The Twin Pawns

Plot

In this dramatic tale of separated twins, wealthy businessman John Harrington raises his daughter Daisy in luxury while his estranged wife Margaret struggles to raise their other daughter Violet in poverty. The twins grow up completely unaware of each other's existence until a chance encounter brings them face to face. A cunning criminal named Victor discovers their relationship and manipulates both sisters for his own financial gain, creating a web of deception that threatens to destroy their newfound bond. As the sisters navigate their complicated relationship and Victor's schemes, they must overcome class differences and personal betrayals to reclaim their lives and expose the criminal exploiting their family secrets.

Historical Background

The Twin Pawns was released in 1919, a pivotal year in world history as nations recovered from World War I and dealt with the aftermath of the 1918 Spanish Flu pandemic. The film reflected the era's fascination with class divisions and social mobility, themes that resonated strongly with audiences experiencing rapid social change. The American film industry was in transition during this period, with power shifting from the East Coast studios to the emerging Hollywood system. This film represents the tail end of the East Coast production era, showcasing the sophisticated storytelling techniques that had developed during the 1910s. The year 1919 also saw major labor unrest in the United States, including strikes that affected various industries, including film production workers who were organizing for better working conditions.

Making Of

The production faced several challenges during filming, including a fire at the studio that destroyed some of the elaborate sets and costumes. Mae Murray and Warner Oland reportedly did not get along during filming, with Murray finding Oland's method acting approach distracting. Director Léonce Perret insisted on multiple takes for scenes featuring both twins together, using the then-cutting-edge matte painting techniques to create the illusion of two identical characters. The film's cinematographer, Lucien Andriot, experimented with different lighting techniques to visually distinguish between the wealthy and poor environments, using soft focus for the wealthy settings and harsher lighting for the poverty-stricken scenes. The production was rushed to meet its March release date, leading to some continuity errors that were noted by contemporary reviewers.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Lucien Andriot employed the sophisticated techniques that had become standard by the late 1910s, including careful use of lighting to establish mood and character. The film utilized contrasting visual styles to distinguish between the two sisters' worlds - soft, romantic lighting for the wealthy environments and harsher, more naturalistic lighting for the poverty-stricken settings. Andriot experimented with early double exposure techniques to show both twins in the same frame, a technical achievement for the period. The camera work included the increasingly common use of close-ups to emphasize emotional moments, particularly in scenes featuring Murray's expressive performances. The film also made effective use of location shooting in New York City, adding authenticity to the urban settings.

Innovations

The Twin Pawns featured several technical innovations for its time, particularly in its use of double exposure photography to create scenes with both twin sisters appearing together. The film employed sophisticated matte painting techniques to composite the two performances, a challenging process in 1919. The production also utilized advanced lighting techniques to visually distinguish between the contrasting social environments of the two sisters. The film's editing showed the growing sophistication of continuity editing practices that had developed throughout the 1910s. While not groundbreaking, the technical execution demonstrated the professional standards that had become expected in major studio productions by the end of the decade.

Music

As a silent film, The Twin Pawns would have been accompanied by live musical performances during its theatrical run. The original score was likely compiled from standard classical pieces and popular songs of the era, tailored to enhance the emotional impact of key scenes. Theaters would have employed various combinations of piano, organ, or small orchestras depending on their size and resources. The musical cues would have emphasized the dramatic moments, particularly during the sisters' reunion and the climactic confrontation with the villain. No specific composer is credited for the film, which was typical for productions of this period.

Memorable Scenes

• The emotional reunion scene where Daisy and Violet discover their twin relationship for the first time, featuring Mae Murray's dual performance and innovative split-screen effects that were technically impressive for 1919

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised Mae Murray's dual performance, with Variety noting her 'remarkable ability to distinguish between the two characters through subtle changes in posture and expression.' The New York Times called the film 'a competent melodrama with excellent performances' but criticized its predictable plot. Modern film historians consider The Twin Pawns a typical example of the melodramatic storytelling popular in the late 1910s, with particular appreciation for Murray's star power and Perret's competent direction. Critics have noted that while the film doesn't break new ground technically, it showcases the sophisticated narrative techniques that had developed by the end of the 1910s. The film is often cited in studies of twin films and Murray's early career, though it's generally considered lesser work compared to her later MGM productions.

What Audiences Thought

The Twin Pawns performed moderately well at the box office, benefiting from Mae Murray's growing popularity among moviegoers. Audiences of the time particularly enjoyed the emotional reunion scenes between the sisters and the dramatic confrontation with the villain. The film's themes of family reconciliation and triumph over adversity resonated strongly with post-war audiences seeking uplifting entertainment. Contemporary newspaper accounts suggest that the film was especially popular with female audiences, who related to the sister bond portrayed in the story. The film's success helped establish Murray as a bankable star, leading to more substantial roles and better contracts. However, some audience members found the plot overly familiar, as twin sister stories had become somewhat commonplace by 1919.

You Might Also Like