Her Crowning Glory

Plot

In this domestic comedy, a recently widowed father becomes increasingly infatuated with his young daughter's attractive governess, much to the dismay of both his child and the household nurse. The governess, aware of the widower's attentions, begins to manipulate the situation to her advantage, creating tension within the household. The daughter, feeling neglected and protective of her mother's memory, teams up with the loyal nurse to expose the governess's true intentions. Through a series of comedic misunderstandings and clever schemes, the truth about the governess's character is revealed. The film concludes with the widower coming to his senses and restoring harmony to the family, while the governess receives her comeuppance.

Historical Background

1911 was a pivotal year in American cinema, marking the transition from the novelty era of film to a period of increased artistic sophistication and industry consolidation. The film industry was centered primarily in New York and New Jersey, with Hollywood not yet established as the film capital. The Vitagraph Company of America, which produced this film, was one of the 'Big Five' studios of the era, along with Biograph, Edison, Essanay, and Kalem. This period saw the rise of film stars, with John Bunny being among the first American actors to achieve celebrity status through motion pictures. The year also witnessed significant technological advancements, including improvements in film stock quality and camera movement capabilities. Socially, 1911 America was experiencing rapid industrialization and urbanization, with a growing middle class that formed the primary audience for these domestic comedies. The Progressive Era was in full swing, bringing changes in social attitudes and values that were reflected in the moral lessons embedded in films of this period.

Making Of

The production of 'Her Crowning Glory' took place during a formative period in American cinema when the film industry was establishing itself as a legitimate entertainment medium. The Vitagraph Studios in Brooklyn, where this film was likely shot, was one of the most sophisticated production facilities of its time. Director Laurence Trimble, who had a background in both acting and directing, brought a polished approach to these domestic comedies. The chemistry between John Bunny and Flora Finch was well-established by 1911, having appeared in numerous films together since 1910. Bunny, a former vaudeville performer, brought theatrical timing to his film work, while Finch's background in stage comedy complemented his style. The film would have been shot quickly, likely in one or two days, with minimal retakes due to the cost of film stock. The sets were simple but detailed, reflecting Vitagraph's commitment to production quality. The young Helene Costello, who played the daughter, was already an experienced child actress having appeared in films since 1909.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'Her Crowning Glory' would have been typical of Vitagraph productions of 1911, featuring relatively static camera positions with occasional pans to follow action. The film was likely shot on 35mm black and white film stock using hand-cranked cameras, resulting in variable frame rates that contribute to the distinctive rhythm of silent films. Vitagraph was known for its higher production values, so the lighting would have been more carefully controlled than in many contemporary productions. The studio's glass-enclosed stages allowed for the use of natural light supplemented by arc lamps, creating a more naturalistic look than was common at the time. Composition would have followed theatrical conventions, with actors positioned to create clear visual relationships and emotional emphasis. The film would have featured medium shots and close-ups, techniques that were still relatively new in 1911 but increasingly used to convey emotion and detail. The domestic setting allowed for detailed set dressing that added visual interest and authenticity to the scenes.

Innovations

While 'Her Crowning Glory' was not a groundbreaking film in terms of technical innovation, it benefited from Vitagraph's commitment to production quality and the general technological improvements occurring in the film industry during this period. The film was likely shot using improved film stock that offered better image quality and consistency than earlier materials. Vitagraph was among the studios experimenting with artificial lighting techniques, allowing for more controlled and visually appealing images. The editing would have been more sophisticated than in earlier films, with clearer narrative continuity and more refined pacing. The use of intertitles would have been more polished, with better typography and more concise wording than in previous years. The film's production would have benefited from the increasing standardization of film equipment and practices, leading to more consistent technical quality across productions. While not revolutionary, these incremental improvements contributed to the overall professionalism and watchability of the film.

Music

As a silent film, 'Her Crowning Glory' would have been accompanied by live music during theatrical exhibitions. The type of musical accompaniment would have varied depending on the theater's resources, ranging from a single piano in smaller venues to small orchestras in more prestigious theaters. Vitagraph often provided cue sheets with their films, suggesting appropriate musical pieces for different scenes. For a domestic comedy like this, the music would likely have included popular songs of the era, classical pieces, and specially composed mood music. The governess scenes might have been accompanied by romantic or waltz music, while the comedic elements would have been enhanced with lighter, more playful selections. The tempo and volume of the music would have been adjusted to match the action on screen, with dramatic moments receiving more intense musical treatment. The practice of providing musical suggestions with films was becoming increasingly common by 1911, helping to standardize the viewing experience across different venues.

Memorable Scenes

• The scene where the governess deliberately 'accidentally' drops her handkerchief to attract the widower's attention, demonstrating her manipulative nature through subtle gestures and expressions.

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of 'Her Crowning Glory' and similar Vitagraph comedies were generally positive, with critics praising the naturalistic acting style of John Bunny and the chemistry between the leads. The New York Dramatic Mirror, a leading trade paper of the era, often commended Vitagraph productions for their quality and attention to detail. Critics noted that Bunny's performances brought a dignity and warmth to comedy that elevated it above mere slapstick. The film's domestic setting and moral undertones were frequently mentioned as positive attributes that made it suitable for family viewing. Modern film historians view these early comedies as important documents of their time, though they acknowledge that their pacing and humor may seem dated to contemporary audiences. The preservation of these films has allowed scholars to study the early development of film comedy and the establishment of narrative conventions that continue to influence cinema today.

What Audiences Thought

The 'Bunnyfinches' films, including 'Her Crowning Glory,' were extremely popular with audiences of their time, making John Bunny one of the highest-paid actors in early American cinema. The relatable domestic situations and the comforting familiarity of the recurring characters created a loyal following among middle-class moviegoers. The films were particularly successful in urban areas where the growing middle class had disposable income for entertainment. Audience feedback from the period suggests that viewers appreciated the films' combination of humor with moral lessons, which made them feel respectable as family entertainment. The popularity of these comedies helped establish cinema as a regular social activity rather than a novelty attraction. Bunny's Everyman quality made him particularly beloved, with audiences seeing elements of themselves or people they knew in his characters. The films' success was such that other studios attempted to create similar domestic comedy series, though none achieved the same level of popularity as the Vitagraph productions.

You Might Also Like