Making a Living

Plot

In this early comedy short, a swindler (Charlie Chaplin) cons a newspaper reporter-photographer out of his money and camera equipment. Unaware that his victim works for a newspaper, the swindler later applies for a job at the same publication. The film follows his clumsy attempts to secure employment while trying to avoid recognition by the man he previously cheated. The comedic situation escalates as Chaplin's character attempts to prove his worth as a reporter while maintaining his disguise. The short culminates in a series of slapstick mishaps that reveal his true identity to his prospective employer.

Historical Background

1914 was a watershed year in cinema history, occurring during the transition from short films to feature-length movies. The film industry was rapidly consolidating in Hollywood, with studios like Keystone pioneering the comedy genre. World War I had just begun in Europe, though America remained neutral, creating a climate where audiences sought escapist entertainment. The film industry was still establishing its conventions, with actors rarely receiving screen credit and directors often working anonymously. This period saw the rise of the star system, and Chaplin's debut occurred at the perfect moment to capitalize on this trend. The technical limitations of the era meant films were shot in one take with stationary cameras, requiring performers to develop exaggerated physical comedy techniques. Keystone Studios, under Mack Sennett, was revolutionizing comedy with its fast-paced slapstick style, setting the template for American film comedy for decades to come.

Making Of

The making of 'Making a Living' represents a pivotal moment in cinema history. Chaplin had been recruited from the Fred Karno comedy troupe in England and arrived at Keystone Studios in December 1913. Mack Sennett, the studio head, was initially unsure how to use Chaplin's talents. Director Henry Lehrman, a veteran Keystone filmmaker, was assigned to direct Chaplin's debut but reportedly grew frustrated with Chaplin's tendency to ad-lib and expand scenes beyond their planned scope. The film was shot on location in Los Angeles, utilizing the city's streets as backdrops. Chaplin's performance style was still evolving, and he had not yet developed the iconic Little Tramp character that would make him world-famous. The on-set tensions between Chaplin and Lehrman were so significant that Sennett decided to let Chaplin direct his own films after this, recognizing his unique comedic vision. This decision would prove crucial in allowing Chaplin to develop his distinctive style and character.

Visual Style

The cinematography in 'Making a Living' reflects the standard practices of 1914 filmmaking. The camera remains stationary for most scenes, typical of the period before the development of more dynamic camera movement. The film was shot in black and white on 35mm film, with exterior scenes utilizing natural lighting. The framing is generally wide to capture the physical comedy, with actors positioned to ensure their actions remain visible within the static frame. The visual style emphasizes clarity over artistic composition, as the primary goal was to showcase the comedy. Location shooting in Los Angeles streets provides authentic urban backdrops that add realism to the newspaper office setting. The cinematography serves its functional purpose effectively, though it lacks the visual sophistication that would develop in cinema throughout the 1910s.

Innovations

While 'Making a Living' does not feature groundbreaking technical innovations, it represents the standard technical practices of professional filmmaking in 1914. The film was shot on 35mm film at approximately 16 frames per second, the standard speed of the era. The use of location shooting in urban Los Angeles demonstrated the growing mobility of film equipment and the industry's move away from studio-bound productions. The film's editing, while simple by modern standards, shows the developing language of continuity editing that was becoming standard in American cinema. The technical aspects of the film, including lighting and camera placement, were handled competently by Keystone's experienced crew. The film's survival and preservation also represent an achievement in itself, as many films from this period have been lost due to the unstable nature of early film stock.

Music

As a silent film, 'Making a Living' had no original soundtrack or recorded dialogue. During its theatrical run in 1914, the film would have been accompanied by live musical performance, typically a pianist or small orchestra in the theater. The music would have been improvised or selected from standard theatrical libraries, with upbeat, jaunty melodies during comedic scenes and more dramatic music during tense moments. No specific musical cues or compositions were created for this film. Modern screenings often feature newly composed scores or period-appropriate music to recreate the silent film experience. The absence of synchronized sound meant that Chaplin's comedy relied entirely on visual storytelling and physical performance, a constraint that helped develop his mastery of pantomime and expressive movement.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence where Chaplin's swindler cons the newspaper photographer out of his equipment and money, establishing his character's deceptive nature. The awkward job interview scene where Chaplin tries to maintain his disguise while being questioned by his victim. The climactic chase sequence through the newspaper office as Chaplin's identity is revealed, showcasing early Keystone-style physical comedy.

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of 'Making a Living' were generally positive, though critics noted that Chaplin's performance was still developing. The Moving Picture World praised the film's comedy but did not single out Chaplin for special attention. Variety noted the film's effective use of physical comedy and situational humor. Modern critics and film historians view the film primarily as a historical artifact, appreciating it for its significance as Chaplin's debut rather than its artistic merits. Many scholars note that while Chaplin's performance lacks the subtlety and depth of his later work, it already shows signs of his unique timing and physical comedy skills. The film is often cited in studies of early cinema as an example of how quickly performers could adapt from stage to screen during this transitional period.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1914 responded positively to 'Making a Living,' finding its premise amusing and Chaplin's performance engaging. The film performed well enough to justify continuing Chaplin's contract with Keystone. However, it was Chaplin's second film, 'Kid Auto Races at Venice' (released February 7, 1914), where he first appeared as the Tramp character, that truly captured audience imagination and launched his stardom. Contemporary audience members likely viewed 'Making a Living' as a standard Keystone comedy without recognizing its historical importance. Modern audiences, when viewing the film today, are often struck by seeing Chaplin in an unfamiliar role and appreciate witnessing the very beginning of his legendary career. The film serves as a fascinating glimpse into the origins of a cinematic genius.

You Might Also Like