Too Wise Wives

Plot

In this silent drama, a newlywed wife becomes consumed with jealousy when she believes her husband is still attached to his former sweetheart. The wife's insecurity leads her to spy on her husband and create elaborate schemes to test his loyalty, which only serves to create more tension and misunderstanding in their marriage. As her suspicions grow, the couple's relationship deteriorates, with the wife's friends offering conflicting advice about how to handle the situation. The film explores the destructive nature of jealousy and the importance of trust in marital relationships, culminating in emotional revelations that force both partners to confront their true feelings and the foundations of their marriage.

Historical Background

The film was produced in 1921, during a period of significant social change in America. The post-World War I era saw women gaining more independence, with the 19th Amendment granting them the right to vote in 1920. This was also the beginning of the Jazz Age, with changing attitudes toward marriage, relationships, and women's roles in society. The film reflected contemporary concerns about the institution of marriage, as divorce rates had been rising steadily since the late 19th century. Hollywood itself was undergoing transformation, with the studio system consolidating power and the film industry becoming increasingly professionalized. Lois Weber's position as a prominent female director was particularly remarkable during this era, as the industry was becoming increasingly male-dominated.

Making Of

Lois Weber was a pioneer in early Hollywood, not only as a female director but as a filmmaker who tackled complex social issues. For 'Too Wise Wives,' Weber drew on her own experiences and observations of marriage dynamics in post-WWI America. The production was characterized by Weber's meticulous attention to detail and her insistence on realistic performances from her actors. Claire Windsor, making one of her early film appearances, was coached extensively by Weber to achieve the subtle emotional expressions required for the role. The film was shot on location in Los Angeles, utilizing the city's growing urban landscape to reflect the changing social dynamics of the 1920s. Weber's direction emphasized psychological realism over melodramatic gestures, which was unusual for the period and contributed to the film's sophisticated treatment of its themes.

Visual Style

The cinematography, credited to Oliver T. Marsh, employed the sophisticated visual techniques characteristic of high-quality silent dramas. The film used careful lighting to create mood and emphasize emotional states, particularly in scenes depicting the wife's anxiety and jealousy. Marsh employed soft focus techniques to suggest psychological states and dream sequences, which was innovative for the period. The visual composition emphasized the psychological distance between characters through framing and blocking, reinforcing the themes of marital discord. The film's visual style was more restrained and naturalistic than many contemporary melodramas, reflecting Weber's preference for realism over theatricality.

Innovations

While not groundbreaking in technical terms, the film demonstrated Weber's mastery of cinematic storytelling techniques. The use of close-ups to convey psychological states was particularly effective, especially in scenes featuring Claire Windsor's expressive performance. The film's pacing and editing were sophisticated for the period, with Weber using cross-cutting to build tension between parallel actions. The production values were high, reflecting Weber's status as a major director with access to studio resources. The film's success in conveying complex emotional states without dialogue demonstrated the maturity of silent film as an art form by 1921.

Music

As a silent film, 'Too Wise Wives' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its theatrical run. The original score was likely composed by a studio musician and would have featured popular songs of the era as well as classical pieces adapted to fit the film's emotional tone. The music would have emphasized the psychological tension in key scenes and provided emotional cues for the audience. The soundtrack would have been performed by theater orchestras in larger venues or by pianists in smaller theaters, with the quality of musical accompaniment varying by theater. No original score recordings survive from the film's initial release.

Memorable Scenes

• The scene where the wife spies on her husband through a keyhole, capturing her anxiety and the tension of the moment
• The emotional confrontation between husband and wife where misunderstandings are finally revealed
• The final reconciliation scene where trust is restored and the couple recommits to their marriage

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised 'Too Wise Wives' for its sophisticated treatment of marital themes and its psychological depth. The Motion Picture News noted that the film 'deals with a universal problem in a manner that is both entertaining and thought-provoking.' Variety appreciated Weber's direction, stating that she 'handles the delicate subject matter with remarkable skill and sensitivity.' Modern critics have rediscovered the film as an important example of Weber's social problem films and her contribution to feminist cinema. Film historians have noted that the film's nuanced exploration of female psychology was ahead of its time, and Weber's direction demonstrates the sophisticated storytelling techniques that characterized the best silent dramas.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by audiences in 1921, particularly among women viewers who could relate to its themes of marital insecurity and jealousy. The emotional authenticity of the performances, especially Claire Windsor's portrayal of the anxious wife, resonated with contemporary audiences. The film's exploration of trust and communication in marriage struck a chord with viewers navigating the changing social landscape of post-WWI America. Audience feedback cards and reviews from the period indicate that many viewers found the film both entertaining and socially relevant. The film's commercial success helped solidify Lois Weber's reputation as one of Hollywood's most reliable and innovative directors.

You Might Also Like