The Circus

Plot

The Tramp (Charlie Chaplin) stumbles upon a circus where he's mistaken for a prop, accidentally becoming the star attraction through his hilarious mishaps. He falls deeply in love with Merna (Merna Kennedy), the circus owner's abused stepdaughter, but she only has eyes for Rex, the handsome tightrope walker. Despite becoming the show's biggest draw, The Tramp remains an outsider who can never win the girl's affection. In a bittersweet finale, after helping Rex and Merna escape together, The Tramp is left alone to wander the roads once more, accepting his role as eternal entertainer but never participant in life's joys.

Historical Background

The Circus was produced during a pivotal transitional period in cinema history, released just as the sound era was beginning to revolutionize filmmaking. In 1927, 'The Jazz Singer' had introduced synchronized dialogue, and by 1928, Hollywood studios were rapidly converting to sound production. Chaplin, deeply committed to the art of silent cinema and his Tramp character, deliberately chose to make The Circus as a silent film despite the industry's shift. The film reflects the anxieties of the late 1920s, a period of economic boom followed by the 1929 stock market crash. The circus setting itself was particularly resonant in an era when circuses were still major cultural attractions, representing both American entertainment and the spectacle of modern life. The film's themes of alienation and the outsider's perspective also reflected Chaplin's own increasing isolation from mainstream Hollywood and his status as an independent artist in an increasingly corporate industry.

Making Of

The production of The Circus became legendary for its difficulties, beginning with Chaplin's contentious divorce from Lita Grey, who had been his second wife and the female lead in his previous film. The divorce proceedings became a public scandal, with Grey's lawyers attempting to seize Chaplin's assets and film footage. During filming, a mysterious fire destroyed Chaplin's studio, wiping out completed sets and expensive footage. Chaplin suffered a nervous breakdown during production and had to take a three-month break to recover. The tightrope sequence proved particularly challenging, requiring extensive planning and multiple takes. Chaplin, a perfectionist, reportedly reshot entire sequences months after principal photography, convinced he could improve them. The film's troubled production coincided with Chaplin's increasing creative isolation and his growing obsession with artistic control, foreshadowing the even more difficult production of his next film, 'City Lights'.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Roland Totheroh and Gordon Pollock represents some of the most sophisticated visual work in silent comedy. The circus setting allowed for complex compositions using depth and multiple planes of action, with Chaplin often creating visual gags that play with foreground and background. The tightrope sequence features innovative camera angles that emphasize both the danger and comedy of the situation. The film uses tracking shots and camera movement more extensively than Chaplin's earlier works, particularly in circus performance sequences. The lighting design creates dramatic contrasts between the bright world of the circus performance and the darker, more intimate moments backstage. The cinematography masterfully balances the spectacle of the circus with the intimate emotional moments, using visual techniques to enhance both comedy and pathos.

Innovations

The Circus pioneered several technical innovations in comedy filmmaking, particularly in its complex circus sequences. The film's use of real circus performers and animals created unprecedented authenticity but also required innovative safety measures and camera techniques. The tightrope sequence required special camera rigs and careful timing to capture both the comedy and the apparent danger. Chaplin developed new techniques for filming in confined spaces, particularly in the mirror maze sequence where he had to avoid showing cameras and crew in reflections. The film's elaborate production design, including a full-scale circus big top, represented a significant technical achievement for its time. The editing by Chaplin and Harry Carr demonstrates sophisticated comic timing, particularly in sequences where The Tramp's mishaps must be precisely synchronized with the circus performance.

Music

Originally released as a silent film with musical accompaniment provided by theaters, The Circus received its first official score when Chaplin re-released it in 1969. Chaplin composed this score himself, creating themes for the main characters and using music to emphasize emotional moments. The 1969 version also included Chaplin's narration, which he recorded at age 80, providing commentary on the action and filling in details that intertitles had originally conveyed. The original musical accompaniment would have varied by theater, but typically included popular songs of the era and classical pieces adapted for circus scenes. Chaplin's later score draws on his characteristic style of simple, memorable melodies that enhance both comedy and emotion, using leitmotifs for characters and situations throughout the film.

Memorable Scenes

• The Tramp accidentally becoming the star of the show when his attempts to escape a pursuing policeman create hilarious chaos during a performance
• The famous tightrope sequence where The Tramp, suspended by a harness, performs a comedy routine while monkeys crawl all over him
• The mirror maze scene where The Tramp encounters multiple reflections of himself, creating surreal visual comedy
• The emotional finale where The Tramp watches Merna and Rex ride away together, then walks alone down the road, kicking a stone in classic Chaplin fashion
• The lion's cage sequence where The Tramp is trapped with a sleeping lion, creating tension through minimal movement and timing
• The opening scene where The Tramp, fleeing the law, stumbles into a circus tent and inadvertently becomes part of the show

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised The Circus as Chaplin's funniest film, with Variety declaring it 'a laugh riot from start to finish' and The New York Times calling it 'the most amusing picture of the year'. Critics particularly noted Chaplin's ability to blend comedy with genuine emotion, a hallmark of his mature work. However, some critics felt it lacked the social commentary of 'The Gold Rush' or the emotional depth of his earlier features. Modern critics reappraise The Circus as a transitional work in Chaplin's career, bridging his earlier pure comedies with the more emotionally complex films that would follow. The film is now recognized as a technical masterpiece, with its complex circus sequences and innovative use of space. Critics today appreciate its bittersweet tone and its role as both a culmination of silent comedy and a meditation on the nature of entertainment itself.

What Audiences Thought

The Circus was a tremendous commercial success, becoming one of the highest-grossing films of 1928 and proving that audiences would still embrace silent comedy even as sound films were gaining popularity. Audiences particularly loved the elaborate circus sequences and Chaplin's increasingly sophisticated blend of comedy and pathos. The film's success was global, with Chaplin's international appeal stronger than ever. However, its release timing meant it was somewhat overshadowed by the excitement surrounding early sound films, and it didn't achieve the same legendary status as 'The Gold Rush' or later Chaplin films. Modern audiences rediscovered The Circus through revivals and home video, where it's appreciated as both a hilarious comedy and a poignant commentary on the nature of entertainment and loneliness.

You Might Also Like