Black and Tan

Plot

Black and Tan is a poignant musical drama that follows Duke Ellington and his orchestra struggling to make ends meet during the Great Depression. Ellington discovers that his talented dancer friend, played by Fredi Washington, has a serious heart condition but desperately needs the work his band can provide. Despite his pleas for her to rest and protect her health, she insists on performing with the group, knowing it's their only opportunity for employment. In a tragic climax, Washington delivers a passionate dance performance but collapses on stage from the strain, fulfilling Ellington's worst fears. The film concludes with Ellington continuing to play his music, suggesting that art persists even in the face of personal tragedy and economic hardship.

Historical Background

Black and Tan was produced during a pivotal moment in American history and cinema. Released just months after the 1929 stock market crash, it captured the economic struggles facing African American musicians during the Great Depression. The film emerged during the Harlem Renaissance, a period of unprecedented Black cultural achievement in arts, literature, and music. In cinema, 1929 marked the transition from silent films to 'talkies,' with studios scrambling to produce sound content. Warner Bros., having pioneered sound with The Jazz Singer (1927), continued to experiment with musical shorts featuring contemporary performers. The film also reflected the complex racial dynamics of its era, presenting authentic Black culture at a time when Hollywood typically relied on racist caricatures and minstrel traditions.

Making Of

Director Dudley Murphy, who had previously worked with avant-garde artists like Man Ray and Fernand Léger, brought an artistic sensibility to this production. The film was made during the transition from silent to sound cinema, presenting technical challenges that required the orchestra to perform live while being filmed. Fredi Washington, despite her light skin, refused to pass as white in Hollywood and was a vocal advocate for better roles for African American actors. The production was filmed on a modest budget typical of short subjects, but Warner Bros. invested in quality production values to showcase their Vitaphone sound system. Ellington and his band had to adapt their usual performance style for the camera, with Murphy encouraging more visual expression to complement the music.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Ray Rennahan employed innovative techniques for capturing musical performance on film. The camera work emphasized the physical expression of the musicians, using close-ups to capture the intensity of their performances. The film utilized dramatic lighting to create mood, particularly in the tragic final sequence. Some scenes were reportedly filmed using early two-strip Technicolor, though most surviving versions are in black and white. The cinematography successfully balanced the requirements of both musical showcase and dramatic narrative, using visual techniques to enhance the emotional impact of both the music and the story.

Innovations

Black and Tan demonstrated several technical innovations for its time. As an early Vitaphone production, it showcased the possibilities of synchronized sound in musical films. The production successfully overcame the technical limitations of early sound recording to capture live musical performance with reasonable clarity. The film experimented with integrating musical numbers seamlessly into dramatic narrative, influencing the development of the musical film genre. The use of camera movement during musical performances was innovative for the era, as early sound films were often static due to technical constraints. Some sequences reportedly employed early color processes, demonstrating Warner Bros.' experimentation with new technologies.

Music

The soundtrack features Duke Ellington and his orchestra performing several of his compositions, including the titular 'Black and Tan Fantasy.' The music represents Ellington's early 'jungle style' period, characterized by exotic harmonies and muted trumpet effects. The score blends hot jazz with blues influences, showcasing the orchestra's unique sound. The recording was made using the Vitaphone sound-on-disc system, which provided surprisingly high audio fidelity for the era. The soundtrack serves both as background music and as an integral part of the narrative, with the lyrics and musical themes reflecting the story's emotional arc. The film preserves some of Ellington's earliest recorded performances, making it historically significant for jazz enthusiasts.

Memorable Scenes

• The climactic dance sequence where Fredi Washington performs with increasing intensity despite her weakening condition, culminating in her dramatic collapse on stage while Ellington continues to play
• The opening scene where Ellington's orchestra struggles through a rehearsal in their cramped apartment, establishing their financial hardship
• The emotional confrontation between Ellington and Washington where he begs her not to perform, showcasing their deep friendship and concern
• The final shot of Ellington alone at the piano, continuing to play as a tribute to his fallen friend, symbolizing music's endurance beyond tragedy

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised the film for its artistic ambition and authentic representation of African American culture. Variety noted that 'the musical numbers are excellent and the dramatic story, though brief, is handled with sincerity.' Modern critics recognize the film as a groundbreaking work that transcended the limitations of its short format. The New York Times retrospective review called it 'a remarkable fusion of jazz and cinema that captures the spirit of the Harlem Renaissance.' Film scholars have analyzed it as an early example of the musical drama genre and as an important document of Black cultural expression in early sound cinema.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by both Black and white audiences upon its release, with particular appreciation for Ellington's musical performances. Harlem audiences reportedly responded enthusiastically to seeing their cultural icons portrayed authentically on screen. The film played in both segregated theaters and integrated venues, reaching diverse audiences. Modern audiences discover the film primarily through film festivals and archival screenings, where it continues to move viewers with its powerful combination of music and drama. Jazz enthusiasts particularly value the film as a rare visual record of Ellington's early orchestra in performance.

You Might Also Like