The Tenth Symphony

Plot

Composer Enrid Damor lives in blissful ignorance about his wife Eve Dinant's scandalous past as the mistress of the adventurer Fred Ryce. When Fred reappears in their lives, he sets his sights on Damor's innocent daughter Claire, attempting to marry her while simultaneously blackmailing Eve about her former life. As Enrid gradually uncovers the truth about his wife's past and Fred's manipulative schemes, he channels his anguish and betrayal into composing his masterpiece - The Tenth Symphony. The film culminates in a powerful sequence where the symphony becomes the ultimate expression of his pain, with the music serving as a metaphor for his emotional journey from innocence to devastating knowledge. This tragic tale of artistic creation born from personal suffering explores how art can transform human suffering into something transcendent and beautiful.

Historical Background

The Tenth Symphony was produced during one of the most tumultuous periods in French history - the final months of World War I. France had been devastated by four years of brutal conflict, with millions of casualties and widespread destruction. The film industry, like all sectors of French society, had been profoundly affected by the war. Many film professionals had been conscripted, resources were scarce, and production had been significantly curtailed. Against this backdrop of national trauma and uncertainty, Abel Gance created a film that spoke to the French experience of suffering and the possibility of transcending pain through art. The film's release in November 1918 coincided with the end of the war, making it part of the cultural renaissance that followed the Armistice. This period saw French cinema breaking away from theatrical traditions and developing its own cinematic language. The French Impressionist movement, of which this film is a cornerstone, represented a deliberate attempt to use cinema's unique capabilities - particularly editing and cinematography - to explore psychological reality and subjective experience. The film's emphasis on individual suffering and artistic redemption resonated deeply with a French public seeking meaning after the trauma of war.

Making Of

Abel Gance approached 'The Tenth Symphony' with a revolutionary vision for what cinema could achieve as an art form. Working with cinematographers Léonce-Henri Burel and Georges Specht, Gance experimented with techniques that were groundbreaking for 1918. He used rapid montage sequences to represent musical composition, superimposed images to show the protagonist's memories and visions, and mobile camera movements to convey emotional states. The production took place under difficult wartime conditions, with limited resources and the constant threat of German bombardment near Paris. Gance insisted on elaborate sets for the concert hall sequences and commissioned an original musical score that was performed live during screenings. The cast, particularly Séverin-Mars in the lead role, underwent extensive preparation to understand the psychological complexity of their characters. Gance's direction emphasized internal emotion over external action, a radical departure from most films of the period. The film's most challenging sequences involved translating the abstract experience of music into visual terms, requiring innovative editing and special effects techniques that pushed the boundaries of contemporary technology.

Visual Style

The cinematography of The Tenth Symphony, executed by Léonce-Henri Burel and Georges Specht, was revolutionary for its time and established many techniques that would become hallmarks of French Impressionist cinema. The film employed innovative camera movements, including tracking shots and fluid camera work that followed characters' emotional states rather than simply recording action. Gance and his cinematographers used extensive superimposition and double exposure techniques to represent the protagonist's memories, visions, and psychological states. The lighting design was particularly sophisticated, using dramatic contrasts and expressive shadows to convey emotional atmosphere. The film featured some of the earliest examples of subjective point-of-view shots, with the camera representing the protagonist's perspective and emotional state. Rapid montage sequences, particularly in the symphony composition scenes, used rhythmic editing to create a visual equivalent of musical experience. The cinematography also employed innovative focus techniques, including soft focus and rack focus, to emphasize psychological elements over physical reality. Color tinting was used in original prints to enhance emotional impact, particularly in the musical sequences. The visual style was deliberately painterly, with carefully composed frames that resembled impressionist paintings in their use of light and movement to convey feeling rather than objective reality.

Innovations

The Tenth Symphony introduced numerous technical innovations that would influence cinema for decades. The film pioneered the use of rapid montage to represent abstract concepts, particularly in sequences depicting musical composition. Abel Gance developed sophisticated superimposition techniques, layering multiple images to represent psychological states and memories. The film featured some of the earliest examples of subjective camera work, with the camera movement reflecting characters' emotional states rather than objective reality. Gance experimented with unconventional editing rhythms, varying pace to match emotional intensity rather than narrative action. The film also employed innovative focus techniques, including soft focus and selective focus, to emphasize psychological elements. The production used special effects techniques, including multiple exposure and in-camera editing, to create dream sequences and visions. The film's approach to representing music through visual means was groundbreaking, establishing techniques that would be developed further in subsequent musical films. The cinematography employed mobile camera movements that were unusually fluid for the period, including tracking shots and camera movements that followed emotional rather than physical action. The film also experimented with color tinting for emotional effect, particularly in the symphony sequences. These technical innovations were not merely decorative but served the film's psychological themes, demonstrating how technical advances could be used to explore inner reality.

Music

The original musical score for The Tenth Symphony was composed by Michel-Maurice Levy and was performed live during screenings, as was standard practice for major silent films. The score was particularly significant because the film's central theme revolves around musical composition, making the music an integral part of the storytelling rather than mere accompaniment. Levy's composition included original pieces meant to represent Enrid Damor's symphony, with different musical themes corresponding to the film's emotional arcs. The score employed leitmotifs for different characters and emotions, a technique borrowed from Wagnerian opera but adapted for cinema. The music ranged from delicate, intimate pieces for domestic scenes to grand, orchestral passages for the symphony sequences. Unfortunately, the complete original score has not survived intact, though fragments and descriptions remain in archival materials. Modern screenings of restored versions typically feature newly composed scores or reconstructions based on contemporary accounts and musical practices of the period. The film's soundtrack represents an early example of music being used diegetically and non-diegetically to explore the relationship between sound and image in cinema. The innovative approach to integrating music into the narrative influenced subsequent films about musicians and composers.

Memorable Scenes

• The symphony composition sequence where Enrid's anguish is visualized through rapid montage, superimposed images, and rhythmic editing, representing the transformation of personal suffering into artistic creation.
• The confrontation scene where Eve's past is revealed, using flashback sequences and superimposition to show the contrast between her present life and former existence.
• The concert hall finale where the symphony is performed, with the film using visual techniques to represent the music's emotional impact on the audience and characters.
• The blackmail scene where Fred threatens Eve, employing dramatic lighting and camera angles to emphasize the psychological tension and moral conflict.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception in 1918 was generally positive, with French critics recognizing the film's artistic ambitions and technical innovations. Critics praised Abel Gance's bold visual style and the film's psychological depth, though some found its narrative complexity challenging. The film's representation of musical experience through visual means was particularly noted as groundbreaking. Over time, critical appreciation has grown significantly, with modern film scholars regarding The Tenth Symphony as a masterpiece of early cinema and a crucial work in the development of film as an art form. Critics now emphasize its importance in establishing the French Impressionist movement and its influence on subsequent cinematic developments. The film is frequently cited in academic studies of early cinema and is recognized for its sophisticated use of film language to express psychological states. Some contemporary critics have noted that while some of its techniques may seem dated to modern viewers, the film's emotional power and artistic vision remain compelling. The film's rediscovery and restoration in recent decades have led to renewed critical appreciation and recognition of its place in cinema history.

What Audiences Thought

Initial audience reception in 1918 was mixed, with some viewers finding the film's innovative techniques and psychological focus challenging compared to more conventional narratives of the period. The film's artistic ambitions and non-traditional storytelling approach required audiences to adapt to new ways of watching and understanding cinema. However, those who appreciated its artistic vision were deeply moved by its emotional power and visual beauty. The film's themes of suffering and redemption resonated particularly strongly with French audiences who had experienced the trauma of World War I. Over time, as audiences became more familiar with cinematic language and techniques, appreciation for the film has grown significantly. Modern audiences, particularly those interested in film history and avant-garde cinema, have responded positively to restored versions of the film. The film now enjoys cult status among cinema enthusiasts and is frequently screened at film festivals and special retrospectives dedicated to classic and avant-garde cinema. Its influence on subsequent filmmaking has ensured that even viewers who haven't seen the original film have experienced its legacy through the many films it inspired.

You Might Also Like