The Crisis

Plot

Set against the backdrop of the American Civil War, 'The Crisis' follows Stephen Brice, a young Unionist lawyer in St. Louis who falls deeply in love with Virginia Carvel, daughter of his benefactor and staunch Confederate supporter. Their political allegiances create an insurmountable divide as Virginia remains loyal to the Southern cause while Brice commits himself to Lincoln's Union. As the war intensifies, Virginia becomes engaged to her cousin Clarence Colfax, a dedicated Confederate officer, while Brice rises through the ranks to become an officer under General Sherman. The story culminates in a dramatic confrontation when Brice discovers the captured Colfax facing execution for espionage, forcing him to choose between personal vengeance and mercy for his romantic rival.

Historical Background

Released in November 1916, 'The Crisis' emerged during a pivotal moment in American history. The country was deeply divided over World War I, with President Woodrow Wilson campaigning on the platform of keeping America neutral. The film's themes of national division and reconciliation resonated strongly with contemporary audiences. The Civil War, having ended only 51 years earlier, was still within living memory for many Americans, and there remained strong regional identities tied to the conflict. The film industry itself was undergoing transformation, with feature-length films becoming standard and Hollywood emerging as the production center. Selig Polyscope, though once a pioneering studio, was facing increasing competition from newer, better-funded companies. The film's release coincided with the presidential election of 1916, one of the closest in American history, further highlighting themes of national unity versus division.

Making Of

The production of 'The Crisis' was a major undertaking for the Selig Polyscope Company, representing their push toward more prestigious literary adaptations. Colin Campbell, known for his efficiency and visual storytelling, worked closely with the art department to ensure historical accuracy in costumes and settings. The film required extensive research into Civil War-era St. Louis, with the production team consulting historical photographs and documents. Battle scenes were particularly challenging to film, requiring coordination of hundreds of extras, horses, and artillery pieces. The cast underwent military training to handle weapons and execute military formations authentically. George Fawcett, though in a supporting role, served as an unofficial mentor to younger cast members, drawing on his extensive theatrical experience. The production faced weather delays during outdoor sequences, with autumn in the Midwest proving unpredictable. The film's emotional climax, where Brice must decide Colfax's fate, required multiple takes to achieve the desired dramatic intensity.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Harry W. Gerstad employed the sophisticated techniques developing in the mid-1910s. The film utilized location photography in and around St. Louis to establish authentic period atmosphere. Battle sequences employed wide shots to capture the scale of military engagements, while intimate scenes used closer framing to emphasize emotional moments. The film made effective use of natural lighting for outdoor sequences, particularly in the battle scenes where the contrast between sunlight and shadow added dramatic impact. Interior scenes demonstrated careful lighting design to create the 19th-century ambiance. The camera movement, while limited by the technology of the period, included some tracking shots during cavalry sequences. The film's visual style balanced historical authenticity with dramatic effect, using composition and lighting to reinforce the narrative's emotional beats.

Innovations

While not groundbreaking in technical innovation, 'The Crisis' demonstrated several advanced techniques for its period. The film's battle sequences featured coordinated action across multiple focal planes, requiring careful planning and execution. The production employed some early special effects techniques for creating the illusion of artillery fire and battlefield explosions. The film's length of seven reels was substantial for 1916, requiring careful pacing to maintain audience engagement. The use of actual historical locations and artifacts added authenticity that few productions of the era could match. The film demonstrated sophisticated editing techniques, particularly in the battle sequences where cross-cutting between different action elements created tension and excitement. The production's ability to coordinate large numbers of extras, animals, and equipment for the war scenes represented a significant logistical achievement for the Selig company.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Crisis' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during theatrical exhibition. The original score was likely composed by a Selig staff musician and would have included popular songs of the Civil War era, such as 'Dixie' and 'Battle Hymn of the Republic,' to establish period atmosphere. The musical accompaniment would have varied by theater size and location, with larger houses employing full orchestras and smaller venues using piano or organ. The score would have followed the dramatic conventions of the period, with romantic themes for the love story, martial music for battle sequences, and somber melodies for moments of conflict and decision. Musical cues would have been synchronized with on-screen action to enhance emotional impact. Some theaters may have used compiled scores of existing classical and popular pieces rather than original compositions.

Memorable Scenes

• The dramatic confrontation between Brice and the captured Colfax, where Brice must decide his rival's fate; The initial meeting between Stephen Brice and Virginia Carvel at a St. Louis society gathering; The大规模 battle sequence featuring cavalry charges and artillery bombardment; The emotional farewell scene as Virginia chooses her Southern allegiance over her love for Brice; The final scene showing the aftermath of war and the possibility of reconciliation

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised 'The Crisis' for its ambitious scope and faithful adaptation of Churchill's novel. The Moving Picture World noted the film's 'impressive battle sequences and heartfelt performances,' while Variety highlighted its 'patriotic sentiment and historical authenticity.' Critics particularly commended Colin Campbell's direction and the performances of the lead actors. The film's visual style and attention to period detail were frequently mentioned in reviews. However, some critics felt the runtime was excessive for the story being told. Modern film historians view 'The Crisis' as an important example of transitional cinema, bridging the gap between early short films and the feature-length epics that would follow. While not as technically innovative as some contemporaries like D.W. Griffith's work, it's recognized for its solid craftsmanship and emotional storytelling.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1916 responded positively to 'The Crisis,' particularly in regions with strong Civil War connections. The film's romantic elements appealed to female viewers, while its battle sequences attracted male audiences. Veterans of the Civil War, though elderly by 1916, reportedly appreciated the film's attention to historical detail. The film performed well in major urban markets and was particularly successful in St. Louis, where much of the story was set. Audience letters published in trade papers indicated that viewers connected with the themes of divided loyalty and the possibility of reconciliation. The film's release timing, just before America's entry into World War I, gave its wartime themes added relevance for contemporary viewers. However, some Southern audiences reportedly felt the film was too sympathetic to the Union perspective, reflecting ongoing regional sensitivities about Civil War representation.

You Might Also Like