lead her to become inexplicably drawn to the abandoned Saltair Pavilion, a deserted amusement park on the shores of the Great Salt Lake. As Mary's grip on reality weakens and she becomes more isolated from those around her, she discovers that the carnival may hold the terrifying truth about her existence and the reason she survived the crash. The film culminates in a shocking revelation that Mary has been dead all along, caught between worlds and destined to join the other souls at the carnival.

Historical Background

Released in 1962, 'Carnival of Souls' emerged during a transitional period in American cinema. The studio system was crumbling, independent films were gaining traction, and the horror genre was evolving from the Universal monster movies of previous decades toward more psychological and supernatural themes. The early 1960s also saw growing interest in European art cinema, with its emphasis on atmosphere and psychological depth over narrative clarity. This cultural shift influenced the film's dreamlike structure and existential themes. The Cold War era's underlying anxieties about death and the unknown also permeated the cultural consciousness, making horror films particularly resonant. The film's exploration of isolation and alienation reflected broader societal concerns in an increasingly modernized but disconnected world.

Making Of

The production was a remarkable example of independent filmmaking ingenuity. Herk Harvey, a veteran industrial filmmaker from Lawrence, Kansas, conceived the idea while driving past Saltair Pavilion and being struck by its eerie appearance. He collaborated with writer John Clifford to create the script over a weekend. The casting was particularly challenging - Candace Hilligoss, a professional actress from New York, was brought in to play Mary, while most other roles were filled with local Utah residents, including Sidney Berger, who was actually a student at the University of Utah. The production faced numerous challenges, including limited equipment, natural lighting constraints, and the need to work around the deteriorating conditions at Saltair. The famous dance sequence was filmed using a special slow-motion technique to create the surreal, otherworldly effect. Despite the minimal budget, the crew managed to create sophisticated visual effects through in-camera techniques rather than post-production manipulation.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Maurice Prather is remarkably sophisticated given the film's budget constraints. Prather employed innovative techniques including disorienting Dutch angles, extensive use of natural light, and deep focus compositions to create the film's unsettling atmosphere. The famous dance sequence was filmed using a combination of slow motion and normal speed footage, creating a surreal effect where Mary appears disconnected from the revelers around her. The Saltair Pavilion sequences utilize the location's natural decay and expansive emptiness to evoke a sense of otherworldly isolation. Prather's work often placed characters at the edges of frames or used reflections to suggest Mary's fractured psyche. The black-and-white photography enhances the film's dreamlike quality, with high contrast lighting creating stark shadows that reinforce the themes of life and death.

Innovations

Despite its minimal budget, 'Carnival of Souls' achieved several technical innovations that have influenced subsequent horror cinema. The film's use of location shooting at Saltair created an authentic atmosphere that studio sets couldn't replicate. The production pioneered various in-camera effects, including the famous mirror sequence where Mary's reflection moves independently, achieved through careful timing and multiple exposures. The underwater sequences in the opening accident scene were accomplished with specially designed camera housings. The film's sound design, particularly the use of reverb and echo to create supernatural effects, was ahead of its time. The editing style, which often uses jump cuts and abrupt transitions, contributed to the film's disorienting quality and influenced later psychological horror films.

Music

The film's distinctive score was composed and performed by Gene Moore on an organ at the Salt Lake City Tabernacle. Moore improvised much of the music during filming, creating dissonant, atonal compositions that perfectly complement the film's unsettling atmosphere. The organ music serves as both diegetic sound (when Mary is playing at church) and non-diegetic score, blurring the line between reality and Mary's psychological state. The recurring theme that plays whenever Mary sees The Man has become one of horror cinema's most recognizable musical motifs. The soundtrack's innovative use of silence is equally important, with moments of complete quiet amplifying the tension. The combination of organ music, ambient sounds, and strategic use of silence creates an audio landscape that is as unsettling as the visual imagery.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening car race and accident sequence, where Mary's car plunges into the river and she emerges as the sole survivor
• The first appearance of The Man at the bus station, staring eerily at Mary from across the terminal
• The famous dance hall sequence where Mary finds herself unable to hear the music or connect with the dancers
• The mirror scene where Mary's reflection moves independently of her, smiling while she remains horrified
• The final revelation at Saltair where Mary is chased by the ghoulish figures and discovers the truth about her death

What Critics Said

Upon its initial release, 'Carnival of Souls' received largely negative reviews from mainstream critics who found it confusing and amateurish. The New York Times dismissed it as 'an amateurish effort' while Variety criticized its 'lack of professional polish.' However, as the years passed, critical opinion underwent a dramatic reversal. By the 1980s, critics began recognizing the film's artistic merits, with Roger Ebert praising its 'eerie, dreamlike quality' and Martin Scorsese including it among his favorite horror films. Modern critics now celebrate its atmospheric tension, innovative cinematography, and psychological depth. The film is now widely regarded as a masterpiece of independent horror, with particular appreciation for its use of location, sound design, and the haunting performance by Candace Hilligoss.

What Audiences Thought

Initial audience reception was lukewarm at best, with many viewers finding the film too artsy and confusing for a horror movie. The limited theatrical run meant few people saw it upon release, and it quickly faded from public consciousness. However, with its revival on television and home video in the 1980s, audiences began to embrace its unique qualities. Horror fans particularly appreciated its atmospheric approach and psychological complexity, distinguishing it from more straightforward horror fare of the era. Today, it enjoys a dedicated cult following, with regular screenings at revival theaters and film festivals. Online film communities consistently rank it among the greatest independent horror films ever made, with particular praise for its enduring ability to unsettle viewers despite its age and low budget.

You Might Also Like