Sherlock Holmes and the Secret Weapon

Plot

Set during World War II, Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson are tasked with protecting Swiss scientist Dr. Franz Tobel, who has invented a revolutionary new bombsight that could change the course of the war. After successfully smuggling Tobel out of Switzerland and away from the Gestapo, Holmes brings him to London where the scientist plans to share his invention with the Allied forces. However, the criminal mastermind Professor Moriarty, working with the Nazis, has other plans and manages to kidnap Tobel, demanding the secrets of the bombsight. Holmes must race against time through a series of clever disguises and deductions to rescue Tobel and prevent Moriarty from delivering the deadly technology to Germany. The film culminates in a dramatic confrontation where Holmes must outwit his arch-nemesis while London faces the threat of Nazi bombing raids.

Historical Background

Made in 1943, during the height of World War II, this film reflects Hollywood's active participation in wartime propaganda and morale-boosting. The decision to update Sherlock Holmes to the contemporary WWII setting was a deliberate choice to make the character relevant to modern audiences and to use his intellectual superiority as a metaphor for Allied superiority over Axis powers. The film's emphasis on protecting scientific innovation from falling into enemy hands mirrored real concerns about technological secrets during the war. This was also during the peak of the Holmes film craze, with Universal having found tremendous success with their modernized Holmes series. The film served as both entertainment and subtle propaganda, reinforcing themes of British-American cooperation against Nazi evil.

Making Of

The production was part of Universal's successful strategy of updating classic literary characters for wartime audiences. Director Roy William Neill, who directed most of the Rathbone-Bruce Holmes films, was known for his efficient shooting style and ability to create atmosphere on limited budgets. Rathbone and Bruce had developed such chemistry in their Holmes roles that they could often complete scenes in single takes. Lionel Atwill's casting as Moriarty was controversial at the time due to his recent legal troubles, but Universal stood by him, and his performance became one of the most memorable interpretations of the character. The film's wartime propaganda elements were carefully crafted to support the Allied cause without being overly heavy-handed, reflecting Hollywood's contribution to the war effort.

Visual Style

The film's cinematography, handled by Universal regular Charles Van Enger, effectively creates a wartime London atmosphere using studio sets and backlot shooting. The lighting employs classic film noir techniques with heavy shadows and high contrast, particularly effective in the suspense sequences. The camera work during the action scenes, particularly the climactic fight on the scaffolding, was more dynamic than typical B-movie fare of the period. Van Enger made excellent use of limited sets to create variety through different camera angles and lighting schemes, giving each location its own distinctive mood while maintaining visual consistency throughout the film.

Innovations

While not a technical innovator, the film demonstrated Universal's expertise in efficient B-movie production. The special effects, particularly the miniature work for the bombsight demonstrations and the explosion sequences, were convincing despite budget limitations. The film's sound design effectively created the illusion of wartime London through carefully layered audio effects. The makeup effects for Holmes's various disguises were particularly noteworthy, allowing Rathbone to create distinct characters without extensive prosthetics. The production design successfully transformed Universal's backlot into wartime London through clever set dressing and matte paintings.

Music

The musical score was composed by Hans J. Salter, one of Universal's most prolific composers. Salter created a distinctive Holmes theme that would recur throughout the series, blending classical elements with more contemporary wartime sounds. The music effectively enhances the suspense sequences and provides appropriate emotional weight to the dramatic moments. Salter also incorporated subtle musical motifs for different characters, with Moriarty's theme using dissonant tones to suggest his villainous nature. The score, while not groundbreaking, was effective and memorable, contributing significantly to the film's atmosphere and pacing.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence where Holmes, disguised as a Nazi officer, rescues Dr. Tobel from the Gestapo at the Swiss border
• The scene where Holmes deduces Moriarty's involvement through a series of seemingly unrelated clues
• The climactic fight scene on the construction scaffolding, where Holmes and Moriarty battle high above London streets
• The sequence where Holmes uses multiple disguises to track Moriarty through London, showcasing Rathbone's versatility
• The tense scene where Holmes must defuse Moriarty's trap while protecting the bombsight plans

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised the film for its entertainment value and wartime relevance, with Variety noting its 'plenty of suspense and action' and The New York Times appreciating Rathbone's 'authoritative' performance. Modern critics view the film as a solid entry in the Rathbone-Bruce series, though some criticize the departure from Conan Doyle's Victorian setting and the comic relief elements. The film is generally regarded as one of the stronger entries in Universal's Holmes series, particularly praised for Lionel Atwill's menacing Moriarty and the effective wartime atmosphere. Film historians often cite it as an example of how Hollywood successfully adapted literary properties for wartime propaganda without sacrificing entertainment value.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by wartime audiences who appreciated its blend of mystery, action, and patriotic themes. Theater audiences responded positively to the clear-cut good versus evil narrative and the satisfying defeat of the Nazi-aligned Moriarty. The film's success at the box office helped ensure the continuation of the Holmes series at Universal. Over the decades, the film has maintained a loyal following among Holmes enthusiasts and classic film fans, with many considering it one of the best of the Rathbone-Bruce entries. The wartime setting, while initially controversial among Holmes purists, has come to be appreciated as a unique and interesting approach to the character.

You Might Also Like