An Eastern Westerner

Plot

In this classic Harold Lloyd comedy, a wealthy young man from New York City is constantly disappointing his father with his irresponsible behavior and wild nights of carousing. Frustrated with his son's lifestyle, the father sends him to his brother's ranch in the American West, hoping the rugged environment will reform him. Upon arrival in the dusty town of Piute Pass, the Easterner discovers the community is living in fear of the notorious outlaw Tiger Lip Tompkins and his gang, the Masked Angels. He befriends a young local woman whose father has been taken captive by Tompkins, and despite his urban upbringing and initial cowardice, he decides to help rescue her father and rid the town of the criminal element. Through a series of comedic mishaps and unexpected displays of courage, the city slicker proves that even an Easterner can become a Western hero.

Historical Background

Released in 1920, 'An Eastern Westerner' emerged during a transformative period in American cinema and society. The film industry was transitioning from short films to features, and comedy was one of the most popular genres. The year 1920 also marked the beginning of Prohibition and the Jazz Age, creating cultural tensions between traditional American values and modern urban lifestyles that the film explores through its East vs. West theme. The Western genre was at its peak popularity during this era, reflecting America's ongoing fascination with frontier mythology and the closing of the American frontier. The film also coincided with the rise of the automobile culture, which plays a role in the opening scenes set in New York. Post-World War I America was experiencing rapid social change, and films like this provided audiences with escapist entertainment while also addressing contemporary themes of urbanization, traditional values, and American identity.

Making Of

The production of 'An Eastern Westerner' took place during a pivotal period in Harold Lloyd's career, as he was developing the screen persona that would make him one of the most successful comedians of the 1920s. Director Hal Roach, who ran his own studio, gave Lloyd considerable creative freedom in developing his characters and gags. The film's Western setting allowed Lloyd to parody the popular genre while incorporating his signature physical comedy. The production team faced challenges in creating authentic-looking Western scenes on a limited budget, often using creative camera angles and selective set dressing to suggest expansive landscapes. The relationship between Lloyd and co-star Mildred Davis was developing both on and off screen during this period, adding natural chemistry to their scenes together. The film's action sequences required careful planning, as Lloyd insisted on performing many dangerous stunts himself, a practice that would later lead to a near-fatal accident on the set of another film.

Visual Style

The cinematography in 'An Eastern Westerner' was typical of high-quality Hal Roach productions of the era, featuring clear, well-composed shots that effectively served both the comedy and the narrative. The film employed a mix of studio and location photography, with the Western scenes shot on outdoor sets and actual California ranches to provide authentic backgrounds. The camera work emphasized Lloyd's physical comedy through careful framing that captured his full range of motion during gags and stunts. The film utilized the standard 1.33:1 aspect ratio of silent films, with the cinematographer using depth of field to create dynamic compositions in the Western town scenes. The lighting techniques of the period, primarily natural light for outdoor scenes and studio lighting for interiors, created the high-contrast look characteristic of 1920s cinema. The film's action sequences featured innovative camera movements for the time, including tracking shots that followed Lloyd's character through chase scenes.

Innovations

While 'An Eastern Westerner' was not groundbreaking in terms of technical innovation, it demonstrated the high production values typical of Hal Roach Studios. The film featured effective use of location shooting combined with studio work to create convincing Western settings. The action sequences required sophisticated stunt coordination and timing, particularly in scenes involving horseback riding and physical confrontations. The film's editing was notable for its rhythm and pacing, effectively building comedic tension and delivering punchlines with precision. The production utilized the latest film stock and processing techniques of 1920, resulting in clear, well-preserved images that have survived remarkably well. The film's special effects, while simple by modern standards, included clever use of camera tricks and props to enhance the comedy. The sound stage construction for the Western town sets demonstrated the growing sophistication of Hollywood set design during this period.

Music

As a silent film, 'An Eastern Westerner' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its original theatrical run. The typical accompaniment would have included a pianist or small orchestra performing a compilation of popular songs and classical pieces selected to match the on-screen action. The music would have ranged from jaunty, upbeat tunes during comedy sequences to more dramatic, suspenseful pieces during the confrontations with Tiger Lip Tompkins. Western-themed compositions would have been used for the ranch and town scenes, while sophisticated urban music would have accompanied the New York sequences. The film's intertitles were presented with musical accompaniment that helped set the tone for each scene. Modern screenings of restored versions often feature newly composed scores that attempt to recreate the musical experience of the 1920s while incorporating contemporary musical sensibilities.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence showing Harold's character's wild lifestyle in New York City, featuring elaborate party scenes and his father's exasperated reaction
• Harold's arrival in Piute Pass, where his Eastern attire and mannerisms immediately mark him as an outsider
• The comedic scene where Harold attempts to ride a horse for the first time, resulting in a series of physical gags and falls
• The confrontation with Tiger Lip Tompkins and the Masked Angels, where Harold must use his wits rather than brawn
• The climactic rescue sequence where Harold, despite his fear, manages to save the day through cleverness and unexpected courage

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised 'An Eastern Westerner' for its fresh take on the Western genre and Harold Lloyd's energetic performance. The Motion Picture News noted that 'Lloyd brings his usual comedic genius to the Western setting with delightful results.' Variety highlighted the film's 'clever gags and well-executed action sequences,' particularly praising the chemistry between Lloyd and Davis. Modern film historians view the short as an important transitional work in Lloyd's career, demonstrating his development of the character that would make him one of the three giants of silent comedy alongside Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton. Critics today appreciate the film's role in establishing the 'city slicker in the West' trope that would influence countless later comedies. The film is often cited as an example of how Lloyd successfully blended physical comedy with character-driven humor, creating a more accessible and relatable style than some of his contemporaries.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by audiences in 1920, who were growing increasingly fond of Harold Lloyd's screen persona. Movie theaters reported strong attendance for the short, particularly in urban areas where audiences related to the Eastern protagonist's fish-out-of-water predicament. The film's blend of comedy and Western action appealed to a broad demographic, from working-class moviegoers to middle-class audiences. Contemporary audience letters and reviews in trade publications indicate that viewers particularly enjoyed the contrast between Lloyd's refined Eastern character and the rugged Western setting. The film's success helped establish Lloyd as a major box office draw, paving the way for his transition to feature-length films. Modern audiences who have seen the film through screenings at film festivals and archives continue to appreciate its timeless humor and Lloyd's remarkable physical comedy skills.

You Might Also Like