Popeye the Sailor Meets Ali Baba's Forty Thieves

Plot

Popeye the Sailor, Olive Oyl, and J. Wellington Wimpy find themselves stranded in the Arabian desert after their camel runs away. They stumble upon a hidden cave where they witness the notorious bandit Abu Hassan and his forty thieves dividing their stolen treasures. When the thieves discover their presence, Popeye must protect his friends and defeat the entire band of criminals. Using his superhuman strength (enhanced by spinach) and quick thinking, Popeye battles the thieves in a spectacular showdown, ultimately capturing Abu Hassan and restoring peace to the desert. The adventure culminates with Popeye turning the thieves' own methods against them, proving once again that he's 'strong to the finish' when he eats his spinach.

Historical Background

Released in November 1937, this cartoon emerged during the golden age of American animation when studios were competing to push the boundaries of what animated shorts could achieve. The late 1930s saw Disney's 'Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs' revolutionizing the industry, while other studios like Fleischer and Warner Bros. were developing their own distinctive styles. Popeye was at the height of his popularity in 1937, rivaling even Mickey Mouse in audience appeal. The Arabian Nights theme reflected contemporary American fascination with exotic locales, fueled by films like 'The Sheik' and popular literature. The production occurred during the Great Depression, when escapist entertainment was particularly valued by audiences seeking relief from economic hardships. Fleischer Studios' decision to produce these special three-reel cartoons demonstrated their ambition to compete with Disney's increasingly ambitious animated projects.

Making Of

The production of 'Popeye the Sailor Meets Ali Baba's Forty Thieves' represented a major undertaking for Fleischer Studios, requiring nearly double the resources of a standard Popeye cartoon. The studio had recently relocated from New York to Miami, Florida, taking advantage of cheaper labor and facilities. Director Dave Fleischer supervised a team of approximately 150 animators and artists for this special production. The voice recording sessions were particularly lively, with Jack Mercer (Popeye), Mae Questel (Olive Oyl), and Lou Fleischer (Wimpy) often ad-libbing lines that made it into the final cut. The animation team developed new techniques for depicting desert landscapes and sand effects, creating some of the most visually striking backgrounds in the Popeye series. The film's elaborate action sequences required extensive planning through storyboards and preliminary animation tests, a practice that was becoming standard for high-budget animated features.

Visual Style

The cartoon showcases Fleischer Studios' innovative Stereo-optical process, which created a 3D effect by placing animated cels over three-dimensional miniature sets. This technique was particularly effective in the desert scenes, creating an unprecedented sense of depth and space in animation. The cinematography employed dynamic camera movements, including sweeping pans across the desert landscape and dramatic zooms during action sequences. The lighting effects were sophisticated for the time, with realistic shadows and highlights that enhanced the three-dimensional illusion. The film used color tinting in certain releases, particularly for the desert sequences, creating a golden, sun-baked atmosphere. The animation team developed new techniques for depicting sand, dust, and wind effects that added to the visual realism. The chase sequences featured innovative perspective shots that followed the action through complex environments, demonstrating the cinematographers' mastery of movement and composition.

Innovations

The cartoon pioneered several technical innovations in animation, most notably the extensive use of the Stereo-optical process for creating three-dimensional backgrounds. The animation team developed new methods for depicting complex crowd scenes with forty thieves moving simultaneously, a significant technical challenge for the time. The film featured some of the most sophisticated character animation of its era, with particularly fluid movement during the action sequences. The sand and dust effects were created using multiple animation techniques including rotoscoping and particle animation, resulting in remarkably realistic environmental effects. The production utilized early forms of exposure sheets for precise timing of animation and sound, improving synchronization quality. The cartoon also featured innovative use of color processing in some releases, experimenting with two-color Technicolor for certain sequences. The complex camera movements and perspective shots required new mechanical solutions for the animation stands, pushing the boundaries of what was technically possible in 1937.

Music

The musical score was composed by Sammy Timberg, Fleischer Studios' resident composer who created many of Popeye's most memorable musical themes. The soundtrack incorporated original compositions along with adaptations of traditional Arabian melodies, creating an authentic exotic atmosphere while maintaining the cartoon's comedic tone. The famous 'I'm Popeye the Sailor Man' theme was cleverly integrated with Middle Eastern musical elements. Sound effects were particularly innovative for the time, with the Foley team creating distinctive sounds for the thieves' movements, the desert environment, and Popeye's spinach-powered actions. The voice performances by Jack Mercer, Mae Questel, and Lou Fleischer were recorded using the latest sound technology of the era, capturing their nuanced performances with clarity. The musical accompaniment during the action sequences was synchronized precisely with the animation, enhancing the comedic timing and dramatic impact. The soundtrack also featured early use of stereo effects in some theaters, taking advantage of emerging sound technology.

Memorable Scenes

• The spectacular opening sequence showing the vast Arabian desert with the Stereo-optical 3D effect
• Popeye's transformation after eating spinach, shown in multiple stages with dynamic animation
• The elaborate battle scene where Popeye single-handedly defeats all forty thieves
• The discovery of the thieves' hidden cave with its treasure-filled interior
• The comedic chase sequence through the desert landscape with innovative camera movements
• The final confrontation between Popeye and Abu Hassan with its dramatic buildup and resolution

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised the cartoon for its technical innovation and entertainment value. The Motion Picture Herald called it 'a triumph of animated art' and highlighted its 'spectacular visual effects.' The New York Times noted that 'Fleischer has once again pushed the boundaries of what animation can achieve.' Modern animation historians regard it as a masterpiece of the Fleischer Studios era, with animation historian Leonard Maltin describing it as 'one of the greatest Popeye cartoons ever made.' Critics particularly praised the elaborate animation sequences and the creative adaptation of the Ali Baba story. The cartoon's Academy Award nomination reflected critical recognition of its artistic merit, though it lost to Disney's 'The Old Mill.' Retrospective analyses often cite this cartoon as an example of animation's potential for sophisticated storytelling and visual innovation.

What Audiences Thought

The cartoon was enormously popular with audiences upon its release, often playing to sold-out theaters as part of double bills. Children and adults alike responded enthusiastically to Popeye's heroic adventure and the spectacular action sequences. The film's success led to increased demand for Popeye merchandise, particularly toys and games featuring the Arabian theme. Audience reaction was so positive that theaters often held the cartoon over for additional weeks, unusual for an animated short. The film's popularity contributed to Popeye becoming one of the most recognizable cartoon characters of the 1930s, second only to Mickey Mouse in merchandising revenue. Contemporary audience letters to exhibitors frequently mentioned this cartoon as a highlight of their theater visits, with many requesting encores. The enduring popularity of this specific cartoon is evidenced by its continued inclusion in Popeye compilation releases and television broadcasts for decades.

You Might Also Like