The Railway Owner

Plot

Filippo Derblay, a young man of humble origins, rises through his work to become the owner of a major ironworks company. He harbors a secret love for Clara, the daughter of the Marquis of Beaulieu who has lost his entire fortune. Clara is initially engaged to the Duke of Bligny, her vain cousin, but when he learns of her family's financial ruin, he abandons her to marry Atenaide Moulinet, daughter of the wealthy industrialist known as the 'King of Cacao'. Seeking revenge and driven by pride, Clara agrees to marry Filippo despite viewing him as an upstart she despises. However, Filippo, whose love for her is genuine and deep, cannot tolerate being humiliated and sets out to prove her prejudices wrong, ultimately winning her genuine affection through his character and actions.

Historical Background

The Railway Owner was produced in 1919, a crucial year in Italian and world history. Italy had emerged from World War I victorious but economically devastated, with significant social unrest including factory occupations and strikes. The film's themes of class conflict, industrial wealth versus aristocratic decline, and social mobility directly reflected the tensions of post-war Italian society. The Italian film industry, which had dominated international cinema before the war, was struggling to regain its position against American competition. This film represents part of the industry's attempt to create contemporary, socially relevant dramas rather than the historical epics that had characterized Italian cinema's golden age. The year 1919 also saw the rise of fascism in Italy, with Mussolini founding the Fasci Italiani di Combattimento, adding political undertones to films dealing with class and power dynamics.

Making Of

The production of 'The Railway Owner' took place during a pivotal moment in Italian cinema history. Director Eugenio Perego, known for his meticulous attention to visual composition, worked closely with cinematographers to create striking contrasts between the industrial and aristocratic worlds depicted in the film. The casting of Pina Menichelli, already a major star, was significant as she was particularly selective about her roles. The film's production design involved extensive location shooting at actual industrial sites, which was unusual for the time and required special permissions from factory owners. The relationship between Menichelli and director Perego was reportedly collaborative, with the actress having significant input into her character's development. The film's pacing and dramatic structure reflected the influence of both Italian melodrama traditions and emerging more naturalistic approaches to storytelling.

Visual Style

The cinematography of The Railway Owner was particularly noted for its sophisticated use of light and shadow to create dramatic contrasts between different social worlds. The factory sequences employed innovative techniques for capturing industrial machinery and workers, using both wide shots to establish the scale of industrial operations and closer shots to show human interaction with machinery. The cinematographer used natural lighting in many scenes, particularly in the industrial locations, creating a more realistic visual style than was common in studio-bound productions of the era. The aristocratic scenes featured more controlled, artificial lighting that emphasized the artificiality and decay of that social world. The camera work included dynamic movements that were advanced for the time, particularly in scenes showing the operation of machinery and industrial processes.

Innovations

The film's most significant technical achievement was its extensive use of location shooting in actual industrial settings, which was relatively rare for the period. The cinematography employed advanced lighting techniques to capture both the vast scale of industrial operations and intimate character moments. The film's editing, particularly in sequences contrasting industrial and aristocratic life, demonstrated sophisticated narrative techniques for the era. The production design successfully integrated real industrial locations with studio sets, creating a cohesive visual world. The film also showcased advanced techniques in capturing movement, particularly in scenes involving machinery and industrial processes, requiring careful choreography of actors and equipment.

Music

As a silent film, The Railway Owner would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its original theatrical run. The typical score would have been compiled from existing classical pieces and popular melodies, selected by the theater's music director to match the film's mood and action. For dramatic scenes, particularly those featuring Pina Menichelli, passionate romantic music from composers like Chopin or Liszt would have been common. The industrial scenes might have been accompanied by more rhythmic, mechanical-sounding music or martial themes to emphasize the power of industry. No original composed score for the film survives, and modern screenings typically use newly commissioned scores or compilations of period-appropriate music.

Memorable Scenes

• The dramatic sequence where Filippo leads Clara through his ironworks factory, showing her the scale of his industrial empire and the workers who depend on him
• The tense confrontation scene where Clara initially agrees to marry Filippo, her face showing contempt mixed with desperation
• The climactic scene where Filippo proves his worth not through wealth but through character, finally breaking through Clara's prejudices
• The visual contrast sequence cutting between the Duke's superficial aristocratic world and Filippo's substantial industrial domain

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised the film for its sophisticated visual style and Pina Menichelli's powerful performance. The cinematography, particularly the factory sequences, was highlighted as innovative and technically accomplished. Critics noted the film's effective contrast between industrial and aristocratic settings, using visual elements to reinforce the social commentary. Some reviewers of the time found the plot somewhat conventional but appreciated the execution and performances. Modern film historians have revisited the film as an important example of post-war Italian cinema and a significant work in Menichelli's filmography. The film is often cited in studies of the diva film genre and its role in shaping star personas in silent cinema.

What Audiences Thought

The film was reportedly successful with Italian audiences, particularly appealing to viewers interested in contemporary social themes. Pina Menichelli's star power ensured significant initial interest, and the film's dramatic elements and visual spectacle satisfied audience expectations for silent-era melodrama. The class conflict themes resonated with post-war Italian audiences experiencing significant social change. The film's success helped cement Menichelli's status as one of Italy's most popular actresses of the period. However, like many Italian films of this era, its international reach was limited by the dominance of American films in the global market.

You Might Also Like