Men O' War

Plot

Sailors Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy are on shore leave when they encounter two young women in a park. The boys attempt to impress them by offering to buy sodas, despite having very little money between them. Fortunately, Stan discovers a knack for playing a slot machine and wins the jackpot, giving them enough cash to rent a rowboat for an afternoon on the lake. Their romantic boat ride quickly descends into chaos as they tangle with other boaters, leading to a series of comedic mishaps that culminate in everyone ending up in the water. The film showcases classic Laurel and Hardy physical comedy as their simple romantic gesture spirals into complete disaster.

Historical Background

1929 was a pivotal year in cinema history, marking the full transition from silent films to talkies. 'Men O' War' was produced during this technological revolution when studios were investing heavily in sound equipment and retraining their personnel. The film reflects the carefree, prosperous atmosphere of the Roaring Twenties, released just months before the devastating stock market crash of October 1929 that would usher in the Great Depression. The entertainment industry was undergoing massive changes, with many silent film stars unable to make the transition to sound. Laurel and Hardy, however, successfully adapted their comedy style to the new medium. The film also represents the peak popularity of short comedy subjects, which were a staple of theater programs before feature films became the dominant format. The naval theme of the film resonated with audiences still influenced by World War I memories and America's growing naval presence.

Making Of

The production of 'Men O' War' took place during a critical transition period in Hollywood history. The film was made when studios were scrambling to convert to sound technology, and Hal Roach Studios was relatively late in adopting the new technology. The sound recording equipment of 1929 was large, noisy, and restrictive, forcing actors to remain relatively stationary near microphones. This created significant challenges for Laurel and Hardy's physical comedy style. The boat sequences were particularly difficult to film, as the early sound equipment couldn't be easily moved on water. The production team had to devise creative solutions, including using long boom poles and hiding microphones in props. The slot machine scene required precise timing to synchronize the mechanical sounds with the visual action, a technical achievement for the time. Director Lewis R. Foster had to balance the new technical requirements with preserving the comedic timing that made Laurel and Hardy famous.

Visual Style

The cinematography in 'Men O' War' reflects the technical constraints and innovations of the early sound era. The camera work is more static than in silent films due to the limitations of sound recording equipment, but the cinematographers found creative ways to maintain visual interest. The park scenes use natural lighting to create a romantic atmosphere, while the boat sequences required careful planning to capture the action on water. The slot machine close-ups demonstrate how the film used camera angles to enhance comedic moments. The cinematography successfully balances the need to accommodate sound equipment with maintaining the dynamic visual style that Laurel and Hardy films were known for. The water scenes were particularly challenging, requiring specialized equipment to keep cameras dry while capturing the chaotic action.

Innovations

Men O' War" achieved several technical milestones for its time. The film successfully integrated synchronized sound with Laurel and Hardy's established physical comedy style, proving that their humor could transcend the silent-to-sound transition. The slot machine sequence featured innovative editing techniques that synchronized mechanical sounds with visual action. The boat scenes demonstrated early techniques for recording sound in difficult outdoor environments. The film's audio-visual balance showed how comedy could be enhanced rather than diminished by sound technology. The production also pioneered methods for hiding microphones in props and sets, allowing for more natural movement within the constraints of early sound recording. These technical achievements helped pave the way for more sophisticated comedy sound films in the 1930s.

Music

The soundtrack for 'Men O' War' was typical of early sound films, featuring a synchronized musical score with sound effects but limited dialogue. The music was composed by Leroy Shield, who created many of the memorable themes for Hal Roach productions. The score uses popular songs of the era to enhance the romantic and comedic elements of the story. Sound effects play a crucial role in the comedy, particularly in the slot machine sequence and the boat collision scenes. The limited dialogue consists mainly of Stan and Ollie's characteristic grunts, exclamations, and brief exchanges, preserving their pantomime style while taking advantage of the new audio technology. The soundtrack demonstrates how early sound films could enhance comedy through carefully timed audio cues without relying heavily on spoken dialogue.

Memorable Scenes

• The slot machine sequence where Stan's lucky streak saves the day, featuring close-ups of the spinning reels and the growing excitement as he keeps winning.
• The chaotic boat collision scene where multiple boats crash into each other, culminating in everyone falling into the water in perfectly timed comedic fashion.
• The soda fountain courtship scene where Stan and Ollie attempt to impress the women despite their obvious financial limitations.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised 'Men O' War' for successfully translating Laurel and Hardy's comedy genius to the sound medium. Variety noted that 'the boys lose none of their comic timing in their first real talking effort.' The New York Times appreciated how the film used sound to enhance rather than overwhelm the visual gags. Modern critics view the film as an important transitional work that demonstrates how classic comedy could adapt to new technology. Film historians often cite it as an example of how Hal Roach Studios managed the sound transition more successfully than many other comedy producers. The slot machine sequence is frequently singled out for its innovative use of sound effects in comedy. The boat chase scenes are considered among the best examples of Laurel and Hardy's ability to create escalating chaos from simple premises.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1929 embraced 'Men O' War' enthusiastically, as it delivered the Laurel and Hardy comedy they loved while showcasing the novelty of sound. The film was a popular attraction in theaters, often playing alongside feature films as part of the typical double-bill programming of the era. Moviegoers particularly enjoyed the familiar chemistry between Stan and Ollie, which remained intact despite the new technical challenges. The soda fountain and boat scenes resonated with working-class audiences who could relate to the characters' attempts at romance and recreation. The film's success helped confirm that Laurel and Hardy had a future in sound pictures, unlike many of their silent-era contemporaries. Over the decades, the film has maintained its appeal through television broadcasts and home video releases, introducing new generations to the comedy duo's work.

You Might Also Like