I Don't Want to Be a Man

Plot

Ossi, a rebellious teenage tomboy, grows frustrated with her strict guardian's constant control and decides to experience life as a man. After purchasing a suit and adopting male mannerisms, she ventures into society where she encounters various comedic situations that challenge her perceptions of gender roles. Her disguise leads to complications when she becomes involved with her guardian's friend, creating a complex web of mistaken identities and romantic entanglements. The film cleverly explores themes of gender equality and social expectations through its progressive narrative structure. Ultimately, Ossi's journey as a man teaches her valuable lessons about both sexes and the arbitrary nature of social conventions.

Historical Background

Produced in November 1918, this film emerged during the final month of World War I, a period of immense social and political upheaval in Germany. The German Empire was collapsing, and the Weimar Republic was about to be established, bringing new freedoms and cultural experimentation. This context of social transformation made the film's themes of gender role reversal particularly resonant. The cinema industry in Germany was thriving despite the war, with German films competing successfully against Hollywood imports. This period saw the rise of sophisticated German cinema that would later influence filmmakers worldwide. The film's progressive take on women's roles reflected broader discussions about gender equality occurring in post-war European society.

Making Of

Ernst Lubitsch, already an established director in Germany by 1918, crafted this gender-bending comedy with remarkable sophistication for the silent era. The production took place in Berlin during the tumultuous final months of World War I, yet the film maintains an escapist, light-hearted tone. Ossi Oswalda, who had previously worked with Lubitsch, underwent extensive preparation for her dual-gender role, studying male mannerisms and body language. The costume department created multiple outfits for her transformation, with particular attention to making her male disguise believable while still allowing for comedic moments. The film's innovative use of visual gags and situational comedy demonstrated Lubitsch's growing mastery of cinematic storytelling techniques that would later influence Hollywood comedy.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Theodor Sparkuhl employed innovative techniques for the era, including sophisticated camera movements and creative framing. The film made effective use of iris shots to focus attention and create visual punctuation. The lighting techniques enhanced the comedy, particularly in scenes highlighting the contrast between Ossi's feminine and masculine presentations. The visual storytelling relied heavily on composition and blocking to convey humor and character development without dialogue. The film's visual style demonstrated the growing sophistication of German cinema in the late 1910s, with careful attention to mise-en-scène and visual gags that would become hallmarks of Lubitsch's later work.

Innovations

The film demonstrated advanced editing techniques for its time, including sophisticated cross-cutting and scene transitions. The use of multiple camera angles and movements showed the growing technical sophistication of German cinema. The costume design and makeup for Ossi Oswalda's gender transformation were technically impressive for the era. The film's pacing and rhythm demonstrated Lubitsch's mastery of comedic timing in the silent format. The visual gags and situational comedy were executed with technical precision that would influence comedy filmmaking for decades.

Music

As a silent film, it would have been accompanied by live musical performance in theaters. The original score has not survived, but contemporary screenings typically feature period-appropriate piano or orchestral accompaniment. The music would have emphasized the comedic moments and supported the emotional beats of the story. Modern restorations often feature newly composed scores that attempt to capture the film's playful and progressive spirit. The absence of dialogue made the visual comedy and musical accompaniment particularly important for conveying the film's sophisticated humor.

Memorable Scenes

• Ossi's transformation scene where she tries on men's clothing for the first time, struggling with the unfamiliar garments and practicing masculine mannerisms in front of a mirror
• The restaurant scene where Ossi, disguised as a man, attempts to navigate male social codes and etiquette with comical results
• The confrontation scene where her disguise is partially revealed, creating tension and misunderstanding
• The final resolution where Ossi returns to her female identity but with newfound understanding and confidence

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised the film for its clever premise and Ossi Oswalda's charismatic performance. German film publications of the era noted the film's sophisticated humor and progressive themes. Modern critics and film historians have recognized the film as remarkably ahead of its time, with particular appreciation for its gender-bending narrative and subtle social commentary. The film is now considered a significant early work in Ernst Lubitsch's filmography and an important example of German silent comedy. Critics have highlighted how the film's themes of gender equality remain relevant and its comedic techniques influenced later Hollywood productions.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by German audiences in 1918, who appreciated its light-hearted escapism during the difficult final months of the war. Ossi Oswalda's performance was particularly popular, cementing her status as one of Germany's leading comedy actresses. The film's success contributed to Lubitsch's growing reputation as a master of sophisticated comedy. Modern audiences rediscovering the film through restorations and film festivals have been impressed by its progressive themes and surprisingly contemporary feel. The gender-bending elements continue to resonate with contemporary viewers, demonstrating the timelessness of its social commentary.

You Might Also Like