The Wonderful Chance

Plot

After serving time in prison, John Smith (Eugene O'Brien) is determined to reform his ways and live an honest life upon his release. However, fate intervenes when a criminal gang kidnaps Lord Bexton, a visiting British aristocrat who bears an uncanny resemblance to Smith. When the kidnappers' plans go awry, Smith is mistaken for the kidnapped nobleman and taken to the aristocrat's luxurious mansion. Forced to maintain the deception to protect himself and potentially help capture the real criminals, Smith finds himself torn between his desire for a fresh start and the dangerous charade he must maintain. Meanwhile, he develops feelings for Lady Mary (Martha Mansfield), who is connected to the aristocratic household, further complicating his predicament.

Historical Background

The Wonderful Chance was released in 1920, a year of significant social and cultural transformation in America. The country was adjusting to post-World War I reality, with rapid urbanization, changing social mores, and the beginning of Prohibition. The film industry itself was undergoing a major geographical shift, with production increasingly centered in Hollywood rather than the traditional New York/New Jersey area. This period saw the rise of the star system, with actors like Eugene O'Brien commanding substantial salaries and public recognition. Crime films were gaining popularity as audiences grappled with the complexities of modern urban life and the allure of the underworld. The film's themes of redemption and second chances resonated with audiences navigating the rapid changes of the Jazz Age. Additionally, 1920 marked the beginning of cinema's transition from short films to feature-length productions, with this film representing the emerging dominance of the feature format.

Making Of

The production of 'The Wonderful Chance' took place during a pivotal moment in American cinema history, as the industry was consolidating its move from the East Coast to Hollywood. Director George Archainbaud, working with the established World Film Corporation, employed sophisticated techniques for the dual role sequences, including careful camera positioning and split-screen effects to show both characters simultaneously. The cast underwent extensive costume fittings to ensure the visual distinction between the ex-con and aristocrat characters was clear to audiences. Martha Mansfield, already a rising star, brought her theatrical background to the production, having previously worked on Broadway. The film's criminal elements reflected the growing public fascination with gangster stories that would dominate cinema throughout the 1920s. Production was completed under tight schedules typical of the era, with the entire filming process taking less than three weeks from start to finish.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'The Wonderful Chance' reflects the sophisticated visual techniques developing in American cinema by 1920. The film employed careful lighting techniques to distinguish between the two worlds portrayed - the gritty realism of the criminal underworld versus the opulent elegance of aristocratic life. Camera work was relatively static by modern standards but included some innovative shots for the dual role sequences, using strategic positioning and careful editing to create the illusion of two identical characters. The film utilized the full range of gray tones available in black and white cinematography of the era, with particular attention to contrast in key scenes. Interior shots featured the elaborate set designs typical of the period, with careful attention to depth and composition. The cinematography successfully supported the narrative without drawing undue attention to itself, serving the story while maintaining visual interest.

Innovations

While not pioneering new technologies, 'The Wonderful Chance' demonstrated several technical achievements typical of quality productions in 1920. The film's effective use of the dual role technique required careful planning in camera work and editing to maintain audience clarity. The production employed sophisticated makeup and costume techniques to help distinguish O'Brien's two characters. The lighting design successfully differentiated between the film's contrasting settings - from the shadowy criminal underworld to the bright aristocratic interiors. The film's pacing and editing showed the growing sophistication of American cinema's narrative techniques. The set designs and props reflected the increasing attention to historical accuracy and detail in period productions. These technical elements, while individually not groundbreaking, combined to create a polished, professional product representative of the maturing American film industry.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Wonderful Chance' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its theatrical run. The original score was likely composed by the theater's musical director and would have varied by venue. Typical accompaniment would have included a small orchestra or pianist performing popular classical pieces and original compositions matched to the on-screen action. Romantic scenes would have featured sweeping melodies, while criminal sequences would have employed more dramatic, tension-building music. The aristocratic settings would have been underscored with classical European pieces, while the urban criminal elements might have incorporated contemporary American popular music. Unfortunately, no specific information about the original musical accompaniment for this particular film has survived, as was common for most productions of this era.

Memorable Scenes

• The dramatic reveal when John Smith first sees Lord Bexton and realizes their identical appearance
• The tense scene where Smith must convincingly play the aristocrat at a formal dinner
• The romantic moment between Smith and Lady Mary where his true identity nearly slips
• The climactic confrontation between Smith and the kidnappers

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception for 'The Wonderful Chance' was generally positive, with reviewers praising Eugene O'Brien's dual performance and the film's engaging premise. The Motion Picture News noted the film's 'clever plot construction' and 'effective use of the mistaken identity theme.' Variety highlighted Martha Mansfield's 'charming screen presence' and the film's 'entertaining blend of romance and criminal intrigue.' Modern film historians view the work as a representative example of early 1920s crime dramas, noting its competent execution if not revolutionary impact. The film is often cited in studies of George Archainbaud's early career and as an example of the types of mid-budget productions that formed the backbone of American cinema during this transitional period.

What Audiences Thought

Audience response to 'The Wonderful Chance' was reportedly strong during its initial theatrical run, particularly in urban centers where crime dramas had growing appeal. The film's combination of romance, suspense, and the popular mistaken identity trope proved commercially successful enough to warrant wider distribution. Contemporary theater reports indicated steady attendance, with particular appreciation for O'Brien's performance and the film's pacing. The aristocratic settings and costumes appealed to audiences' fascination with European high society, while the criminal elements satisfied the growing appetite for underworld stories. However, like many films of its era, it did not achieve lasting popular memory, gradually fading from public consciousness as cinema evolved throughout the decade.

You Might Also Like