The Starfish

Plot

The Starfish (L'Étoile de Mer) follows a man who becomes obsessed with a woman he encounters on the street. After following her, he enters her apartment and finds a starfish in a jar, which becomes a recurring symbol throughout the film. The narrative unfolds through a series of fragmented, dreamlike sequences that blend reality with surrealist imagery. The man's pursuit of the woman is portrayed through abstract visual metaphors and experimental cinematographic techniques. The film concludes with the man's ultimate rejection and the starfish returning to the sea, suggesting themes of unattainable desire and the cyclical nature of longing.

Historical Background

The Starfish emerged during the height of the Surrealist movement in Paris, a period of intense artistic experimentation following World War I. The 1920s in Paris saw a convergence of artists, writers, and filmmakers from around the world, all seeking to break with traditional forms and explore the subconscious. The film reflects the influence of Sigmund Freud's theories on the unconscious mind and André Breton's Surrealist manifestos. This was also a time of significant technical innovation in cinema, with filmmakers like Luis Buñuel, Salvador Dalí, and Germaine Dulac pushing the boundaries of what film could express. The interwar period in France was marked by a cultural renaissance, with Paris serving as the undisputed capital of the avant-garde. The film's creation coincided with the peak of the 'Années folles' (Crazy Years), a time of artistic freedom and experimentation that would end with the economic crisis of 1929 and the rise of fascism in Europe.

Making Of

The making of The Starfish was deeply intertwined with the Parisian Surrealist movement of the 1920s. Man Ray, an American expatriate artist, created the film as a collaboration with poet Robert Desnos, who wrote the scenario. The relationship between Man Ray and Kiki of Montparnasse was not only romantic but also artistic, with Kiki serving as his primary model and muse. The film was shot without a formal script, instead relying on spontaneous creation and Surrealist principles of automatic expression. Man Ray utilized his expertise as a photographer to create groundbreaking visual effects, including the famous solarization technique that he had accidentally discovered when a light was accidentally turned on in his darkroom. The production was typical of avant-garde films of the era - low budget, experimental, and created outside the commercial film industry.

Visual Style

The cinematography of The Starfish is revolutionary for its time, featuring multiple innovative techniques that Man Ray adapted from his photographic work. The film employs solarization (a technique that reverses tones and creates a halo effect), negative images, double exposure, and out-of-focus photography to create dreamlike, disorienting effects. Man Ray also used prismatic lenses and distorted reflections to fragment reality. The camera work is deliberately unconventional, with unusual angles and movements that contribute to the film's surreal atmosphere. The interplay of light and shadow creates a mysterious, poetic visual language. The famous starfish sequence uses macro photography to transform the object into an abstract pattern. The cinematography consistently blurs the line between representation and abstraction, creating visual metaphors that operate on both conscious and unconscious levels.

Innovations

The Starfish pioneered several technical innovations that would influence experimental cinema for decades. Man Ray's use of solarization in motion pictures was groundbreaking, creating eerie, dreamlike effects that had never been seen before. The film's seamless integration of photographic techniques into cinema demonstrated new possibilities for visual storytelling. The editing style, which rejects continuity in favor of poetic association, was revolutionary and influenced later filmmakers. The film also demonstrated how found objects could be transformed into powerful cinematic symbols. The use of negative imagery and multiple exposures created visual metaphors that were impossible to achieve through conventional photography. These technical achievements were not merely decorative but essential to the film's meaning and its expression of Surrealist principles.

Music

As a silent film, The Starfish had no original soundtrack or synchronized score. However, when it was first shown, it was often accompanied by live music, typically avant-garde compositions or improvisations that reflected the film's experimental nature. In some screenings, contemporary jazz or atonal piano music was used to enhance the surreal atmosphere. The film's rhythm and pacing were designed to work with musical accompaniment, with visual transitions timed to suggest musical phrases. Modern screenings and restorations sometimes use period-appropriate music or new compositions inspired by the film. The absence of dialogue or intertitles in many versions emphasizes the purely visual nature of the work, making it a true example of pure cinema.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence where the man follows the woman through Paris streets with distorted, dreamlike photography
• The famous scene with the starfish floating in a jar, using macro photography to transform it into an abstract pattern
• The solarized sequences that create ghostly, otherworldly images of the lovers
• The final scene where the starfish returns to the sea, shot through prismatic lenses

What Critics Said

Initial critical reception was divided, with mainstream critics often dismissing the film as incomprehensible or self-indulgent. However, avant-garde circles embraced it enthusiastically, with figures like André Breton praising its revolutionary approach. Surrealist publications hailed it as a breakthrough in cinematic art. Over time, critical opinion has shifted dramatically in the film's favor. Modern critics and film scholars now recognize it as a masterpiece of avant-garde cinema. The film is frequently cited in academic studies of Surrealist art and experimental film. Contemporary critics particularly appreciate its technical innovations and its successful fusion of photographic and cinematic techniques. The film is now regarded as one of Man Ray's most significant artistic achievements and a key work in the history of experimental cinema.

What Audiences Thought

The Starfish was never intended for mass audiences and was primarily shown in avant-garde film clubs, art galleries, and Surrealist gatherings. Its initial audience consisted mainly of artists, writers, and intellectuals who were already familiar with Surrealist principles. These viewers generally received the film positively, appreciating its experimental nature and artistic ambitions. General audiences, when they had the opportunity to see it, were often confused or put off by its non-linear narrative and abstract imagery. The film's challenging nature meant it never achieved popular success, but this was never its goal. Today, the film is primarily viewed by film students, scholars, and enthusiasts of avant-garde cinema, who approach it with an understanding of its historical and artistic context.

You Might Also Like