Triple Trouble

Plot

In this chaotic comedy, Colonel Nutt is conducting dangerous experiments with explosives in his household when a new, incompetent janitor arrives and immediately begins disrupting the household staff. The janitor, played by Charlie Chaplin, creates a series of disasters while attempting to perform his duties, including encounters with a German spy plot involving secret documents and a bomb. As the janitor bumbles through his work, he inadvertently uncovers the spy scheme while causing mayhem in the kitchen, with the cook and other staff members becoming increasingly frustrated with his incompetence. The film culminates in a frantic sequence where the janitor's mistakes accidentally help thwart the spy's plans, though he remains completely unaware of his heroic role in the situation.

Historical Background

Triple Trouble was released in August 1918, during the final months of World War I. The film's German spy subplot reflects the wartime tensions and anti-German sentiment prevalent in American media at the time. 1918 was also a pivotal year in film history, as the industry was transitioning from short films to feature-length productions. Chaplin himself was at the height of his fame and had just signed a groundbreaking contract with First National for $1 million, making him one of the highest-paid people in the world. The film's unauthorized release occurred during a period when studios were beginning to assert more control over creative content, leading to conflicts with artists who wanted autonomy over their work. The Spanish Flu pandemic was also sweeping across the globe in 1918, affecting film production and theater attendance, though the film industry was considered essential and continued operating.

Making Of

The creation of Triple Trouble represents one of the most unusual production stories in Chaplin's career. After Chaplin left Mutual Film Corporation in 1917 to form his own production company, Mutual found themselves with valuable unused footage from Chaplin's previous films. Rather than let this material go to waste, studio executives decided to piece together a new film from these outtakes, primarily from 'The Count' and 'The Adventurer.' They hired a director to shoot new connecting scenes to link the disparate footage into a somewhat coherent narrative. Chaplin was furious when he learned of this unauthorized use of his work, as he maintained strict creative control over his films. The legal battle that ensued set important precedents regarding artistic control and intellectual property rights in early Hollywood. The film's disjointed quality reflects its piecemeal construction, with noticeable continuity issues and tonal shifts between the different source materials.

Visual Style

The cinematography in Triple Trouble reflects the standard practices of the Mutual Film Corporation period, with the characteristic use of medium shots and wide shots typical of Chaplin's comedies. The film features the clean, well-lit interiors that were a hallmark of Mutual's production values. Because it was assembled from footage shot at different times by different cinematographers, there are noticeable variations in lighting style and camera placement throughout the film. The explosion sequences demonstrate the technical challenges of filming such effects in the silent era, requiring careful timing and multiple camera setups. The film maintains the visual clarity and composition quality that Chaplin demanded, even in the unused footage, showing the high standards maintained at Mutual during Chaplin's tenure.

Innovations

Triple Trouble doesn't feature significant technical achievements, as it primarily repurposes existing footage from earlier Chaplin productions. The film does demonstrate the sophisticated editing techniques being developed in the late 1910s, particularly in how the editors attempted to create narrative continuity from disparate sources. The explosion sequences, while simple by modern standards, required careful coordination of practical effects and timing to achieve the desired comic effect. The film's existence itself represents an early example of compilation filmmaking, though this was done without artistic merit in mind. The lighting and camera work maintain the high technical standards of Chaplin's Mutual period, showing the professional quality of the studio's productions even in discarded material.

Music

As a silent film, Triple Trouble would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its original theatrical run. The typical accompaniment would have consisted of a pianist or small orchestra playing popular songs of the era along with classical selections appropriate to the on-screen action. For the explosion scenes, dramatic percussion would have been employed to enhance the comedic effect. Modern releases of the film feature newly composed scores by silent film accompanists, typically using piano or small ensemble arrangements that reflect the musical styles of the 1910s. Some contemporary versions include sound effects to enhance the physical comedy, though purists prefer silent presentation with only musical accompaniment.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence where Chaplin as the janitor attempts to enter the house while carrying an absurd amount of cleaning equipment, resulting in a cascade of falling mops, buckets, and brooms that blocks the doorway.
• The kitchen scene where the janitor's attempt to help the cook results in flour covering every surface and character, creating a snow-like effect in the domestic setting.
• The climactic explosion sequence where the janitor accidentally triggers Colonel Nutt's experimental explosives while trying to clean the laboratory, resulting in perfectly timed comic destruction that inadvertently stops the spy's plot.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics in 1918 generally recognized Triple Trouble as inferior to Chaplin's other work, though they still appreciated his comic genius. Many reviewers noted the film's disjointed quality and suspected it was assembled from various sources. The New York Times review mentioned that while Chaplin's comedy was still evident, the film lacked the polish and cohesion of his previous efforts. Modern critics and film historians view Triple Trouble primarily as a curiosity rather than a significant Chaplin work. In his definitive Chaplin biography, David Robinson described it as 'a Frankenstein monster of a film' that 'should be viewed only by Chaplin completists.' Film scholars generally agree that the film's historical interest outweighs its artistic merit, though they acknowledge that even Chaplin's discarded footage contains moments of comic brilliance.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1918, still eager for any new Chaplin material, generally received Triple Trouble positively despite its flaws, though box office returns were reportedly modest compared to Chaplin's authorized releases. Many viewers likely didn't notice or care about the film's patchwork construction, simply happy to see their favorite comedian in new situations. Chaplin's immense popularity at the time meant that even subpar product could find an audience. Modern audiences typically encounter Triple Trouble only in Chaplin retrospectives or home video collections, where it's usually presented with explanatory notes about its unusual origins. Today, the film is primarily of interest to Chaplin enthusiasts and film scholars rather than general audiences.

You Might Also Like