Utopia

Plot

Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy inherit a South Seas island called Utopia from their uncle, and set sail with their French chef Antoine and a stowaway refugee named Giovanni to claim their inheritance. Upon arrival, they discover the island is rich in uranium, attracting unwanted attention from various governments and corporations. The boys attempt to establish a perfect society on the island, but their bumbling nature and the interference of outsiders leads to chaos. Their utopian dreams are further complicated when the island's volcano becomes active, threatening to destroy everything. In the end, their attempts at creating paradise fail spectacularly, but they escape with their lives, having learned that utopia is harder to achieve than they imagined.

Historical Background

The film was produced during the early Cold War period, a time of intense anti-communist sentiment in America that led to the Hollywood Blacklist. The replacement of original director John Berry exemplifies this political climate. In post-war Europe, co-productions between countries were becoming more common as the film industry rebuilt itself. The early 1950s also saw the decline of the classic Hollywood studio system and the comedy duo format that had been popular since the 1920s. The film's uranium subplot reflects contemporary anxieties about nuclear energy and the atomic age. Additionally, this was during a period when many American stars were working in Europe due to better tax conditions and creative opportunities.

Making Of

The production of 'Utopia' was plagued with problems from the beginning. The film began shooting in 1950 with director John Berry, but he was replaced by Léo Joannon after being blacklisted. The cast and crew had to deal with language barriers as it was a French-Italian co-production. Both Laurel and Hardy were in poor health - Hardy had undergone prostate surgery and was dealing with diabetes and heart problems, while Laurel was recovering from prostate issues himself. The filming locations in the South of France were beautiful but challenging to work in. The script went through numerous rewrites, and multiple endings were filmed. The production ran out of money multiple times, causing delays. The French and English versions were shot simultaneously, requiring the actors to perform scenes twice. The final editing was chaotic, with different cuts released in different countries.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Raymond Picon-Borel captured the beautiful Mediterranean locations effectively, providing a stark contrast to the chaotic comedy. The Technicolor photography was vibrant for its time, though some critics felt it made the stars' health problems more visible. The island sequences were particularly well-shot, creating a believable tropical paradise. The volcanic eruption scenes used practical effects that were typical of the era but appear dated by modern standards.

Innovations

While not groundbreaking technically, the film did feature some impressive miniature work for the volcanic eruption sequences. The dual-language production was technically challenging for the era, requiring precise synchronization between French and English takes. The underwater sequences were relatively ambitious for the time, though they appear primitive by modern standards.

Music

The musical score was composed by Jean-Jacques Grunenwald, incorporating both comedic and dramatic elements. The film featured several musical numbers, including a scene where the characters attempt to establish their own national anthem. The soundtrack also included traditional South Seas-inspired music to establish the island setting. The French version had different musical arrangements compared to the English release.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence where Stan and Ollie learn about their inheritance and immediately begin planning their paradise
• The chaotic ship journey where everything that can go wrong does go wrong
• The scene where they attempt to write their own constitution and national anthem
• The volcanic eruption climax where they must flee their failed utopia
• The final scene where they reflect on their failed attempt at creating paradise

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics were largely disappointed with 'Utopia'. Many reviews noted that the comedy seemed tired and that both stars appeared frail and unwell. Critics pointed out that the film lacked the energy and creativity of their earlier work. The French version received slightly better reviews than the English version, with some French critics appreciating its satirical elements. Modern critics and film historians view the film with more sympathy, recognizing the difficult circumstances under which it was made and treating it as a poignant final chapter in the duo's career rather than a fair representation of their talents.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception was generally poor, with the film performing badly at the box office in most markets. Many longtime fans of the comedy duo were saddened to see their heroes in such poor health and in what appeared to be a subpar film. The film's limited release in the United States (not until 1954) further hurt its commercial prospects. However, over time, the film has gained a cult following among Laurel and Hardy enthusiasts who appreciate it as a historical artifact and the team's final collaboration.

You Might Also Like