Fiddlesticks

Plot

In this silent comedy short, Harry Langdon plays a hapless young man with dreams of becoming a great musician despite having no discernible talent. After numerous failed attempts to learn various instruments and join orchestras, he becomes discouraged and gives up on his musical ambitions. His fortunes change when a junk collector discovers him randomly playing unusual melodies on discarded objects, revealing an unconventional musical genius. The junk collector promotes Harry's unique talents, leading to a series of comedic situations as Harry attempts to perform for audiences using his unconventional instruments. The film culminates in a chaotic but successful performance where Harry's junk-yard symphony surprisingly delights the crowd, proving that true talent can emerge from the most unexpected sources.

Historical Background

1927 was a pivotal year in cinema history, marking the end of the silent era and the beginning of the sound revolution. The Jazz Singer had been released in October 1927, forever changing the film industry. 'Fiddlesticks' was released just before this seismic shift, representing one of the last waves of pure silent comedy shorts. The film was produced during the height of the Roaring Twenties, a period of economic prosperity and cultural change in America. Silent comedy was at its artistic peak, with stars like Chaplin, Keaton, Lloyd, and Langdon each developing their unique comic personas. The film's release came at a time when Hollywood studios were frantically preparing for the transition to sound, with many silent comedians facing uncertain futures. This historical context makes 'Fiddlesticks' a valuable artifact of the final golden age of silent comedy.

Making Of

The production of 'Fiddlesticks' took place during a challenging period in Harry Langdon's career. After his initial success with First National, Langdon signed with Mack Sennett, where he was paired with director Harry Edwards. Edwards had a reputation for being a fast, efficient director who could crank out comedy shorts quickly, which suited Sennett's production model. The filming likely followed the typical Mack Sennett approach of shooting with minimal preparation and relying on the stars' established personas. Langdon's meticulous preparation and slow, deliberate style sometimes conflicted with Edwards' faster pace, creating tension on set. The junk yard scenes would have been carefully choreographed to maximize comedic effect while ensuring safety for the performers. The film was shot on the Mack Sennett studio lot in Edendale, Los Angeles, utilizing standing sets and props from the studio's extensive collection.

Visual Style

The cinematography in 'Fiddlesticks' follows the standard practices for comedy shorts of the period, with clear, well-lit compositions designed to maximize visibility of the physical comedy. The camera work would have been relatively static compared to later films, allowing the performances to be the focus. The junk yard scenes likely utilized wider shots to establish the setting and then moved to medium shots for the comedy sequences. The film would have used the typical intertitle style of the period, with text cards providing dialogue and narrative exposition. The visual style emphasizes clarity and readability, essential for silent comedy where visual information must be immediately understandable to the audience. The photography would have been done on the Mack Sennett studio lot, utilizing both interior sets and exterior locations to create variety in the visual presentation.

Innovations

While 'Fiddlesticks' was not particularly innovative from a technical standpoint, it represents the polished craftsmanship of the late silent era comedy short production. The film would have utilized the standard 35mm film format with the typical aspect ratio of the period. The editing would have followed the established continuity editing system, with clear narrative progression and timing optimized for comedic effect. The film demonstrates the efficient production methods developed by Mack Sennett for creating comedy shorts on a tight schedule. The special effects would have been limited to in-camera techniques and practical effects, typical of comedy productions of the era. The film's preservation provides modern viewers with insight into the technical standards and production methods of late silent comedy shorts.

Music

As a silent film, 'Fiddlesticks' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its original theatrical runs. The typical accompaniment would have included a piano or organ player providing mood music and sound effects. Given the film's musical theme, the accompaniment would likely have included various musical pieces that complemented the on-screen action. The score would have used popular songs of the era as well as classical pieces arranged for theater organ. The music would have been synchronized with the action, with faster tempos during comedic sequences and slower, more sentimental music during emotional moments. Modern screenings of the film often feature newly composed scores or period-appropriate music performed by silent film accompanists. The musical nature of the film's content makes it particularly suitable for creative musical interpretation by contemporary accompanists.

Memorable Scenes

• The scene where Harry Langdon's character discovers his musical talent by randomly playing on discarded junk items in the junkyard, creating an impromptu symphony that surprises everyone
• The climactic performance scene where Harry presents his junk-yard orchestra to an initially skeptical audience, winning them over with his unique musical approach
• The sequence of Harry's failed attempts to learn conventional instruments, showcasing Langdon's signature physical comedy and innocent frustration

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of 'Fiddlesticks' were generally positive, with critics noting Langdon's charm and the film's amusing situations. Variety, in its review, praised Langdon's performance and the effective use of musical comedy elements. Modern critics and film historians view the film as a solid example of Langdon's work during his Mack Sennett period, though not considered among his absolute best. The film is often discussed in the context of Langdon's career trajectory, representing his work after his initial peak but before his decline. Silent comedy enthusiasts appreciate the film for its preservation of Langdon's unique comic style and its representation of the final phase of silent comedy shorts. The film is valued by archivists and scholars for its contribution to the documentation of silent comedy techniques and styles.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1927 responded positively to 'Fiddlesticks,' enjoying Langdon's gentle humor and the film's musical comedy elements. The film performed well in theaters as part of comedy short programs that accompanied feature films. Harry Langdon's popularity at the time ensured that his new releases were eagerly anticipated by his fan base. The film's premise of discovering musical talent in junk would have resonated with audiences during the economically prosperous 1920s, when themes of self-improvement and unexpected success were popular. Modern audiences, primarily silent film enthusiasts and scholars, appreciate the film for its historical value and Langdon's unique performance style. The film continues to be shown at silent film festivals and special screenings, where it receives appreciation from dedicated silent cinema fans.

You Might Also Like