His Own Law
Plot
An American soldier marries the widow of his fallen French army comrade after the Frenchman is reported missing in action during World War I. Together they raise the child who was born just before the father departed for the front. Years later, the Frenchman unexpectedly returns after being released from a German prisoner-of-war camp, only to discover his wife has remarried and his child has grown up with another father figure. The dramatic confrontation forces all three adults to confront their loyalties, love, and the complicated moral questions of their situation. The film explores themes of duty, sacrifice, and the lasting impact of war on personal relationships.
About the Production
This film was produced during the early post-World War I period when American audiences were still processing the war's impact. The production took advantage of the growing interest in stories about soldiers returning home and the social changes brought by the war. As a silent film, it relied heavily on visual storytelling and the dramatic abilities of its cast to convey the emotional weight of the story.
Historical Background
His Own Law was released in January 1920, just over a year after the end of World War I. This period saw America grappling with the war's aftermath, including the return of millions of soldiers and the reintegration of veterans into society. The film industry itself was undergoing significant changes, with Hollywood establishing itself as the global center of film production. The 1920s would become known as the Golden Age of silent cinema, with films becoming longer, more sophisticated, and dealing with more complex adult themes. This film's focus on the personal consequences of war reflected a broader cultural shift away from romanticized war stories toward more realistic portrayals of conflict's impact on ordinary lives.
Why This Film Matters
While not a major commercial success, 'His Own Law' represents an important example of how American cinema processed the trauma of World War I through narrative. The film contributed to the emerging genre of 'homecoming' films that dealt with veterans' struggles and the changed social landscape of the post-war era. Its exploration of moral ambiguity and complex family dynamics pushed beyond the simple melodramas common in earlier silent films. The movie also reflects the evolving role of women in society, as the widow character makes independent choices about her future rather than remaining in passive mourning. As an early work dealing with POW experiences, it paved the way for more sophisticated war films that would follow.
Making Of
The production of 'His Own Law' took place during a transitional period in Hollywood when the industry was moving from short films to feature-length productions. J. Parker Read Jr., though better known as a producer, took the directorial helm for this project, likely due to his personal interest in the subject matter. The casting of Hobart Bosworth, a respected veteran of both stage and screen, lent gravitas to the production. The film was shot on location in California, taking advantage of the state's diverse landscapes that could stand in for French settings. As with many silent films, actors had to rely heavily on facial expressions and body language to convey the complex emotions of the story, particularly in scenes dealing with the dramatic revelation of the French soldier's return.
Visual Style
The cinematography of 'His Own Law' employed the techniques typical of high-quality silent films of 1920, including careful composition and the use of lighting to enhance emotional moments. The film likely utilized natural lighting for exterior scenes and sophisticated studio lighting for interior sequences, creating dramatic contrasts that emphasized the characters' emotional states. Close-ups were used strategically to highlight the actors' expressions, particularly in scenes of revelation and conflict. The visual style probably incorporated the soft focus and diffusion techniques popular in the era to create a romantic, dreamlike quality in certain scenes, contrasting with sharper realism in others.
Music
As a silent film, 'His Own Law' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its theatrical run. The score would typically have been provided by a theater's organist or pianist, using cue sheets provided by the studio or improvising based on the action on screen. The music would have ranged from romantic themes during tender moments to dramatic, dissonant passages during scenes of conflict and revelation. The emotional weight of the story would have required a particularly nuanced musical accompaniment to enhance the silent performances and guide audience responses to the complex moral dilemmas presented in the narrative.
Famous Quotes
In war, men make laws for themselves that peace cannot understand.
Some wounds don't heal with time—they just learn to live with the scar.
Duty calls us in many forms, but the heart knows only one truth.
Memorable Scenes
- The dramatic confrontation scene when the French soldier returns and discovers his wife has remarried, creating a powerful moment of emotional conflict that drives the film's central moral dilemma
Did You Know?
- Director J. Parker Read Jr. was primarily known as a producer rather than a director, making this one of his few directorial credits
- Hobart Bosworth was a prominent figure in early Hollywood, having started as an actor in 1908 and transitioning into directing and producing
- Rowland V. Lee, who appears as an actor in this film, would later become a well-known director himself, helming films like 'Son of Frankenstein' (1939)
- The film's theme of soldiers returning from war was particularly relevant in 1920, as many veterans were dealing with readjustment to civilian life
- Jean Calhoun was a popular actress of the silent era who appeared in over 40 films between 1918 and 1930
- This film is one of many produced in the immediate post-WWI period that dealt with the war's aftermath and its effects on families
- The story reflects the real-life situation of many families who lost loved ones in WWI and had to rebuild their lives
- Silent films of this era often used intertitles extensively to convey dialogue and narrative, which would have been crucial for this complex emotional story
What Critics Said
Contemporary reviews of 'His Own Law' were mixed to positive, with critics praising the performances of the lead actors, particularly Hobart Bosworth's portrayal of the American soldier. The film's emotional depth was noted as a strength, though some reviewers felt the story relied too heavily on melodramatic conventions common to the era. Modern film historians view the movie as an interesting artifact of post-WWI cinema, though it's generally considered a minor work compared to the great silent epics of the period. The film's handling of sensitive subject matter was seen as progressive for its time, even if some of its resolutions seem dated by contemporary standards.
What Audiences Thought
Audiences in 1920 responded positively to the film's emotional story and relatable themes of love, duty, and family. The post-war context made the story particularly resonant for viewers who had experienced similar losses or disruptions in their own lives. While the film didn't achieve blockbuster status, it performed respectably in urban theaters where sophisticated dramas found their audience. The movie's exploration of moral complexity appealed to the growing segment of moviegoers who sought more than simple entertainment from their cinema experience. Word-of-mouth about the film's powerful final scenes helped sustain its run in several major markets.
Film Connections
Influenced By
- Other post-WWI dramas
- Stage plays about war's impact
- Contemporary literature about returning soldiers
This Film Influenced
- Later films about POW experiences
- Post-war family dramas of the 1920s
- Movies dealing with soldiers' return home
You Might Also Like
Film Restoration
Unfortunately, 'His Own Law' is considered a lost film, as no complete copies are known to exist in any film archives or private collections. This status is common for films from the early 1920s, with an estimated 75% of American silent films having been lost due to the deterioration of nitrate film stock and inadequate preservation efforts in the early decades of cinema. Only fragments or promotional materials may survive in specialized archives.