Getting Evidence

Plot

A jealous husband, convinced his wife is being unfaithful, storms into the office of private detective Hawkshaw demanding photographic evidence of her infidelity. The determined detective accepts the case and begins trailing the suspicious wife through various locations, attempting to capture incriminating photographs. Just as Hawkshaw believes he has the perfect shot of the wife in a compromising position, a series of mishaps and comedic accidents prevent him from getting the evidence. Despite multiple setbacks including camera malfunctions, missed opportunities, and mistaken identities, the persistent detective continues his surveillance with increasing desperation. The film culminates in a final attempt to fulfill his assignment, showcasing the early cinematic tradition of slapstick comedy and the lengths to which characters will go to complete their mission.

Historical Background

1906 was a pivotal year in early cinema, occurring during the transition period between novelty short films and more sophisticated narrative storytelling. The Nickelodeon boom was in full swing, with thousands of small theaters opening across America to show short films to working-class audiences. Edwin S. Porter was at the height of his influence at Edison, having already created groundbreaking films like 'The Great Train Robbery' (1903). This period saw the establishment of many cinematic conventions, including cross-cutting, continuity editing, and narrative structure. The film industry was still dominated by the Edison Manufacturing Company and other patent holders, who controlled production through the Motion Picture Patents Company. Photography itself was still relatively new and mysterious to the general public, making the premise of a detective using photographic evidence particularly contemporary and intriguing to audiences of the time.

Making Of

The making of 'Getting Evidence' reflects the transitional period of cinema from simple actualities to narrative storytelling. Edwin S. Porter, working at the Edison Manufacturing Company, was experimenting with more complex narratives and character development. The film was likely shot in just one or two days, as was typical for productions of this era. The actors, primarily stage performers, had to adapt their acting styles for the camera, which required different techniques than theater performance. The production crew would have been small, probably consisting of Porter as director and cameraman, plus a few assistants. The film's chase sequences and physical comedy required careful choreography within the limitations of stationary cameras and short film lengths. The Edison studio's indoor sets and nearby outdoor locations provided the necessary backdrops for the detective's surveillance activities.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'Getting Evidence' reflects the technical limitations and emerging techniques of 1906 filmmaking. Shot on 35mm black and white film using hand-cranked cameras, the film likely employed static shots typical of the period, with the camera positioned to capture the action in a theatrical manner. Edwin S. Porter was known for experimenting with camera placement and movement, so the film might include some variation in shot composition. The lighting would have been natural for outdoor scenes and artificial for studio interiors, creating high contrast images typical of early cinema. The film stock would have had relatively low sensitivity, requiring bright lighting conditions. The cinematography prioritized clarity of action and narrative comprehension over artistic flourish, as was standard for commercial films of this era.

Innovations

While not revolutionary in its technical aspects, 'Getting Evidence' represents the refinement of filmmaking techniques that Edwin S. Porter had been developing. The film demonstrates effective use of continuity editing to maintain narrative coherence across different locations and time periods. The production likely utilized multiple camera setups and careful planning to execute the comedic timing and chase sequences. The film's clear storytelling structure shows the maturation of narrative cinema beyond the simple tableaux of earlier years. The use of photography as a plot device also demonstrates cinema's growing self-awareness and its ability to comment on contemporary technology. The film represents the standardization of film grammar that would become the foundation of classical Hollywood cinema.

Music

As a silent film from 1906, 'Getting Evidence' had no synchronized soundtrack. During exhibition, the film would have been accompanied by live music, typically provided by a pianist or small ensemble in the Nickelodeon theater. The musical accompaniment would have been improvised or selected from standard collections of appropriate mood music, with lively, upbeat selections for the comedic scenes and more suspenseful music for the surveillance sequences. The choice of music was left to the individual theater's musical director or accompanist, and would vary from venue to venue. Sound effects might have been created live by theater staff, particularly for the comedic mishaps and accidents depicted in the film.

Memorable Scenes

• The detective's frantic attempts to photograph the wife through various obstacles and mishaps, culminating in a final failed attempt that sends him tumbling, perfectly encapsulating the film's blend of determination and comedic frustration.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception for films of this era was limited, as film criticism as we know it today had not yet developed. Trade publications like 'The Moving Picture World' and 'Variety' were just beginning to cover films, but their reviews were typically brief and focused on commercial potential rather than artistic merit. The film was likely noted for its clear narrative and comedic elements, which were considered desirable qualities for the Nickelodeon market. Modern film historians view 'Getting Evidence' as a representative example of Porter's work during this period and an important document of early narrative cinema development. The film is studied for its contribution to the establishment of cinematic language and its role in the evolution of the comedy genre.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1906 would have received 'Getting Evidence' as an entertaining novelty, appreciating its clear story and humorous situations. The detective genre was popular with Nickelodeon audiences, who enjoyed the mix of mystery and comedy. The film's premise would have been particularly engaging to viewers, as photography was still somewhat mysterious and impressive to the general public. The physical comedy and mishaps would have provided the kind of visual entertainment that appealed to the diverse immigrant audiences who frequented early Nickelodeons. The film's length, typical of the era, was perfect for the program format of the time, where multiple short films were shown together to create a varied entertainment experience.

You Might Also Like