Mabel’s Wilful Way

Plot

Mabel Normand plays a young woman who defies her strict parents' wishes by sneaking out to enjoy a day at the local fairgrounds. Once there, she encounters two bumbling suitors, played by Roscoe 'Fatty' Arbuckle and Edgar Kennedy, who compete for her attention through increasingly ridiculous antics. The trio's mischievous adventures include chaotic rides, carnival games gone wrong, and slapstick encounters with various fairground attractions. As the day progresses, Mabel's parents begin searching for her, leading to a frantic chase sequence through the crowded fair. The film culminates in a madcap finale where Mabel must choose between her suitors while avoiding her parents' wrath, all while maintaining the high-energy comedy typical of the Keystone Studios style.

Historical Background

1915 was a pivotal year in American cinema, occurring during the transition from short films to feature-length productions. The film industry was rapidly consolidating in Hollywood, with studios like Keystone establishing the template for classical Hollywood filmmaking. World War I was raging in Europe, making American films increasingly dominant internationally. This period also saw the rise of the star system, with actors like Arbuckle and Normand becoming major box office draws. The fairground setting reflects the growing popularity of amusement parks in American culture during the early 20th century, which were seen as symbols of modern leisure and entertainment. The film's release coincided with the groundbreaking premiere of D.W. Griffith's 'The Birth of a Nation,' highlighting the contrast between epic historical dramas and the simple, universal appeal of slapstick comedy.

Making Of

The production of 'Mabel's Wilful Way' exemplified the Keystone Studios approach to filmmaking under Mack Sennett's leadership. The studio operated like an assembly line, with multiple films shooting simultaneously on their backlot and nearby locations. Arbuckle and Normand, both seasoned comedy veterans, would have been given only the basic premise and expected to develop the gags and pacing during filming. The fairground scenes presented both opportunities and challenges - real carnival rides and games provided authentic settings, but coordinating physical comedy around moving equipment and crowds required careful timing. The film was likely shot with a single camera, as was standard practice, with multiple takes of each gag until the director was satisfied. The chemistry between Arbuckle and Normand was well-established from their numerous previous collaborations, allowing for natural comic timing and rapport that translated effectively to the screen.

Visual Style

The cinematography in 'Mabel's Wilful Way' follows the typical Keystone Studios style of the period - straightforward, functional, and focused on clearly capturing the physical comedy. The camera work would have been static for most scenes, using wide shots to ensure the actors' movements and gags were fully visible. The fairground setting allowed for some dynamic compositions, with the camera positioned to take advantage of the natural visual interest of rides, games, and crowds. The film likely employed some tracking shots during chase sequences, a technique Keystone pioneered to enhance the energy of their comedies. The cinematography prioritized clarity and timing over artistic flourishes, ensuring that every pratfall, pie in the face, or comic reaction was easily visible to audiences in large theaters.

Innovations

While 'Mabel's Wilful Way' was not groundbreaking technically, it demonstrated the efficiency and reliability of Keystone's production methods. The film showcases the studio's mastery of the one-reel format, packing maximum comedy into approximately ten minutes. The coordination required for the fairground sequences, particularly if filmed on location with real crowds and moving attractions, represented a considerable technical challenge for the period. The film also exemplifies the sophisticated understanding of comic timing and pacing that Keystone had developed by 1915, allowing for complex physical comedy sequences to be executed with precision. The use of real locations and props, rather than relying entirely on studio sets, added authenticity to the production while maintaining the studio's rapid production schedule.

Music

As a silent film, 'Mabel's Wilful Way' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its original theatrical run. The typical Keystone comedy was scored with upbeat, lively music that matched the frenetic pace of the action. A theater's house organist or small orchestra would have used a combination of classical pieces, popular songs of the day, and specialized cue sheets that suggested appropriate music for different scenes. The fairground setting would have inspired carnival-like music during those sequences, while more romantic moments would have been accompanied by waltzes or popular love songs. The music was crucial to establishing mood and enhancing the comedic timing, with accents and stings timed to coincide with physical gags.

Memorable Scenes

• The chaotic fairground sequence where Arbuckle and Kennedy compete for Mabel's attention through increasingly ridiculous carnival games, culminating in both suitors getting tangled in a ring toss booth while Mabel laughs at their antics

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of Keystone comedies like 'Mabel's Wilful Way' were generally positive, with trade publications praising the energetic performances and inventive gags. The Motion Picture News noted the film's 'rollicking good humor' and 'expert comic timing' from its stars. Variety typically praised Keystone productions for their consistent entertainment value and crowd-pleasing nature. Modern film historians view this film as representative of Keystone's output during its peak period, though it's considered less innovative than some of the studio's more famous works. The film is appreciated today for showcasing the talents of Arbuckle and Normand at the height of their collaborative partnership, though it doesn't rank among their most individually celebrated works.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1915 responded enthusiastically to 'Mabel's Wilful Way,' as they did to most Keystone comedies of the era. The combination of Arbuckle's physical comedy, Normand's charm, and the relatable fairground setting proved to be a winning formula. The film likely played well to the working-class audiences that formed the backbone of early cinema attendance, who appreciated the simple, direct humor and lack of pretension. The rebellious nature of Mabel's character probably resonated with younger audience members seeking entertainment that challenged social conventions. Contemporary reports suggest the film generated good laughs and applause during theatrical runs, which was the primary measure of success for short comedies of this period.

You Might Also Like