A Sailor-Made Man
"Harold Lloyd in His First Full-Length Feature Comedy - The Boy Who Went to Sea to Win His Girl!"
Plot
Harold, a wealthy and idle young playboy, falls desperately in love with Mildred, but her father strongly disapproves of Harold's lack of purpose and direction. When confronted by Mildred's father who demands Harold prove himself worthy by getting a real job, Harold impulsively enlists in the United States Navy without understanding what military life entails. The film follows Harold's hilarious misadventures as he struggles to adapt to naval discipline, basic training, and shipboard life, creating chaos wherever he goes. Through a series of comedic mishaps including a disastrous attempt at cleaning duties, an awkward encounter with naval regulations, and a climactic sequence involving a submarine, Harold eventually proves his courage and character. By the film's conclusion, Harold has not only earned the respect of his fellow sailors and commanding officers but has also won the approval of Mildred's father, proving that true worth comes from personal growth rather than social status.
About the Production
This was Harold Lloyd's first full-length feature film, marking his transition from short comedies to feature-length productions. The film was shot over several weeks in early 1921, with extensive location filming at actual naval facilities to add authenticity. The submarine sequence required elaborate set construction and special effects that were considered groundbreaking for the time. Lloyd performed many of his own stunts, including several dangerous sequences aboard naval vessels. The production faced challenges coordinating with the U.S. Navy for filming permissions, but ultimately secured cooperation that allowed for unprecedented access to naval ships and facilities.
Historical Background
Released in 1921, 'A Sailor-Made Man' emerged during a transformative period in American cinema and society. The film was produced just after World War I, when military service and patriotism remained prominent in American culture. The early 1920s marked the transition from short films to feature-length productions as the standard for commercial cinema, with Lloyd's film representing this industry evolution. The decade also saw the rise of the 'common man' protagonist in American films, reflecting the country's post-war democratic ideals and the growing influence of the middle class. The naval setting tapped into America's growing interest in military modernization and the country's emerging status as a world power. The film's theme of a wealthy young man proving himself through work and service resonated with post-war American values that emphasized merit over inherited status. Additionally, 1921 was a year of significant labor unrest and social change, making the film's message about the dignity of work particularly relevant to contemporary audiences.
Why This Film Matters
'A Sailor-Made Man' holds considerable importance in film history as Harold Lloyd's first feature-length comedy and a template for the romantic comedy genre that would flourish throughout the 20th century. The film established Lloyd's 'Glass Character' persona in a feature format, demonstrating how his distinctive blend of ambition, optimism, and physical comedy could sustain longer narratives. Its success proved that feature-length comedies could be commercially viable, encouraging other comedians including Buster Keaton and Charlie Chaplin to expand into longer formats. The film's structure, following a character's journey from immaturity to responsibility through comedic misadventures, became a template for countless subsequent comedies. The naval setting also reflected and reinforced America's fascination with military life in the post-WWI era, contributing to the popular culture image of the Navy as a character-building institution. The film's preservation of early 1920s American values regarding work ethic, romance, and social mobility provides valuable historical insight into the cultural attitudes of the period.
Making Of
The production of 'A Sailor-Made Man' represented a significant milestone in Harold Lloyd's career, marking his ambitious leap into feature-length filmmaking. The collaboration between Lloyd and director Fred C. Newmeyer, who had worked together on numerous shorts, proved crucial in maintaining the comedic timing and pacing required for a longer format. The film's naval sequences required extensive coordination with the U.S. Navy, which was initially reluctant but eventually became cooperative after recognizing the potential recruitment value of the film. Lloyd, known for his meticulous preparation, spent weeks studying naval mannerisms and routines to ensure authenticity in his performance. The famous cleaning sequence, where Harold's character creates chaos while attempting to scrub a deck, involved complex choreography and multiple takes to perfect the timing of the physical comedy. The submarine climax required innovative special effects techniques, including the construction of a large water tank and detailed miniature models. Mildred Davis's casting as the romantic lead was natural given her real-life marriage to Lloyd, but their on-screen chemistry was carefully managed to avoid appearing too domestic for the romantic comedy format. The film's success led to immediate planning for Lloyd's next feature, establishing a pattern that would continue through the rest of the silent era.
Visual Style
The cinematography by Walter Lundin and Glen Gano was considered innovative for its time, particularly in its use of location photography at actual naval facilities. The film employed a mix of studio sets and authentic locations, creating a visual variety that enhanced the storytelling. The naval sequences utilized wide shots to capture the scale of ships and harbor facilities, while intimate scenes used closer framing to emphasize the romantic elements. The film also made effective use of the then-popular technique of tinting, with blue tones for naval scenes and warm amber for romantic moments. The submarine sequence required special photographic techniques including underwater photography effects that were cutting-edge for 1921. The camera work during physical comedy sequences was particularly noteworthy for its ability to capture complex gags while maintaining clear sightlines for the audience. The cinematography successfully balanced the epic scale of naval life with the intimate comedy of Lloyd's performance, creating a visual style that supported both the romantic and comedic elements of the story.
Innovations
The film featured several technical innovations for its time, most notably in its submarine sequence which required pioneering special effects techniques. The production team constructed one of the first detailed submarine models for underwater filming, using glass tanks and innovative camera housing to achieve realistic effects. The naval location filming represented an early example of extensive cooperation between Hollywood and the U.S. military, setting precedents for future military-themed productions. The film's use of actual naval vessels and facilities provided an unprecedented level of authenticity for a comedy film. The complex cleaning sequence required innovative camera placement and timing to capture the elaborate physical comedy gags. The production also employed early forms of stunt coordination, particularly for scenes involving Harold's character navigating naval equipment and ship structures. The film's successful integration of location photography with studio work demonstrated new possibilities for blending real and constructed environments in cinema.
Music
As a silent film, 'A Sailor-Made Man' was originally accompanied by live musical performances that varied by theater. Large urban theaters typically commissioned full orchestral scores, while smaller venues used piano or organ accompaniment. The suggested score, distributed by Pathé Exchange, included popular naval-themed songs of the period such as 'Anchors Aweigh' and original compositions by theater musicians. The music was carefully coordinated with the action, with lively marches for naval sequences and romantic melodies for the love scenes. Modern restorations have been accompanied by newly composed scores, most notably a 2005 version by the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra that incorporates authentic period music. The original cue sheets specified particular emotional tones for each scene, emphasizing the importance of music in conveying the film's comedic and romantic elements. The soundtrack's naval themes reinforced the film's patriotic elements while the romantic underscore supported the developing love story between Harold and Mildred.
Famous Quotes
Harold's character: 'I'll show you! I'll get a job!' (when challenged by Mildred's father)
Mildred's father: 'No daughter of mine will marry a man who's never done an honest day's work!'
Harold's character: 'The Navy? That's it! I'll join the Navy!'
Naval officer: 'You, sir, are the worst sailor I have ever seen!'
Mildred: 'Oh Harold, you're so brave when you're trying so hard!'
Memorable Scenes
- The chaotic deck cleaning sequence where Harold's character creates a soapy disaster while trying to prove his competence
- The enlistment scene where Harold impulsively signs up for the Navy without understanding what he's getting into
- The submarine climax involving a dramatic rescue operation that showcases Harold's unexpected heroism
- The initial confrontation between Harold and Mildred's father that sets the entire plot in motion
- The basic training montage showing Harold's struggles with naval discipline and physical requirements
Did You Know?
- This was Harold Lloyd's first full-length feature film after years of making successful short comedies
- The film's success convinced Lloyd and producer Hal Roach to focus primarily on feature-length productions
- Mildred Davis, who plays the female lead, was Harold Lloyd's real-life wife at the time of filming
- The U.S. Navy cooperated extensively with the production, providing access to ships and facilities rarely seen in films of the era
- Noah Young, who plays the heavy, was a former professional athlete and became one of Lloyd's most frequent co-stars
- The film was shot on location at the U.S. Naval Training Station in San Diego, California
- A famous sequence involving Lloyd trying to clean a naval vessel took three days to film due to the complexity of the gags
- The film's title was a play on the common phrase 'self-made man,' adapted for the naval theme
- Original release prints were tinted in various colors to enhance different scenes, a common practice in the 1920s
- The submarine sequence in the film's climax used one of the first miniature submarine models ever created for cinema
What Critics Said
Contemporary critics in 1921 overwhelmingly praised 'A Sailor-Made Man' as a triumph of the emerging feature comedy format. Variety called it 'a laugh riot from start to finish' and particularly noted Lloyd's successful transition from shorts to features. The Motion Picture News praised the film's 'perfect pacing and inventive gags' while highlighting the authentic naval setting as adding significant production value. Modern critics have recognized the film as a pivotal work in Lloyd's career and an important milestone in comedy cinema. Film historian Kevin Brownlow has noted that the film 'established the template for the romantic comedy that would dominate Hollywood for decades.' The New York Times retrospective on silent comedies ranked it among Lloyd's most important works, particularly for its innovative use of location shooting and military cooperation. Contemporary film scholars often cite it as a key example of how silent comedies successfully addressed themes of social mobility and American identity in the early 1920s.
What Audiences Thought
Audiences in 1921 embraced 'A Sailor-Made Man' with tremendous enthusiasm, making it one of the year's biggest box office successes. The film played to packed houses in major cities across America and was particularly popular with younger audiences who identified with Harold's character. Contemporary newspaper accounts reported frequent laughter and applause during screenings, with the naval sequences generating especially strong reactions. The film's success led to increased demand for Harold Lloyd appearances and merchandise, solidifying his status as one of the three major comedy stars of the silent era alongside Chaplin and Keaton. Audience letters to fan magazines frequently praised the film's blend of romance and comedy, with many viewers expressing particular enjoyment of the authentic naval setting. The film's popularity extended internationally, with strong reported reception in Europe where American comedies were gaining significant followings. Modern audiences viewing restored versions continue to respond positively to the film's physical comedy and charming romance, with many noting its surprisingly modern sensibilities despite being a century old.
Film Connections
Influenced By
- Earlier Harold Lloyd short comedies
- Charlie Chaplin's feature 'The Kid' (1921)
- Buster Keaton's transition to features
- Traditional American romantic comedy structure
- Military-themed films of the WWI era
- Popular culture's fascination with naval life
This Film Influenced
- Harold Lloyd's subsequent features including 'Grandma's Boy' (1922)
- Other naval comedies of the 1920s
- The romantic comedy genre structure
- Military-themed comedies throughout cinema history
- Films featuring wealthy protagonists learning life lessons
- Physical comedy films requiring location shooting
You Might Also Like
Film Restoration
The film is well-preserved with complete copies existing in major film archives. A restored version was released by the Harold Lloyd Trust in 2005 with newly commissioned musical accompaniment. The original nitrate negatives have been preserved and transferred to safety stock. The film is part of the permanent collections at the Library of Congress, the UCLA Film and Television Archive, and the Museum of Modern Art. Various versions exist including the original release version and later reissue prints with minor alterations. The restoration work has preserved the original tinting effects and intertitles, maintaining the film's original visual presentation.