A House Divided

Plot

In this early comedy short, a married couple becomes suspicious of each other's fidelity after a series of misunderstandings and coincidences. Rather than divorcing, they decide to live 'separately together' in the same house, creating comedic tension as they attempt to maintain their independence while sharing living space. The husband and wife each try to prove their own virtue while catching the other in compromising situations, leading to increasingly absurd scenarios. Their elaborate schemes to spy on one another backfire repeatedly, ultimately revealing that both were faithful all along. The film concludes with the couple reconciling after realizing their foolishness, having learned a lesson about trust and communication in marriage.

Historical Background

1913 was a pivotal year in cinema history, occurring during the transition from short films to feature-length productions. The film industry was centered on the East Coast, particularly Fort Lee, New Jersey, where Solax Studios was located. This was also a period of significant advancement in film technology and technique, with directors like Guy-Blaché pushing the boundaries of what could be accomplished in narrative cinema. Women still held prominent positions in the industry during this era, before the studio system would later marginalize them. The film's domestic comedy themes reflected the social concerns of the Progressive Era, when questions about marriage, gender roles, and family life were widely debated in American society.

Making Of

Alice Guy-Blaché was a pioneer who had been making films since the 1890s, first in France and then in America. By 1913, she was running her own studio and had developed a distinctive directorial style that emphasized naturalistic acting and innovative camera work. The casting of Fraunie Fraunholz, Marian Swayne, and Vinnie Burns reflects Guy-Blaché's use of regular Solax players who were familiar with her directing methods. The film was likely shot quickly, as was common for one-reel comedies of the era, but under Guy-Blaché's supervision, it would have maintained high production values. The domestic setting allowed for elaborate set design within the studio space, and the comedic situations required precise timing and physical comedy skills from the actors.

Visual Style

The cinematography would have employed techniques typical of 1913, including static camera positions with occasional movement for dramatic effect. Given Guy-Blaché's reputation as an innovator, the film might have featured more dynamic camera work than was common at the time. The domestic setting would have allowed for careful composition within interior spaces, with attention to lighting that could create mood and highlight comedic moments. The film stock of the era required significant lighting, and the cinematographer would have needed to balance artistic considerations with the technical limitations of early film equipment.

Innovations

While this film likely didn't feature groundbreaking technical innovations, it benefited from the professional production standards of Solax Studios. The film would have used the standard 35mm format of the era and might have employed techniques like double exposure or split screen if the narrative required visual effects to show the couple's separate activities within the shared house. Guy-Blaché was known for her attention to technical details and might have incorporated subtle camera movements or editing techniques that advanced the storytelling beyond the static shots common in many early films.

Music

As a silent film, 'A House Divided' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during exhibition. The specific musical score would have varied by theater and performance, with pianists or small ensembles providing appropriate accompaniment. For a comedy, the music would likely have been light and playful, with musical cues timed to enhance the comedic moments. Some theaters might have used compiled scores drawing from popular classical pieces, while others might have had original compositions created specifically for the film.

Memorable Scenes

• The scene where the couple first decides to 'live separately together' and begins dividing their shared space with imaginary lines or barriers would likely have been a key comedic moment. The various hiding places and spying techniques employed by each spouse to catch the other in suspicious behavior would have provided opportunities for physical comedy and visual gags typical of the era.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception of this specific film is not well documented, which was typical for short comedies of the era. Trade publications like Variety and The Moving Picture World likely reviewed it briefly, focusing on its entertainment value. Modern film historians recognize Alice Guy-Blaché's work as historically significant, though individual films like this are often studied more for their place in her filmography than for their standalone merits. The film is generally viewed by scholars as an example of Guy-Blaché's skill with domestic comedy and her ability to combine entertainment with subtle social commentary.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception data for specific short films from 1913 is largely unavailable, though comedies about domestic situations were popular with early film audiences. The theme of marital discord and reconciliation would have been relatable to contemporary viewers. The physical comedy elements would have appealed to the diverse audiences of nickelodeons and early movie theaters. As part of Solax's output, the film likely benefited from the studio's reputation for quality productions and may have been well-received by audiences familiar with the work of its featured actors.

You Might Also Like