Sugar Daddies

Plot

Wealthy oil tycoon Cyrus Brittle (James Finlayson) awakens after a wild night of partying with a massive hangover and a wedding ring on his finger. To his horror, he discovers he has married a gold-digging woman named Ethel (Charlotte Mineau) during his drunken revelry. Desperate to escape the unwanted marriage, Cyrus calls upon his lawyers, played by the bumbling duo of Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy, to arrange a quick annulment. The incompetent attorneys attempt various schemes to separate the couple, leading to a series of comedic misadventures and misunderstandings. Their efforts culminate in a chaotic courtroom scene where their legal incompetence is on full display. The film ends with the lawyers somehow managing to resolve the situation through sheer luck rather than skill, preserving Cyrus's fortune and freedom.

Historical Background

The year 1927 marked a transformative period in American cinema history, occurring just before the industry-wide transition to sound films that would begin with 'The Jazz Singer' later that year. 'Sugar Daddies' was produced during the height of the Roaring Twenties, a period of economic prosperity and social change in America that saw the rise of consumer culture and changing attitudes toward relationships and marriage. The film's theme of a wealthy man being trapped in an unwanted marriage reflected contemporary anxieties about gold diggers and the potential pitfalls of newfound wealth during this era. The comedy short format was still the dominant form of cinematic entertainment, with theaters typically showing several shorts before the main feature. Hal Roach Studios was one of the most successful comedy production companies of the period, competing with Mack Sennett and other comedy producers for audiences. The film also came out during Prohibition, which may have influenced the plot's focus on drunken revelry and its consequences.

Making Of

The making of 'Sugar Daddies' occurred during a pivotal time at Hal Roach Studios when producers were still experimenting with the chemistry between different comedians. Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy had appeared together in several films before this, but the studio hadn't yet committed to them as an official team. Director Fred Guiol, who worked extensively with both comedians individually, recognized their complementary comedy styles and pushed for more collaborations. The filming took place at the Hal Roach Studios lot in Culver City, where the production team built an elaborate courtroom set that would be reused in subsequent productions. James Finlayson, a Scottish actor known for his distinctive mustache and explosive temper, was brought in to play the wealthy tycoon, a role he would perfect in later Laurel and Hardy films. The production faced the typical challenges of silent film era shooting, including the need for exaggerated physical comedy and clear visual storytelling without dialogue. The cast and crew worked long days to complete filming within the tight schedule typical of short film productions, often shooting multiple scenes in a single day.

Visual Style

The cinematography in 'Sugar Daddies' was handled by Hal Roach Studios regular cinematographers, employing the standard techniques of silent film era comedy. The visual style emphasized clarity and composition to ensure the physical comedy would be easily understood by audiences without dialogue. The camera work typically used medium shots to capture the full range of physical movement while allowing for facial expressions to be visible. The courtroom scenes utilized wider shots to establish the setting before moving to closer shots for reactions and comedic beats. The film employed the typical lighting techniques of the period, with bright, even illumination to ensure clear visibility of the action. The cinematography supported the comedy by maintaining visual continuity during physical gags and ensuring that the cause-and-effect relationships in the humor were visually clear to the audience.

Innovations

While 'Sugar Daddies' did not introduce groundbreaking technical innovations, it demonstrated the mastery of established silent film techniques by the Hal Roach Studios production team. The film's editing effectively paced the comedy, allowing physical gags to land properly while maintaining narrative momentum. The production utilized the studio's established lighting and camera setups efficiently, creating a polished final product within the constraints of a short film budget and schedule. The intertitles were well-crafted to provide necessary exposition and dialogue while maintaining the film's comedic tone. The film also demonstrated effective use of props and set design to support the comedy, particularly in the courtroom scenes where the physical environment contributed to the humor. The synchronization of action between multiple performers in complex scenes showed the technical proficiency of both the cast and crew in executing coordinated comedic sequences.

Music

As a silent film, 'Sugar Daddies' did not have an original synchronized soundtrack. During its initial theatrical run, the film would have been accompanied by live musical performances typical of the era, usually a piano or organ player in smaller theaters and a small orchestra in larger venues. The musical accompaniment would have been selected from standard compilations of mood music that theaters maintained, with selections matched to the on-screen action and emotional tone. For dramatic moments, slower, more somber pieces would be used, while the comedy sequences would be accompanied by upbeat, playful music. Modern restorations and screenings of the film typically feature newly composed scores or carefully selected period-appropriate music to recreate the silent film experience for contemporary audiences. Some versions have featured scores by silent film accompanists like Robert Israel or Ben Model, who specialize in creating authentic-sounding accompaniments for silent comedies.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence where James Finlayson's character awakens with a massive hangover, gradually discovering his predicament through a series of shocking revelations about his wedding ring and new wife.
• The chaotic initial meeting between the wealthy client and his bumbling lawyers, where Laurel and Hardy demonstrate their incompetence from the moment they enter the room.
• The elaborate attempt to stage a compromising situation to grounds for annulment, which backfires spectacularly and creates even more complications.
• The climactic courtroom scene where legal procedures are completely subverted by physical comedy, with witnesses being knocked around and evidence being destroyed through slapstick mishaps.
• The final resolution sequence where the lawyers accidentally stumble upon the perfect solution to their client's problem through sheer luck rather than legal skill.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception for 'Sugar Daddies' was generally positive, with trade publications like Variety and Motion Picture News praising the film's comedic timing and the chemistry between the performers. The Motion Picture World noted that 'the combination of Laurel and Hardy continues to prove successful, with their bumbling legal antics providing consistent laughs.' Modern critics and film historians view the film as an important stepping stone in the development of the Laurel and Hardy partnership, though it's not considered among their finest works. The Laurel and Hardy appreciation community generally regards it as an entertaining early effort that showcases the duo's potential even before they were officially paired as a team. Film historian Randy Skretvedt has noted that the film 'demonstrates the complementary skills that would make Laurel and Hardy one of cinema's greatest comedy teams, even if the material doesn't quite reach the heights of their later masterpieces.'

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1927 responded positively to 'Sugar Daddies,' with the film proving popular in theaters across the United States. The combination of physical comedy and relatable themes about marriage and money resonated with moviegoers of the era. The film's success helped convince Hal Roach Studios to continue experimenting with pairing Laurel and Hardy in future productions. Modern audiences, particularly fans of silent comedy and classic film, continue to enjoy the film as an example of early Laurel and Hardy work. The film is frequently screened at silent film festivals and classic cinema events, where it receives appreciative responses from contemporary viewers. Online forums and Laurel and Hardy fan communities often discuss the film as an essential viewing for understanding the development of the comedy duo's partnership.

You Might Also Like