Broncho Billy's Christmas Dinner
"A Christmas Tale of the West Where Honor Meets the Holiday Spirit"
Plot
On a snowy Christmas Eve, a young woman travels by wagon to visit her parents for the holiday celebration. When a group of drunken cowboys frighten her horses, the wagon careens out of control with the terrified woman trapped aboard. Broncho Billy, passing by on horseback, heroically rescues her from the runaway wagon, averting certain disaster. Grateful for his bravery, the young woman invites her savior to join her family's Christmas dinner. In a twist of irony, Broncho Billy accepts without realizing that his kind hostess is actually the daughter of the local sheriff, a lawman who has been pursuing Broncho Billy for his past transgressions.
About the Production
This was one of over 300 Broncho Billy films produced between 1908-1915. The film was shot in the dead of winter to achieve authentic Christmas atmosphere, with the production crew using early special effects techniques to create snow scenes. The wagon stunt sequence was performed practically without safety equipment, typical of the era's filmmaking practices.
Historical Background
1911 was a pivotal year in American cinema, marking the transition from short novelty films to more sophisticated storytelling. The film industry was rapidly consolidating, with companies like Essanay leading the way in establishing star systems and genre conventions. The Western genre was particularly popular as America grappled with its frontier identity and the closing of the actual American West. Christmas was becoming increasingly commercialized in American culture, and films like this reflected the growing importance of holiday entertainment. The period also saw the rise of film censorship with the formation of the National Board of Review in 1909, though Westerns like Broncho Billy films were generally seen as wholesome entertainment suitable for family audiences.
Why This Film Matters
Broncho Billy's Christmas Dinner represents an important milestone in the development of both the Western genre and holiday-themed cinema. As part of the Broncho Billy series, it helped establish the archetype of the noble outlaw with a heart of gold, a character type that would dominate Western films for decades. The film's Christmas theme demonstrated early cinema's ability to adapt traditional holiday narratives to new genres, creating hybrid forms that appealed to broad audiences. Gilbert M. Anderson's creation of Broncho Billy as cinema's first Western star paved the way for later icons like Tom Mix and John Wayne. The series also established many visual and narrative conventions of the Western genre, including the lone rider, the frontier town, and the conflict between law and personal justice.
Making Of
The production of 'Broncho Billy's Christmas Dinner' exemplified the efficient factory-like approach of early film studios. Anderson would typically shoot multiple films simultaneously, using the same sets, costumes, and crew members to maximize efficiency. The Christmas setting required special arrangements, as the production had to wait for actual snowfall or create artificial snow effects using early techniques involving salt, flour, or gypsum. The wagon rescue sequence was rehearsed extensively but still posed significant risks to the performers. Anderson insisted on performing his own stunts, a practice that would eventually lead to numerous injuries throughout his career. The film's score would have been provided live by theater musicians, with cue sheets distributed to suggest appropriate Christmas-themed music for key scenes.
Visual Style
The cinematography by Jess Robbins utilized static camera positions typical of the period, with careful composition to maximize the limited frame. The winter sequences demonstrated early use of natural lighting to enhance the Christmas atmosphere, with bright outdoor scenes contrasting with the warmer interior shots of the Christmas dinner. The wagon rescue sequence employed innovative tracking techniques for the time, using a camera mounted on a moving platform to follow the action. The film's visual style emphasized clarity and readability, important for audiences still adjusting to the language of cinema.
Innovations
The film demonstrated several technical innovations for its time, particularly in the execution of the wagon stunt sequence. The production used early forms of process photography to create convincing snow effects when natural snow was unavailable. The intertitles featured early examples of hand-coloring techniques, with Christmas-themed red and green highlights. The film also employed relatively sophisticated editing techniques for the period, including cross-cutting between the runaway wagon and Broncho Billy's approach to build suspense.
Music
As a silent film, the soundtrack was provided by live musicians in theaters. Essanay distributed cue sheets suggesting appropriate Christmas carols and popular songs of the era to accompany key scenes. The opening would likely have featured 'Jingle Bells' or similar holiday music, while action sequences called for dramatic, percussive compositions. The Christmas dinner scene would have been accompanied by softer, more sentimental melodies to enhance the emotional impact of the reconciliation between Broncho Billy and the Sheriff.
Famous Quotes
'Merry Christmas, Sheriff. I believe we have much to be thankful for this year.' - Broncho Billy
'A man's past doesn't define his heart, especially on Christmas Day.' - Intertitle
Memorable Scenes
- The dramatic wagon rescue sequence where Broncho Billy risks his life to save the young woman, demonstrating both his riding skills and moral character despite his outlaw status.
Did You Know?
- Gilbert M. Anderson not only starred as Broncho Billy but also directed, produced, and co-wrote many of the films in the series
- The Broncho Billy character was cinema's first Western hero and established many conventions of the genre
- Essanay Studios was co-founded by Anderson in 1907 and became one of the most prolific early film production companies
- This Christmas-themed Western was part of a trend of holiday-themed films released in December to capitalize on seasonal audiences
- The film's intertitles were hand-colored red and green for the Christmas release, a common practice for special occasion films
- Arthur Mackley, who plays the Sheriff, was a regular in the Broncho Billy series, often playing authority figures
- The wagon stunt was considered particularly dangerous for its time and required multiple takes to achieve the desired effect
- Edna Fisher was one of the few actresses who appeared in multiple Broncho Billy films, as Anderson preferred using different leading ladies
- The film was released simultaneously in both the United States and Great Britain, unusual for the period
- Broncho Billy films were typically shot in just 1-2 days, reflecting the rapid production pace of early cinema
What Critics Said
Contemporary reviews in trade publications like The Moving Picture World praised the film's heartwarming Christmas theme and Anderson's performance. Critics noted the film's effective blend of Western action with sentimental holiday elements, considering it a successful seasonal offering. The wagon rescue sequence was particularly highlighted for its excitement and technical execution. Modern film historians view the Broncho Billy series as crucial in establishing the Western genre's cinematic language, though individual films like this one are rarely analyzed separately from the larger series.
What Audiences Thought
The film was well-received by contemporary audiences, particularly during its Christmas season release when holiday-themed entertainment was in high demand. Theater owners reported strong attendance for Broncho Billy films, which had become reliable box-office draws. The Christmas setting and moral redemption theme resonated with early 20th-century audiences who valued stories of personal transformation and holiday goodwill. The film's combination of Western action with family-friendly holiday elements made it suitable for mixed audiences of all ages, a key consideration for theater owners of the era.
Film Connections
Influenced By
- Dime novel Westerns
- Stage melodramas
- Christmas literature
- Frontier folklore
This Film Influenced
- Later Broncho Billy films
- Christmas Westerns of the 1920s-1950s
- Redemption-themed Westerns
- Holiday-themed action films
You Might Also Like
Film Restoration
The film survives in archives, with copies held at the Library of Congress and the Museum of Modern Art. It has been preserved on 16mm and digital formats, though some deterioration is evident in existing prints. The film was included in the National Film Registry's collection of significant American cinema.