Seven Keys to Baldpate
"Seven Keys - Seven Mysteries - One Night of Suspense"
Plot
Famous novelist William Magee accepts a challenge from his publisher to write a 10,000-word novel in just 24 hours. To ensure complete seclusion, Magee is given the sole key to Baldpate Inn, a remote mountain resort closed for the winter season. As he settles in to begin his ambitious writing project, his solitude is repeatedly interrupted by a mysterious succession of visitors, each possessing their own key to the supposedly locked inn. Each new arrival brings complications, secrets, and potential dangers, transforming Magee's creative retreat into a night of intrigue and suspense. The novelist soon discovers that nothing at Baldpate Inn is what it seems, and his literary challenge becomes a real-life mystery he must solve to survive.
About the Production
This was one of the first film adaptations of Earl Derr Biggers' popular stage play. The production utilized innovative lighting techniques to create the mysterious atmosphere of the isolated inn. George M. Cohan, a legendary Broadway star, made this rare film appearance, bringing his theatrical charisma to the silent medium. The film was shot during the winter months to authentically capture the desolate, snowbound setting crucial to the story's atmosphere.
Historical Background
The film was released during World War I, a time when American audiences were increasingly turning to movies for entertainment and escape from the grim news from Europe. 1917 was a pivotal year in American cinema, marking the transition from short films to feature-length productions as the industry standard. The United States entered World War I in April 1917, and films like 'Seven Keys to Baldpate' provided audiences with suspenseful entertainment that didn't directly address the war. This period also saw the rise of the star system in Hollywood, with actors like George M. Cohan bringing their established stage fame to the new medium. The film industry was consolidating, with major studios like Paramount (which released this film) beginning to dominate production and distribution.
Why This Film Matters
As one of the earliest examples of the 'locked room' mystery genre in American cinema, 'Seven Keys to Baldpate' helped establish conventions that would influence countless later films. The story's premise of a seemingly secure location being repeatedly breached became a staple of mystery and thriller genres. George M. Cohan's participation represented the growing legitimacy of film as an art form capable of attracting top theatrical talent. The film's success demonstrated that complex, dialogue-heavy plays could be successfully adapted for the silent screen, paving the way for more sophisticated narrative films. The multiple remakes of this story across different decades show its enduring appeal and adaptability to changing cinematic styles and audience expectations.
Making Of
The production faced the unique challenge of adapting a stage play that relied heavily on dialogue for the silent screen. Director Hugh Ford, who had extensive experience in both theater and film, worked closely with the cast to translate the verbal wit and suspense into visual storytelling. George M. Cohan, accustomed to commanding Broadway stages, had to adjust his performance style for the camera's intimate perspective. The inn set was constructed with multiple levels and hiding places to accommodate the film's numerous surprise entrances and exits. The winter scenes were particularly challenging to film, requiring artificial snow and carefully controlled lighting to maintain the isolated atmosphere. The production team worked closely with Earl Derr Biggers to ensure the film captured the essence of his theatrical hit while taking advantage of cinema's unique capabilities.
Visual Style
The cinematography by Harold Rosson utilized innovative lighting techniques to create the mysterious atmosphere of the isolated inn. Rosson employed dramatic shadows and silhouettes to enhance the suspense, particularly in scenes where characters moved through the darkened corridors of the inn. The winter setting was emphasized through careful use of filters and lighting to suggest cold and isolation. Camera work was relatively static, as was typical of the period, but included some tracking shots to follow characters through the inn's multiple rooms and hidden passages. The visual style emphasized contrast between light and dark to reflect the story's themes of revelation and concealment.
Innovations
The film featured innovative set design with the inn constructed as a multi-level environment allowing for complex chase sequences and surprise entrances. The production utilized early forms of matte painting to establish the remote, mountainous setting. The lighting techniques employed to create nighttime and winter effects were considered advanced for the period. The film's editing, particularly in scenes of rising tension as more characters arrive at the inn, demonstrated growing sophistication in narrative pacing. The production also experimented with different camera angles to create visual interest within the confined setting of the inn.
Music
As a silent film, 'Seven Keys to Baldpate' would have been accompanied by live musical performance in theaters. The typical score would have included popular songs of the era, classical pieces, and specially composed mood music to enhance the suspenseful scenes. George M. Cohan's fame as a songwriter may have influenced the inclusion of some of his popular compositions in the musical accompaniment. The music would have been coordinated with cue sheets provided by the studio, indicating which pieces should be played during specific scenes to maximize emotional impact.
Famous Quotes
As this is a silent film, no dialogue quotes survive, but the intertitles likely included lines like: 'The only key to Baldpate - and complete solitude for my novel!'
'Another key? How can this be?'
'In twenty-four hours, I'll have written a masterpiece - or gone mad trying!'
Memorable Scenes
- The opening sequence where Magee receives the supposedly sole key to the inn, establishing the premise that will be repeatedly undermined
- The first surprise arrival of another character with a key, shattering Magee's belief in his isolation
- The climactic scene where multiple characters with keys converge, revealing the true nature of the situation
Did You Know?
- This was the first of seven film adaptations of Earl Derr Biggers' play, with later versions made in 1925, 1929, 1935, 1947, and 1983
- George M. Cohan, who played the lead, was one of Broadway's biggest stars but made very few films during his career
- The story was so popular that it inspired a running gag in The Simpsons where characters repeatedly claim to have 'the only key to Baldpate'
- The original stage play opened on Broadway in 1913 and ran for 322 performances
- Hedda Hopper, who appears in the film, would later become one of Hollywood's most famous gossip columnists
- The film was shot at Fort Lee, New Jersey, which was the center of American film production before Hollywood's dominance
- This adaptation is now considered a lost film, with no known surviving copies in any archive
- The story's premise of a writer under deadline pressure in a remote location became a recurring trope in mystery films
- Earl Derr Biggers wrote the play while staying at a real inn in New Hampshire's White Mountains
- The film's success helped establish the 'locked room' mystery genre in American cinema
What Critics Said
Contemporary critics praised the film for maintaining the suspense and wit of the original stage play despite the challenges of silent adaptation. The Motion Picture News noted that 'George M. Cohan brings his trademark energy to the screen, making the transition from stage to film with remarkable success.' Variety highlighted the film's clever visual storytelling, stating 'Director Hugh Ford has found inventive ways to convey the play's verbal spats and plot twists through pantomime and visual gags.' Modern critics, unfortunately, cannot evaluate the film directly as it is considered lost, though film historians consider it an important early example of the mystery genre and a significant work in Cohan's limited filmography.
What Audiences Thought
The film was well-received by 1917 audiences who were familiar with the popular stage play. George M. Cohan's star power drew significant crowds to theaters, particularly in major cities where his Broadway reputation was well-established. Audiences appreciated the film's suspenseful atmosphere and clever plot twists, which were considered quite sophisticated for the time. The movie's success at the box office helped demonstrate that feature-length mysteries could be commercially viable, encouraging studios to produce more films in this genre. Contemporary newspaper accounts suggest that audiences particularly enjoyed the film's surprise elements and the satisfying resolution of the mystery.
Awards & Recognition
- No major awards were given for this film in 1917, as the first Academy Awards would not be presented until 1929
Film Connections
Influenced By
- Original stage play by Earl Derr Biggers (1913)
- Earlier mystery films like 'The Perils of Pauline' serials
- Contemporary detective fiction
- German Expressionist cinema's emphasis on shadows and atmosphere
This Film Influenced
- The Bat (1926)
- The Cat and the Canary (1927)
- The Old Dark House (1932)
- And Then There Were None (1945)
- The Haunting (1963)
- Clue (1985)
You Might Also Like
Film Restoration
This film is considered LOST. No known copies survive in any film archive or private collection. The Library of Congress, the British Film Institute, and other major archives have confirmed they do not possess any footage of this 1917 version. Only still photographs, reviews, and promotional materials remain to document its existence.