A Fool There Was

Plot

John Schuyler, a prominent Wall Street lawyer and devoted family man, receives a prestigious appointment as a special envoy to England. When his wife and young daughter are unable to accompany him due to a sudden illness, Schuyler travels alone aboard an ocean liner where he encounters the mysterious and seductive woman known only as 'The Vampire.' Despite his initial resistance to her charms, Schuyler becomes completely enthralled by the femme fatale, abandoning his family, career, and reputation for her destructive influence. As their relationship intensifies, Schuyler's life spirals into ruin, leading to alcoholism, financial ruin, and complete moral degradation. The film culminates with Schuyler broken and destitute, while the Vampire moves on to her next victim, leaving behind another destroyed life in her wake.

Historical Background

The film was released during a transitional period in American cinema, just as feature-length films were becoming the industry standard. 1915 was also the year of D.W. Griffith's controversial 'The Birth of a Nation,' which was changing how films were produced and marketed. The film emerged during the Progressive Era, when there was significant public debate about morality, sexuality, and the changing role of women in society. World War I was raging in Europe, making Americans particularly interested in stories of moral corruption and redemption. The film's success coincided with the rise of the studio system and the beginning of Hollywood's golden age.

Making Of

The production was remarkably quick and inexpensive, shot in just 12 days at Fox's studio in Fort Lee, New Jersey. Director Frank Powell, who had previously worked at Biograph with D.W. Griffith, recognized the potential in the story and fought to cast the relatively unknown Theda Bara. Fox Studios launched an elaborate publicity campaign for Bara, creating a false backstory claiming she was an Arabian princess with occult powers. The film's most famous scene, where Bara's character hypnotizes Schuyler with her eyes, was achieved through innovative close-up techniques and careful lighting. The production faced some censorship challenges due to its controversial subject matter, but Fox successfully argued that the film served as a moral warning against temptation.

Visual Style

The film utilized innovative close-up shots to emphasize the emotional intensity of key scenes, particularly those featuring Bara's hypnotic gaze. Cinematographer John W. Noble employed dramatic lighting techniques, using shadows to enhance the mysterious and dangerous atmosphere surrounding the Vampire character. The film made effective use of intertitles to convey dialogue and narrative progression, with some titles featuring stylized lettering to match the film's dramatic tone. The ocean liner scenes were particularly well-shot, using the confined space to create tension and claustrophobia.

Innovations

The film pioneered several techniques that would become standard in cinema, including the use of dramatic close-ups to convey psychological states. The makeup design for Theda Bara's character was revolutionary, creating a distinctive look that would influence film makeup for decades. The film's editing techniques, particularly the cross-cutting between the suffering family and the corrupting influence of the Vampire, were sophisticated for their time. The production also demonstrated the commercial potential of creating a distinctive star persona through carefully crafted publicity and visual presentation.

Music

As a silent film, 'A Fool There Was' would have been accompanied by live musical performances in theaters. The original score was composed by William Furst, who created dramatic leitmotifs for different characters - a seductive, exotic theme for the Vampire and a more traditional, romantic theme for the Schuyler family. Theater orchestras were provided with detailed cue sheets indicating which music to play for each scene. The score emphasized the film's moral themes through its contrast between the 'good' family music and the 'evil' seduction themes.

Memorable Scenes

• The first encounter on the ocean liner where the Vampire first spots John Schuyler and declares him her next victim
• The hypnotic seduction scene where Bara uses her intense gaze to entrance Schuyler
• The heartbreaking scene where Schuyler's wife discovers his betrayal through a newspaper
• The final confrontation scene where the Vampire abandons the broken Schuyler for her next conquest
• The iconic poster shot where Bara reclines seductively with the caption 'The Vampire'

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics were divided but generally impressed by the film's boldness and Bara's performance. The New York Times praised it as 'a powerful and absorbing drama' while Variety noted Bara's 'magnetic screen presence.' Some moralists condemned the film as corrupting, but most critics acknowledged its technical merits and strong performances. Modern critics recognize the film as historically significant, with the American Film Institute including it in their list of important American films. Film historians often cite it as a crucial example of early cinema's exploration of complex female characters and its role in establishing star power as a commercial force.

What Audiences Thought

The film was a massive commercial success, becoming one of the biggest hits of 1915 and earning extraordinary returns on its small investment. Audiences were shocked and fascinated by Theda Bara's portrayal of the unapologetic seductress, with women particularly drawn to her powerful and independent character. The film sparked nationwide discussions about morality and the dangers of temptation. Many theaters reported record attendance, and the film's success led to increased demand for more daring and sophisticated content in motion pictures. The character became so popular that 'vamp' entered the popular vocabulary as a term for a seductive woman.

You Might Also Like