Stella Maris

Plot

Stella Maris is a beautiful, wealthy young woman who has been paralyzed from birth and is confined to a bed or wheelchair. She lives a sheltered, idyllic existence in the home of her wealthy guardians, the Risley family, completely unaware of life's harsh realities and cruelties. Meanwhile, Unity Blake is a poor, orphaned girl who has experienced nothing but hardship and abuse in the harsh world of workhouses and poverty. Both women fall in love with John Risley, the adopted son of Stella's guardians, though he is trapped in a loveless marriage to the cruel Louise. The story explores how John cares for both women while navigating his complicated marital situation, ultimately leading to a dramatic resolution where true love and selflessness triumph over selfishness and cruelty.

Historical Background

Stella Maris was produced during the final year of World War I, a time when American audiences were seeking escapist entertainment and moral clarity in cinema. The film industry was transitioning from short films to feature-length productions, with stars like Mary Pickford becoming powerful independent producers. 1918 was also a year of the devastating Spanish Flu pandemic, which affected film production and theater attendance. The film's themes of innocence versus experience, and its exploration of class differences, reflected America's own social tensions during this period of rapid industrialization and social change. The success of Stella Maris demonstrated the growing sophistication of American cinema and its ability to tackle complex emotional themes, helping establish the United States as the dominant force in global filmmaking.

Making Of

The production of Stella Maris presented unique technical challenges for 1918. To show Mary Pickford as both characters in the same scenes, the cinematographer Walter Stradling employed sophisticated double exposure techniques that were cutting-edge for the era. Pickford had to perform each scene twice, once as Stella and once as Unity, with careful timing and blocking to create the illusion of two different people interacting. The transformation between characters was remarkable - Stella was portrayed with delicate features, light hair, and ethereal costumes, while Unity was made up with darker features, simpler clothing, and a hardened demeanor. The bed-ridden scenes for Stella required specially designed sets and camera angles to maintain the illusion of her paralysis. Director Marshall Neilan worked closely with Pickford to ensure the emotional authenticity of both performances, often shooting scenes out of sequence to accommodate the extensive makeup and costume changes required for the dual role.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Walter Stradling was groundbreaking for its time, particularly in the techniques used to show Mary Pickford's dual role. Stradling employed sophisticated double exposure methods, careful matte work, and innovative camera placement to create convincing scenes featuring both Stella and Unity. The visual contrast between the two characters was emphasized through lighting - Stella was filmed in soft, ethereal light to emphasize her innocence and fragility, while Unity was shot in harsher, more realistic lighting reflecting her rough life. The camera work for Stella's bed-ridden scenes required special setups to maintain the illusion of her paralysis while still allowing dynamic storytelling. The film's visual style, while typical of the romantic melodramas of its era, was elevated by these technical innovations and Stradling's sensitive handling of the emotional material.

Innovations

Stella Maris was technically innovative for its time, primarily in its use of double exposure and split-screen techniques to show Mary Pickford in dual roles. The film employed sophisticated matte painting and in-camera effects that were cutting-edge for 1918. The production team developed new methods for seamless scene transitions between the two characters, requiring precise timing and coordination. The makeup and costume departments created dramatically different looks for each character while maintaining the illusion that they were different people. The film also featured innovative camera techniques for the scenes showing Stella's paralysis, including specially designed camera mounts and angles. These technical achievements were particularly impressive given the limitations of film equipment in 1918 and helped establish new possibilities for narrative filmmaking.

Music

As a silent film, Stella Maris would have been accompanied by live musical performances in theaters. Original scores were typically provided by the theater's organist or pianist, using cue sheets provided by the studio. The score would have featured popular songs of the era, classical pieces, and original compositions tailored to enhance the film's emotional moments. For the Stella Maris scenes, the music would have been light and ethereal, while Unity's scenes would have featured more dramatic, minor-key compositions. Modern restorations of the film have been accompanied by newly composed scores, most notably by musicians like Rodney Sauer and the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra, who have created historically appropriate accompaniments using authentic period instruments and musical styles.

Memorable Scenes

• The first reveal of Mary Pickford in both roles, showing the stark contrast between the ethereal Stella and the hardened Unity
• The scene where Unity first meets Stella and sees the completely different world she lives in
• The emotional climax where both women realize they love the same man and must face this reality
• Stella's scenes in her garden, filmed with soft focus and ethereal lighting to emphasize her innocence
• Unity's transformation from a bitter, abused girl to someone capable of selfless love
• The final resolution where true love and sacrifice triumph over selfishness and cruelty

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics hailed Stella Maris as a masterpiece of silent cinema, with particular praise for Mary Pickford's dual performance. The Moving Picture World called it 'a triumph of the art' and praised Pickford's ability to create two completely distinct characters. The New York Times noted that 'Miss Pickford has never given a finer performance' and highlighted the film's emotional depth. Modern critics continue to appreciate the film's technical achievements and emotional power. Film historian Kevin Brownlow has praised it as 'one of the great achievements of the silent era,' while contemporary reviewers on platforms like Letterboxd and IMDb consistently rate it highly, noting its surprisingly sophisticated themes and Pickford's remarkable performance.

What Audiences Thought

Stella Maris was enormously popular with audiences in 1918, becoming one of the biggest box office hits of the year. The film's emotional story and Pickford's dual performance resonated strongly with wartime audiences seeking meaningful entertainment. Theater owners reported that the film played to packed houses and received standing ovations. The success was particularly notable because it was a dramatic role for Pickford, who was equally known for comedies. Modern audiences who have seen the film through screenings at film festivals or on home video continue to be moved by its emotional power and impressed by Pickford's performance. The film's themes of love, sacrifice, and redemption remain relatable, and its technical achievements continue to impress contemporary viewers familiar with modern special effects.

You Might Also Like