The Corsican Brothers

Plot

The Corsican Brothers tells the story of identical twins, Louis and Lucien de Franchi, who are born with the extraordinary ability to feel each other's physical pain and emotions. Separated at birth when their family is betrayed by the evil Baron de Montaigne, Louis remains in Corsica while Lucien is sent to Paris for education. As adults, Louis becomes a bandit leader fighting injustice in Corsica, while Lucien rises in Parisian society. When Lucien falls in love with the beautiful Emilie de Varenne, who is also desired by Baron de Montaigne, the brothers' psychic connection intensifies. After Lucien is mortally wounded by the Baron in a duel over Emilie, Louis feels his brother's pain across the distance and travels to Paris to seek vengeance, ultimately confronting their family's enemy in a dramatic final showdown that unites the brothers in their quest for justice and redemption.

Historical Background

The Corsican Brothers was produced in 1920, during a transformative period in American cinema. The film industry was transitioning from short films to feature-length productions, with studios like Fox investing heavily in literary adaptations to attract middle-class audiences. Post-World War I America was experiencing economic prosperity and cultural change, with movies becoming the dominant form of entertainment. The year 1920 also saw the beginning of Prohibition, which ironically boosted theater attendance as people sought new forms of entertainment. The film's themes of revenge, family loyalty, and justice resonated with audiences who had recently experienced the trauma of war. This period also marked the peak of Dustin Farnum's career, as he was one of the last major stars from the pre-war era still commanding top billing. The film's production coincided with technical innovations in cinematography, allowing for more sophisticated visual storytelling.

Making Of

The production of The Corsican Brothers faced several challenges typical of the silent era. Creating the psychic connection between the twin brothers required innovative camera work by cinematographer John W. Brown, who used a combination of double exposure and split-screen techniques. The duel sequences required weeks of rehearsal with the actors learning authentic 18th century fencing techniques. Director Colin Campbell was known for his hands-on approach, often operating the camera himself during crucial scenes. The film's elaborate costumes were designed by Fox's head costume designer, who researched period clothing extensively. The production was delayed for two weeks when Winifred Kingston suffered a minor injury during a horseback riding scene, but she recovered quickly to complete filming. The film's score was compiled from classical pieces, including works by French composers to enhance the Corsican setting.

Visual Style

John W. Brown's cinematography in The Corsican Brothers showcased several innovative techniques for 1920. The film employed extensive use of double exposure to create the psychic connection between the twins, with careful timing to show one brother reacting to the other's pain. The split-screen sequences were particularly advanced for the time, allowing both brothers to appear simultaneously in the same frame. Brown utilized natural lighting for the outdoor Corsican scenes, creating a stark contrast with the more elaborately lit Paris interiors. The camera work included dynamic tracking shots during the chase sequences, demonstrating the increasing mobility of film cameras. The duel scenes were filmed with careful attention to framing, using deep focus to capture both combatants clearly. The cinematography also featured soft focus techniques for romantic scenes and dramatic lighting for confrontations. The film's visual style helped establish the emotional tone through lighting choices, with warm tones for family scenes and cold blues for moments of danger.

Innovations

The Corsican Brothers featured several technical innovations for its time. The twin effect sequences required pioneering work in double exposure and matte photography, techniques that were still being refined in 1920. The film's editing was particularly sophisticated for the era, with cross-cutting between the brothers to build tension during their psychic connections. The production used newly developed panchromatic film stock for some outdoor scenes, which provided better tonal range than the orthochromatic film typically used. The duel sequences featured innovative camera angles, including low shots that emphasized the dramatic height differences between combatants. The film's intertitles were artistically integrated into the visual composition, sometimes appearing as part of the set design rather than as separate cards. The production also experimented with color tinting, using blue tones for night scenes and amber for daylight sequences. These technical achievements demonstrated Fox Film Corporation's commitment to pushing the boundaries of cinematic technology.

Music

As a silent film, The Corsican Brothers featured a compiled musical score performed live in theaters. The recommended score included classical pieces by French composers such as Lully and Rameau to establish the 18th-century setting. Theater organists were instructed to use minor keys during scenes of psychic connection and dramatic chords during moments of danger. The love theme was adapted from a popular French folk song, providing cultural authenticity to the romance between Lucien and Emilie. Fox provided detailed cue sheets to theaters, specifying which musical pieces should accompany each scene. The score also included original compositions by Fox's music department, created specifically for the film's more dramatic moments. The musical accompaniment was crucial for conveying the emotional connection between the brothers, as the intertitles alone could not fully express their psychic bond. Some larger theaters employed small orchestras for the film's premiere runs, enhancing the epic quality of the production.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence showing the twins' birth and immediate psychic connection as they both cry simultaneously despite being in different rooms
• The dramatic duel scene where Lucien is mortally wounded, intercut with Louis feeling the wound in Corsica miles away
• The reunion of the brothers in Paris, where they recognize each other through their psychic bond despite years of separation
• The final confrontation with Baron de Montaigne, where both brothers combine their strength to defeat their family's enemy
• The romantic balcony scene between Lucien and Emilie, featuring innovative night photography and soft focus techniques

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised The Corsican Brothers for its ambitious storytelling and Dustin Farnum's dual performance. The Motion Picture News called it 'a stirring tale of brotherly love and vengeance, beautifully rendered by Fox's finest.' Variety noted that 'Farnum's portrayal of the twins is nothing short of remarkable, capturing both the physical and emotional connection between the brothers.' The film's technical achievements, particularly the twin effects, were highlighted in several trade publications. Modern critics have had limited opportunity to evaluate the film due to its incomplete preservation status, but film historians consider it an important example of early 1920s literary adaptations. The film is often cited in studies of Dustin Farnum's career as representing his transition from western star to dramatic actor. Some contemporary critics felt the psychic connection elements were melodramatic, but acknowledged that they were handled with relative subtlety for the era.

What Audiences Thought

The Corsican Brothers was moderately successful at the box office, particularly in urban areas where literary adaptations were popular. Audiences responded positively to Dustin Farnum's performance, with many theater owners reporting strong attendance during its initial run. The film's romantic elements and action sequences appealed to both male and female viewers, making it a solid date movie of its time. Some audience members found the psychic connection between the brothers confusing, though most appreciated the dramatic tension it created. The film performed particularly well in theaters that featured live musical accompaniment, as the emotional score enhanced the viewing experience. Despite not being a blockbuster, the film earned enough to be considered a success for Fox and helped maintain Dustin Farnum's star status. Word-of-mouth was generally positive, with many viewers recommending it to friends who enjoyed romantic adventure stories.

You Might Also Like