The Hobo

Plot

Billy West plays a hobo who loiters around a busy train station, creating chaos wherever he goes. The film follows his misadventures as he first disrupts operations in the ticket office, confusing the clerk and causing mayhem with other passengers. He then moves to the lunch counter where his antics escalate, interfering with customers and staff alike. The hobo's disruptive behavior culminates in a series of slapstick encounters with various travelers, including romantic entanglements and misunderstandings. The comedy builds through escalating physical gags and situational humor, typical of the silent era's style. Eventually, his presence creates a domino effect of comic disasters throughout the station before his inevitable departure.

Historical Background

1917 was a pivotal year in cinema history, occurring during World War I and at the height of the silent film era. The United States had just entered the war in April 1917, and films served as both propaganda and escapist entertainment for audiences. Comedy shorts like 'The Hobo' were particularly popular as they provided relief from war-related anxieties. The film industry was centered in Hollywood, with studios like King Bee churning out content to meet the massive demand from the growing network of movie theaters across America. This period also saw the rise of feature-length films, though short comedies remained a staple of theater programming. Charlie Chaplin was at the peak of his fame in 1917, which explains the proliferation of Chaplin imitators like Billy West. The film industry was also dealing with technological limitations, with cameras being bulky and lighting challenges requiring outdoor shooting or specially constructed glass studios.

Making Of

The production of 'The Hobo' was typical of the factory-like efficiency of silent comedy studios. King Bee Studios specialized in rapid-fire production of two-reel comedies, often completing films in just a few days. Billy West, the star, was under contract to produce multiple films per month, leading to formulaic but efficient filmmaking. The train station set was a permanent fixture on the King Bee lot, reused for multiple productions. Oliver Hardy, who would later become half of the legendary comedy duo Laurel and Hardy, was still building his career and appeared in numerous supporting roles during this period. Director Arvid E. Gillstrom worked with a small crew and relied heavily on improvisation and the physical comedy skills of his actors. The film was likely shot in sequence to save time and maintain continuity in the gags.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'The Hobo' was typical of 1917 comedy shorts, utilizing static camera positions and wide shots to capture the physical comedy and action. The camera was likely hand-cranked, resulting in variable frame rates that could exaggerate the speed of movements for comic effect. The train station setting allowed for natural lighting through large windows or glass ceilings, common in studio sets of the era. The cinematographer would have focused on ensuring clear visibility of the actors' movements and expressions, crucial for silent comedy. Long takes were probably used extensively to maintain the flow of gags and minimize editing. The visual style prioritized clarity and functionality over artistic innovation, serving the comedy rather than creating distinctive imagery.

Innovations

The film does not feature notable technical achievements, as it was a standard production for its time and budget level. The technical aspects were functional rather than innovative, using established techniques of the period. The film was likely shot on 35mm film with standard cameras of the era. Editing would have been done on flatbed editors with manual splicing techniques. The train station set construction represents the studio system's efficiency in creating reusable locations. The film's value lies not in technical innovation but in its preservation of early comedy filmmaking techniques and the documentation of performers before they achieved greater fame. The production represents the industrial efficiency of the Hollywood studio system during the silent era.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Hobo' had no synchronized soundtrack. During its original theatrical run, it would have been accompanied by live music, typically a pianist or small theater orchestra. The musical accompaniment would have been improvised or selected from standard mood music libraries, with upbeat, jaunty tunes for comedic moments and more dramatic music for tension scenes. The score would have followed the action closely, emphasizing physical gags with musical stings and maintaining energy throughout. Modern screenings of the film often feature newly composed scores or period-appropriate music to recreate the silent film experience. The lack of dialogue meant that music played a crucial role in setting tone and enhancing the comedic timing of the visual gags.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence where Billy West's hobo character disrupts the ticket office, creating confusion among passengers and staff
• The lunch counter scene featuring escalating food-related gags and physical comedy
• The climactic chase sequence through the train station involving multiple characters and slapstick mishaps

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception for 'The Hobo' was minimal, as comedy shorts of this era rarely received detailed reviews from trade papers. The film was likely evaluated primarily on its entertainment value and gag effectiveness rather than artistic merit. Modern critics and film historians view the film primarily as a historical artifact, notable for featuring Oliver Hardy before his partnership with Stan Laurel and as an example of the Chaplin imitation phenomenon. The film is generally considered typical of its genre and period - competent but not exceptional. Some silent film enthusiasts appreciate the film for its representation of early comedy techniques and the opportunity to see Hardy in an early role. The film serves as an important document for understanding the commercial film industry of the 1910s and the star system that produced such content.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception in 1917 was likely positive, as comedy shorts were reliable crowd-pleasers during theater programs. The familiar gags and physical comedy would have entertained audiences seeking lighthearted entertainment during wartime. Billy West's Chaplin-esque character was recognizable to audiences of the period, though he never achieved Chaplin's level of popularity. The film's brief runtime and straightforward humor made it suitable for the varied programming of movie theaters, which typically included newsreels, short subjects, and feature films. Modern audiences encountering the film through archives or special screenings often appreciate it as a window into early comedy styles, though some may find the pacing and humor dated compared to later comedy classics.

You Might Also Like